From eyeliners to mascaras, we’ve tried every beauty arsenal to get bold and defined eyes. But many times, we ignore eyebrows and just focus on eye makeup. Though eyeliners and mascaras give an alluring appeal, still you'll feel something missing in your overall look. And that missing element can easily be achieved with the best eyebrow pencil. Eyebrows are a structural frame of your face that balances your facial features and defines your appearance. 

Since eyebrow enhancement can help define your features, some of us may want to use eyebrow pencils regularly. Talking about the daily use of eyebrow pencils, our contributor Maya Adivi, a certified makeup artist, says, “As long as you remove your makeup at the end of the day, wearing an eyebrow pencil on a daily basis is perfectly safe for the eyes and skin.”

Sparse or patched brows ruin your charm. But, properly grooming them will reduce your effort to beautify your eyes. No matter what, eye pencils are makeup staples that you must use, especially if you have thin brows. They will fill in sparse and shape your brows perfectly. Based on our observation, we've found the top 16 best brow pencils that promise the naturally voluminous look you have been craving for. 

Scroll below and choose what suits you the best. 

• 1
  Best Overall

  Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil

  Buy on Amazon

The Maybelline Total Temptation pencil is best suited for beginners who prefer a professional-like brow finish. It not only defines brows perfectly but also shades them for a more dramatic look. You can blend it with an eyebrow spoolie brush to have soft and natural-looking brows. Besides, the pencil features a tear drop tip for suitably outlining the brows, shaping them, and filling the gaps. Further, the pigment is waterproof meaning you can appreciate a long-lasting and smudge-free appearance all day. 

2

Clinically Tested

L'Oréal Paris Makeup Brow Definer

Buy on Amazon

This tool by L'Oréal Paris is like your brow stylist at home. The pencil has an ultrafine tip that runs smoothly onto the tiny brow hairs like a crayon. Available in soft black color and natural finish, this eye definer works like magic. It refills the voids and styles your brows like your favorite celebrities. Not just that it's an ideal piece for everyone even for those with sensitive eyes. Since it's ophthalmologically tested, you don't need to worry about its safety.

3

Best for Daily Use

Bodermincer Eyebrow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

Most women love experimenting with different shades and colors. And if you're one of the cult members, this Bodermincer Eyebrow Pencil would be the right pick. The pencil comes in 5 classic colors; black, dark brown, light brown, medium brown, and gray, so you can try different options and see what suits the best. Moreover, it has a matte finish that makes your brow shiny and glamorous. It's the best pencil for everyday use. So whether you're going office or planning for a night out, don't forget to add this to your handbag.

4

Best Smudge-proof

theBalm Cosmetics Furrowcious Eyebrow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

Tame unruly brows and get stunning eyebrows with the eyebrow pencil by theBalm Cosmetics. It comes with a slim retractable tip that makes it highly simple to use. Just short, light strokes are enough to define your arches and get the look you desire. Its spoolie brush comes in handy to make the blending experience easier for you. Plus, you don’t have to worry about ruining the makeup look as this has a smudge-proof formula that lasts for a long time. 

5

Wet n Wild Ultimate Eyebrow Definer

Buy on Amazon

The Wet n Wild Ultimate Eyebrow Definer is the most affordable piece on our list. It's a 2-in-1 designer product featuring a brow pencil and a fine brush. This is an ideal combination that provides your brows with a perfect arch. The pencil tones and highlights your fine hair while the spoolie shapes it. Further, it features a triangular pencil tip that creates the finest strokes with rub-resistant pigments for long-lasting effects. The tip is retractable, so when you're done it seamlessly retracts for easy storage in your makeup kit. 

6

Best Drugstore Pencil

Rimmel Brow This Way Professional Eyebrow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

Rimmel eyebrow pencil is a buildable coverage formula that lets you make your desired looks with utmost ease. It's one of the best drugstore eyebrow pencils you must add to your beauty routine. Suitable for all skin types, the double-ended pencil refines your brow shape and increases depth. You can either fill the gaps or lengthen the arc as per your needs in just a few seconds. No need to wait long for a stylist. Just hold the pencil, glide it smoothly, and that's it. You're now ready to flaunt.

7

Hypoallergenic

COVERGIRL Easy Breezy Brow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

When we need the best eyebrow pencil, it's always better to find a blendable one. The Covergirl eye definer blends colors with its built-in spoolie for providing a balanced look. It consists of a micro-fine tip that works well on your brows and reduces sparse. The tip is already sharp, so you don’t have to use a sharpener every now and then to adjust it. Besides, it’s made of a hypoallergenic formula that doesn’t cause irritation or any other eye problem. This means it’s 100% safe to use.

8

Smudge-proof

Benefit Precisely My Brow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

This brow pencil is made for those ladies who want flawless brows from morning to night. With a staying time of up to 12 hours, this Benefit's creation is your best companion that deserves a place in your makeup drawer. A single application brings symmetry to your brows and transforms your face completely. This ultra-rich, waterproof pencil is ideal for drawing natural-like hair strokes to your tweezed areas. Based on our observation, the pencil effectively deepens the brows and covers empty spots.

9

Scientific Formulation

IT Cosmetics Brow Power Eyebrow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

IT's brow pencil is a scientific formula crafted with biotin that adds a bit of flare to your brows while protecting your skin. It provides polished finished brows just like Dua Lipa's brows. Further, it features an oval tip that resembles the appearance of natural hair strands. Each glide ensures deep spot filling depending on the pressure applied. The harder you press, the deeper the pigmentation will be. And yes, the color won't fade easily. All credit goes to its budge-proof feature.

