If you have oily skin, you must already be familiar with skin-specific makeup products. But, if you still haven't stumbled upon the best mascaras for oily skin, we're happy to help. Contrary to popular belief, when it comes to makeup, one size does not fit all. No-makeup look, red-carpet look, or just a bare-faced look—whatever look you're going for, it's incomplete without the swoosh of a smudge-proof mascara. And a wrong mascara is akin to a direct ticket to raccoon eyes, so it's important to find a mascara that suits your skin type and also delivers on your needs—volume, length, or drama.

The dramatic magic these tiny wands cast upon your lashes is like the cherry on your sundae or the icing on the cake, and we don't want you to miss out on having that wonderful feeling. To channel your inner diva and make sure that you don't stand in the makeup aisle, overwhelmed by the numerous options in mascaras and brands, we have curated a list with the best smudge-proof mascaras for oily skin.

• 1
  Editor’s Pick

  Yves Saint Laurent Lash Clash Extreme Volume Mascara

  BUY ON AMAZON
  BUY ON SEPHORA

The above-mentioned mascara by Yves Saint Laurent is one of the rarest ones for oily skin that comes with an oversized brush to ensure smooth and uniform delivery of the product throughout the lash layers. Well, there's more to it, this volumizing mascara also provides an intense uplifted look to flimsy lashes hence, eliminating the need for fake eyelash attachments. Moreover, the product has a robust, non-smudgy tear and sweat-proof formulation which makes it a loved choice among modern-day women. The best part is that you will not need an additional eyelash curler to shape to your lashes as the ergonomically designed applicator tip provides a high-definition curl with its soft and strong bristles without causing any visible specks. 

2

Best Overall for Oily Skin

Estee Lauder Double Wear

Buy on Amazon

Estee Lauder is reputed to produce top-notch makeup and skincare products. This mascara by Estee Lauder lives up to its fame as one of the best makeup brands. It is one of the best mascaras available for oily skin. You need to get your hands on this mascara to give your eyes the desired pop, regardless of whether the temperature is hot and muggy or you are dripping with sweat. It lengthens and defines your lashes while keeping them clump-free all day. This mascara brush's microfiber bristles make its application more manageable and keep the lashes untangled for a flawless appearance.

3

Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Maybelline's Lash Sensational mascara helps in creating looks that define eyes, regardless of your signature eye style. Natural or dramatic, this mascara guarantees the precision you need to style your eyes. The lashes quickly transform into a fanned, elongated, and long set of beauty. This cult-favorite mascara infused with conditioning Rose Hip oil and mineral pigments gives its users thick lashes that never feel heavy. The ten-layered fanning mascara brush adds humungous volume to the eyelashes giving them a beautiful look, without clumps or flakes.

4

Best Lightweight Consistency

Perricone MD No Makeup Mascara

BUY ON AMAZON

Beautiful eye makeup can elevate your overall appearance. And the Perricone MD No Makeup Mascara does exactly that without hurting your eyes. This 2-in-1 lash treatment and mascara comes with a double-sided brush to help you apply the product precisely and evenly without any hassle. Plus, it is added with biotin, avocado oil, and tocotrienols to strengthen, nourish, and smoothen eyelashes. To add on, a blend of these ingredients also boosts lash growth and helps you achieve thicker and stronger eyelashes that won’t pluck easily. Lift your eyelashes and uplift your spirits with this amazing mascara, built to make your eyelashes healthier.

5

Best Gluten-free

Blinc Amplified Tubing Mascara

BUY ON AMAZON

Liven up your spirits and get bold and beautiful eye makeup looks with the splendid mascara by Blinc. It has a super duper buildable formula that adds definition, volume, and length to the eyelashes in one coat. It gives a beautiful shiny, glossy, and voluminizing appearance to the eyelashes, making you grab all the attention wherever you go. Plus, you need not worry about adding a layer of coats as its formula allows you to add as many coats as you want till you get the look you desire. The best part is that it is easy to apply and remove. 

