IU x Suga's Eight vs Younha x RM's Winter Flower: Which BTS member collaboration is your favourite? VOTE NOW

IU and Suga's collab, Eight, finally released yesterday and is ruling the music charts all around the world, similar to the success of Younha and RM's collab, Winter Flower. Vote for your favourite BTS member collaboration below.
Both Eight and Winter Flower have achieved the #1 spot on the US iTunes Chart.Both Eight and Winter Flower have achieved the #1 spot on the US iTunes Chart.
  • 25
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • Share on whatsapp

The one thing admirable, besides the many, many more things, about BTS is the fact that not only do ARMY get to see their collective musical talent but their individual charms as well. While we have countless BTS songs to obsess over, many times, we see the members delve into solo work and collaborations with other artists as well. Whether it be RM, Suga and J-Hope releasing their own mixtapes or even collaborating with the likes of Halsey, Lauv and Steve Aoki.

Recently, Suga collaborated with IU for a song titled Eight, the music video of which was unveilled yesterday for the world to consume. Given how IU and Yoongi are of the same age, 28, the song is nothing short of a heartbreaking tune about how "forever is a sandcastle." In what Namjoon referred to as a drive song, we see IU's powerful vocal take center stage with a brief but effective rap verse by Suga, who has also co-produced and co-written Eight.

ALSO READ: Eight: IU x Suga successfully topple Megan Thee Stallion and Beyonce to claim the top spot on US iTunes Chart

Breaking chart records all around the world, Eight earned both IU and Suga their first solo #1 spot on the US iTunes Chart, defeating Megan Thee Stallion and Beyonce's Savage Remix.

On the other hand, another BTS member collaboration that was a huge hit amongst fans was Younha and RM's Winter Flower. The collab sheds light on mental health and gives a realistic point of view of what endeavours while in a contradictory state of mind. Moreover, Namjoon helped co-write the gorgeous lyrics of Winter Flower, which has lyrics like, "They say life is full of paradox. All you gotta do is gettin' used to this marathon." Just like Eight, Winter Flower too secured the #1 spot on the US iTunes Chart trumping Justin Bieber's Yummy.

ALSO READ: Winter Flower: Younha, BTS' RM shed light on mental health; trump Justin Bieber's Yummy to top US iTunes chart

For Younha, in particular, the singer became the first female Korean soloist to achieve the top spot on the US iTunes Chart with Winter Flower, with IU following suit with Eight.

This begs the question; which BTS member collaboration is your favourite - Eight or Winter Flower? Vote below and even let us know your pick in the comments section below.

 
Anonymous 3 months ago

I prefer Winter Flower more, I really like Younha’s vocals! Also do NOT call me a FAKE army because I do NOT stan BTS, I only stan IU and Younha.

Anonymous 4 months ago

Both the song are best but I like more eight it touched my heart I just love it but I also love winter flower

Anonymous 4 months ago

Bot songs are amazing they deliver similar but very different messages Winter flower gives you strength to hold on no matter what you are going through while eight tells you it's okay to sometimes look back at your past and to say u now what I've been there I've gone through that that means I can also go through this. You have to hold on no matter what coz everyone is doing the same you can get through this coz you've gone through it amazing isn't it

Anonymous 5 months ago

Both songs are great you should not have to pick

Anonymous 5 months ago

Both songs are really beautiful with great message of hope in each of them, but this time I choose Younha and Namjoon's Winter Flower. This song touched my heart the most. This is just my opinion

Anonymous 5 months ago

Winter Flower is better. Why better ? Because Younha and Namjoon planned this collab since 5 years ago, Namjoon is her loyal fanboy while younha is legendary in south korea way before IU, Younha also better in vocal and overall singing ability. well this is just my opinion.

Anonymous 5 months ago

I love Eight

Anonymous 5 months ago

By my opinion both the songs are heart touching omg what u guys eat for ur lunch man

Anonymous 5 months ago

If ur a real army you won't choose because both are amazing and all four artists are super talented and deserve respect and love for what they do. They should not be compared as they are both brilliant songs with amazing melodies raps and singing. Periodt.

Anonymous 5 months ago

The meaning of both songs are beautiful but I love winter flower more..

Anonymous 5 months ago

I was deeply touched by "Eight"s message and listen to it on repeat because the melody and beat are so addictive.

Anonymous 5 months ago

"Eight" is better.

Anonymous 5 months ago

I love IUxSUGA more but I think ppl will choose RM because he is the leader and they feel obliged to say his collab is better.

Anonymous 5 months ago

I doubt that is the reason people picked or will pick winter flower. That song is a masterpiece, honestly they are both masterpiece.However my cup of tea leans more towards winter flower

Anonymous 5 months ago

Your logic is really dumb

Anonymous 5 months ago

That's kinda sounds like ur trying to impose ur opinion on everyone else and no one feels obliged to like any of the members songs well I personally like both equally and if u can't appreciate rm's talent then don't downplay it by saying people feel obliged just say u don't like him very much

Anonymous 5 months ago

I prefer Eigth. Winter Flower was not my taste.

Anonymous 5 months ago

Love both but .. I love winter flower more

Anonymous 5 months ago

btssssss!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Anonymous 5 months ago

none.. I prefer Respect.. and that's it. PERIOD!

Anonymous 5 months ago

If u r an army u won't choose 1 out of these masterpieces and its not right to compare the songs when IU and Suga just released their song stop creating rivalries into the fandom

Anonymous 5 months ago

You are right

Anonymous 5 months ago

Both are amazing songs...but I prefer eight iu nd suga ..

Anonymous 5 months ago

Both are beautiful but I support Younha and RM's Winter flower.

Anonymous 5 months ago

I didn't watch winter flower. But 8 is not beautiful enough. But a little.

Pinkvilla has updated its Privacy and Cookie policy. We use cookies to improve your experience on our site and show you Personalized advertisement.

Options

Pinkvilla has updated its Privacy and Cookie policy. We use cookies to improve your experience on our site and show you Personalized advertisement