10

For Perfect Matte Finish

Anastasia Beverly Hills - Perfect Brow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

The Anastasia eyebrow pencil is more than just a wooden brow highlighter. It provides you maximum control while defining brows. What's great about this product is- it possesses a customized spoolie that enables color blending for a vivid matte finish. Besides, the pencil tip can be sharpened to point for more deep and precise sparse filling. After putting it to test, we discovered that it provides better results when the tip was applied at its side. Also, you can pair it with brow gels to put a pinch of shimmer for glossy brows.

11

Sustainable

Udream Eyebrow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

Achieve instant-shaped brows with Udream's eyebrow pencil. The pencil has a 4-point tip that quickly adjusts your brows in a blink. If you're in a hurry but don't want to give up on perfect brows, try using this. The tip glides smoothly like melted cheese leaving behind lucid and gleaming brows. The liquid eyebrow pencil is a waterproof formula that avoids smudging and budging even on the hottest day. Unlike most pencils that are made of plastics, this one is crafted from high-quality materials to ensure long-time use. 

12

Music Flower Eyebrow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

This pencil by Music Flower gives special care to your eyebrows. It helps you enhance your appearance and lights up your face by symmetrizing your brows. The pen not only draws brows easily but also fills hairlines for a natural and matte finish. Filled with a stainless liquid formula, the pencil gives you the most subtle brow look that never vanishes due to water or sweat. No matter whether you're traveling on a hot day or exploring the countryside, this product will make sure that you appreciate flawless brows anywhere anytime.

13

Chella Brown Eyebrow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

With zero harsh ingredients, this cute pink Chella eyebrow pencil provides fuller and fluffier brows instantly. It's composed of clean ingredients and pigments that sit well on your fine brow hair and add extra volume. Moreover, it's waterproof and budge-proof wear with maximum staying power. To use this pencil, you don't need much experience, even a novice can apply. It's just a 3-step process; fill in gaps, define, and highlight. As indicated by our tests, the product helps avoid messy applications and delivers a clean and alluring look.

14

JOAH Brow Down To Me Dual Brow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

The JOAH brow pencil is one of a kind beauty staple that is multifaceted. It's an ultimate combo of a pencil and gel you can't resist. The pencil's triangular tip bridges spaces with utmost precision, while the gel volumizes brows, intensifies hair color, and helps you get rid of grays. The duo keeps brows intact and avoids scattering. Besides, it includes a soft spoolie brush for easy application. In addition, it's a lightweight formulation that doesn't feels heavy and sticky on the area. 

15

Go Ho Brown Eyebrow Eyeliner Pencils

Buy on Amazon

For those who need great yet low-cost brow pencils, this is the best deal for them. The Go Ho eyebrow pencils are multi-functional that work as a brow highlighter and eyeliner. This means you can use them on your brows along with on your lashes. Don't worry they aren't harsh on the surface and run well. Not just that the pencils are quick drying, and the colors don't peel off. Furthermore, the pens are available in a set of 12 pieces at a cheap price, so now you don't have rob a bank to get your fav looks.

16

PYT Beauty Defining Eyebrow Pencil

Buy on Amazon

Nothing could be better than a brow pencil that gives 3 finishes in 1. This might have blown your mind, but that's true. The PYT Beauty pencil provides you polished, natural, and matte finish in just a single application. It is fully retractable and sculpts your face precisely with its ultrasoft tip and brush. Also, it has a hidden sharpener if you prefer ultra-precise brows. The most interesting part is the body of the pen is made with 47% recyclable plastic as the brand believes in sustainability. Overall, it's a complete treatment for your sparse and thin eyebrows. 

We hope you've found our recommendations for the best eyebrow pencils useful. Now let's proceed further and see how you can choose a brow pencil.

Here are the factors you must know before adding an eyebrow pencil to your cart:

Ingredients: Your eyebrow pencil should have ingredients that are highly pigmented and also enhance hair growth like organic coconut oil, castor oil, shea butter and Vitamin E.Other organic ingredients that you should look out for is aloe vera gel, raw honey, Rhassoul red clay among many others. As per our contributor Maya Adivi, eyebrow pencils, like all other makeup products should contain skin-friendly ingredients. She adds, “Natural waxes are excellent in an eyebrow pencil since they ensure the produce will glide on the skin easily and will be waterproof.”

Hair color 

Now you may be thinking about how hair color fixes into the context, but let us tell you that the color of your eyebrows is almost the same as the natural color of your hair. If you've ever used a brow pencil earlier, you may have noticed that even the slightest change in color intensity can make or break your look. If you use a shade lighter or darker than your natural hair color, your brows will look fake. So choose one that aligns with your hair color. 

Color depth 

Make sure that your eyebrows neither get suppressed nor overpower your facial features. They should be accurately colored and have balanced color intensity i.e., neither too dark nor too light. 

Consumer reviews

Check the customer ratings and reviews before making a purchasing decision. This will allow you to gather more details about the product. 

Conclusion 

Your eyebrows need as much attention as you give styling your eyes. If glamorous eyes can make you appear attractive, well-maintained brows complete and amplify your overall look. Both go hand in hand to perfectly sculpt your face. Sparse and bald spots on your brows hide your natural beauty. Hence, you should use the best eyebrow pencils to add life to your brows. They put in natural-like volume and texture just like a pro. Also, they provide intense pigmentation, bridge gaps, and shape your brows. No matter what look you want, eyebrow pencils will surely fulfill your dream to look wow everywhere you go.

Contributor: Maya Adivi, Certified Makeup artist, Click here for blog