6

Eyeko Beach Waterproof Mascara

BUY ON AMAZON

This waterproof Eyeko mascara should definitely make it to your makeup bag if you need mascara that can sustain any weather. It does not just keep your lashes look beautifully defined with deep pigment but also holds shape, and does not fade even if you take a dip in the pool. For our vegan friends, this mascara fits your bill of vegan-friendly and cruelty-free ingredients. It is super long-lasting and is best for special occasions. It may take time to patiently get this mascara off as it is difficult to remove.

7

Beauty Bakerie Huge Extreme Lash Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Beauty Bakerie has the cutest products for makeup queens who love all things big and grand. This mascara is certainly a unique one as it provides extreme lash lift and mega volume with just one swipe. It can also be layered without looking or feeling bulky. It is simple to seize each lash because the curved brush closely resembles the shape of the eye. It has bristles that are crimped and hug every lash, covering it completely.

8

Best Volume Building

Grande Mascara Conditioning Peptide Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Grande Mascara Conditioning Peptide Mascara hits two birds with one stone. It conditions your lashes while you build the mascara on them to make it look dramatically huge and long. The Grande Mascara is full of peptides, natural waxes, and panthenols that keep your eyelashes safe and nourished. The combination of soft and hard bristles on the mascara brush help in giving the lashes a lifted look. While applying the mascara, sweep the brush upward from the base of the lashes to the tips. If you wish to give your lashes more volume, apply multiple coats. After you’re done flaunting the mascara and are ready to retire for the day, gently wash it with cleanser or remove it with wipes.

9

Best for Fragile Lashes

MILK MAKEUP KUSH High Volumizing Mascara

BUY ON SEPHORA

When the Milk Makeup volumizing mascara is a part of your vanity, the risk of fallout, transfer, and smudging is negligible. To note more, the mascara contains a blend of natural ingredients that not just elevate hydration levels within the lashes but also prevent the lashes from getting rigid and glued to one another. The best part? The product does not carry any covet skin allergens and is purely made with skin-compatible ingredients after innumerable attempts of trials and testing. Need more reasons? It not just accentuates lash curls and strengthens fragile lashes but also prevents premature shedding and lash follicle fractures by boosting the supply of nutrition to the lash tips. 

10

Best for Dry Skin

ANASTASIA BEVERLY HILLS Jet-Black Volumizing Mascara

BUY ON SEPHORA

The Anastasia Beverly Hills volumizing mascara for oily skin dries within the blink of an eye and is hence loved by beginners and beauty aficionados alike. To add on, the product comes with a unique lightweight gel-based formulation that glides on easily without causing any caking, smudging, or melting. What’s more is that it comes with an hourglass-shaped sturdy applicator that separates each strand of hair and assures highly pigmented coverage lasting up to a considerable period. Thus, if you wish to have voluptuous-looking lashes without any messy and complex DIY homemade remedies, this product is your savior. 

11

Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara

Buy on Amazon

The Heroine Make Long and Curl Masacra will complete your anime obsession because it is deeply inspired by Japanese culture. This mascara provides the lashes with much-needed nourishment because it is packed with natural extracts like camellia oil, argan oil, and royal jelly extract. With this smudge-proof mascara, even those with thin and small lashes can keep them curled up for long hours. Heroine Make mascara is formulated to withstand tears, sweat, and grease, so wear the mascara and go watch a chick flick or play a game of basketball, your lashes will still look fleek.

12

Best Pigmented

Secret Xpress Control 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Secret Xpress Control 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara can be used by everyone. This lovely soft mascara is hypoallergenic and made with non-irritating ingredients. It lengthens and volumizes the lashes, giving them a fuller, more glitzy appearance. For oily skin types, its long-lasting formula is a fantastic waterproof option because it lasts all day without smudging or flaking. Finding a mascara that is as quick to remove as it is to wear is not easy. But, Secret Xpress Control mascara is a Godsend because it can be removed easily without losing any eyelashes. It suits oily skin well as it provides a non-sticky look that lasts for up to 12 hours.

13

Best Natural Formula

Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara

Buy on Amazon

This mascara is not your average drugstore mascara. It is one of the best mascaras for oily hooded eyes in the world of mascaras. True to its name, the mascara is honest with its ingredients and has the cleanest ingredients that your lashes will be grateful for. Despite being an easy-to-remove mascara, this mascara-primer combo is designed to give long-lasting volume and length. While the mascara brush has specially shaped bristles to outline and frame each lash for a defined, natural-looking appearance, the primer aids in establishing an even base and intensifying the mascara pigment, which is very important for oily skin.

14

Blinc Original Tubing Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Blinc Original Tubing Mascara has a unique formula that attaches itself to the eyelashes effortlessly, making them look stunning. The number of times, we, women accidentally rub our eyes and run like Flash to the powder room to check if our makeup is in place is astoundingly funny. If you are someone who is mindlessly rubbing her eyes often, please do yourself a favor and buy this tubing mascara by Blinc. If you've never used tubing mascara, you may be surprised to see the lash look-alikes fall off when you wash your face, but fret not, it's the product coming off, not the lashes. It is water-proof and maintains its natural state even after hours of application.

15

Best Hypoallergenic Formula

Ellocy 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara

Buy on Amazon

You can say goodbye to your fake lashes and switch to this two-in-one  4D Mascara. Your eyelashes appear bigger and seem more naturally full after applying this no-flake mascara. The mascara comes with two brushes, one for enhanced length and with a natural appearance and another for added volume. The mascara is long-lasting and waterproof. It contains natural beeswax that keeps your lashes moisturized all through the day. So, even when you're removing it with your makeup remover, it won’t strip your lashes of moisture or damage them.

If you want to make the best use of mascaras, you need to be mindful of a couple of factors that make the mascara suitable for your skin. Since oily skin is prone to secreting oil, it would be wise to give mascaras with oil-based compositions a pass. Also, it is important to consider the following factors:

Ingredients
To protect your eyes from damaging UV rays, choose a mascara with  SPF. Furthermore, mascara with microfiber would be the best option for oily skin. You must stay away from mascaras with Sodium Lauryl Sulfate (SLS), gluten, or any sulfate formula. Most hypoallergenic mascaras have been certified by ophthalmologists, so it would be a good choice to choose mascaras that have the green signal from ophthalmologists. 

Lasting Power
Make your lashes appear thicker and longer by using microfiber mascara. The unique wax-containing composition of these mascaras makes the product stick to the lashes without being smeared on the surrounding surfaces. For long-lasting mascara that does not make your eyes look tired or drugged, waterproof mascaras with non-drying formulas are another option. From the list, look for mascaras that do not flake or clump, because that's what you need when you buy mascara. 

Removable
Although waterproof and smudge-proof mascaras are the best choice for oily skin, it's advisable to use mascara that can be washed or removed relatively easily. Most mascaras can be easily removed with makeup remover or oil/ cleanser. But, if the mascara requires you to rub your lashes, pull them, or clean them vigorously, run as far as you can from it. All you need your mascara to do is stay put, but not latch on to your lashes so tight that they end up damaging the lashes. So, pick one that's easily removable. A popular choice for people with oily lids is tubing mascara. Instead of flaking and smudging like traditional mascaras, tubing mascaras wrap the lashes in polymers like a tube. 

Formula
Choose gentle formulations if you want a mascara that will give you more volume. Pick mascaras that don't clump, flake, or make your lashes look artificial. Look for mascaras that have less harmful ingredients. 

Shades
Having oily skin does not mean you limit your options. You have a God-given shine, so let that sparkle, and while you're at it, add some color to your lashes too. The majority of oil-free mascaras are available in a range of colors, including black, brown, blue, and other colorful shades. These hues are flattering on everyone and are worth trying on. You can use black mascara on regular days and experiment with other colors for special occasions.

Eyelashes are the most subtle yet glorifying feature of our faces, and we dare not deprive them of attention. Take cues from this list and equip your makeup vanity with not one but a handful of the best mascaras for oily skin that complement your makeup routine and lifestyle. You can always count on the best drugstore mascara for oily skin if you don't wish to splurge. It is better to use foundation and primers that suit oily skin too so that the overall look is well complimented. It would be helpful to always carry blotting paper to blot out any excess oil from the skin. So, go slay your lashes, girl!