11 Best Color Eyeliners to Accentuate Your Eyes Dramatically

Written by Sayantani Deb, Makeup & Beauty Writer
Updated on Feb 07, 2024
Best Color Eyeliners to Accentuate Your Eyes Dramatically
The products curated for this article are independently chosen by the editorial team. If you make a purchase through the links mentioned below, we may receive a commission. Check out our product research & curation process

It is quite fascinating how a line on the eyelid along the lashline can change the whole look for us! The best color eyeliners are the ultimate options to get you there! They are smudge-proof, hypoallergenic, and intensely pigmented to cover all aspects single-handedly. The seamless finishes of the products allow you to get the best result that you have been yearning for! Furthermore, special features like hypoallergenic, cruelty-free, and waterproof formulas are the cherries on the cake, to say the least.

Your eye color plays the biggest role in how the eyeliner will look on you! The thumb rule is using the complementary color that contrasts your natural eyeball according to the color wheel. For instance- if you have green eyes, using a copper-toned liner will be the best for you, similarly, for brown eyes beauties blue colored eyeliner is a game changer. Simply follow the color wheel to locate your eyeliner color.

“Live your eyeliner, breathe your lipstick,” says American songstress Lady Gaga. Well, Gaga is right! All you need is a dash of color over your eyes to get your desired look. Check out these products to get the hang of ‘em—

11 Best Color Eyeliners

Available in 10 intriguing shades, the Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner helps to create a look that you yearn for! The cruelty-free formula of the eyeliner ensures you a clean beauty that doesn’t come by sacrificing the environmental aspect. Get the dramatic sharp look that will accentuate your eyes with the help of the designed tip. The versatile eyeliner lets you experiment with your look to fetch compliments. It glides over the eye base to ensure a smooth line for a perfect look.

Pros
  • Cruelty-free
  • Versatile
  • Wide range of colors
  • Designed tip
  • Breakproof tip
  • Built-in smudger
Cons
  • Dries out quickly
  • Intensely Pigmented

    stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

    stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner
  • Stila comes with three variants and 8 different colors of eyeliners to serve various purposes. The first variant, the dual-ended liquid liner provides you with an ultra-precise tip on both sides, while the micro tip one, the second variant, offers you superior control and accuracy. On the other hand, the third and the original one is suitable to deliver any look from thin to dramatic while gliding smoothly over your lids. The color-liquid eyeliner has a fast-drying formula that is a boon for girls who are always in a hurry! The waterproof and smudge-proof formula is another blessing to novices to pros.

    Pros
    • Various shades
    • Three variants
    • Smooth tip
    • Waterproof
    • Quick-drying
    Cons
    • Could be more long-lasting
  • Best for a Shimmery Finish

    Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil

    Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil
  • Even if you’re wearing a simple LBD for a special occasion, this shimmery-colored eyeliner by Urban Decay can jazz up your look. While the shade Roxy (metallic blue) is our favorite, other shades, such as copper, turquoise, purple, cobalt, green, dark brown, etc. are also gorgeous picks for different aesthetics and skin tones. As it is infused with rich botanical oils and vitamin E, the pencil glides smoothly over your eyelids and nourishes them to prevent drying or flaking. 

    Pros
    • Intense color payoff
    • Vegan and cruelty-free
    • Blendable consistency
    • Lasts very long
    • Easy application
    • Smudge-proof
    Cons
    • Can’t be worn with contact lenses
  • Ophthalmologist-tested

    Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil

    Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner Pencil
  • The Revlon Colorstay is already a raging name in the beauty industry. The versatile colored eyeliner pencil is one of the cult-classic products in the makeup industry. The creamy formula glides over the lid like butter and stays put for more than 24 hours. The smudge-proof eyeliner comes with an in-built sharpener to save you from all the hassles of looking out for one! It also has an in-built smudger that allows you to go bold from a minimal look as you please.

    Pros
    • Built-in smudger
    • Sharpener
    • Stays for more than 24 hours
    • Smudge proof
    • Waterproof
    • Smooth
    • Ophthalmologist-tested
    Cons
    • Crumbles
  • Waterproof

    Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Eyeliner

    Maybelline Unstoppable Waterproof Eyeliner
  • The Unstoppable range from Maybelline is what makeup artists are going gaga over! The smudge-resistant formula of the eyeliner ensures that the product stays in place for a long time without ruining the look. The highly pigmented formula provides you with the ultimate finish with just one stroke. The brand is already making a difference with the eye makeup range, and the waterproof eyeliners are no less! Amp up the style quotient with your favorite eye makeup fearlessly!

    Pros
    • Smudge-resistant
    • Versatile
    • Highly pigmented
    • Gentle on the skin
    • Self-sharpening tip
    • Waterproof
    Cons
    • Breakable
  • L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner

    L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner
  • The Infallible Pro eyeliner is one of the cult-favorite makeup products you need to achieve Goddess-like eyes! With 10 available vibrant shades, the creamy formula glides on your eyes like butter and stays on for up to 24 hours. The smudge-free formula gives you a no-messy look for that sharp appearance. It allows room to experiment with different types of liner and helps achieve your desired look with ultimate precision. All you need is the pencil to create your preferable looks ranging from smokey eyes, cat eyeliner, or even basic eyeliner.

    Pros
    • Waterproof
    • Smudge-proof
    • Glides on smoothly
    • Lasts up to 24 hours
    • Best for everyday looks
    • Easy-to-apply
    Cons
    • Hard to sharpen
  • NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Eye Pencil

    NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Slim Eye Pencil
  • NYX slim eye pencil comes in 13 variants to let you play with the colors for your desired eye makeup look! The creamy and long-wearing formula of the colorful eyeliner pencils provides you with the smoothest finish that stays put for a long time. It resists bleeding and assures a sharp look without getting messy. The cruelty-free product is given an ergonomic shape to ensure a firm grip and easy use. With different finishes from matte to shimmery, these bunch of pencil eyeliners covers every aspect of your eyeliner needs.

    Pros
    • Creamy formula
    • Longwear
    • PETA approved
    • Cruelty-free
    • Sharpens easily
    • Smooth application
    Cons
    • Not good for waterline
  • stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

    stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner
  • The Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner by Stila comes in 15 vibrant colors that glide over your eyelid smoothly so that you don’t need to pull or tug for the ultimate look. The transfer-proof eyeliner is easy-to-use and doesn’t smudge or fade for a vibrant look all day long. The classic pencil eyeliner has a noteworthy intense color payoff for a bold look. Furthermore, this best-colored eyeliner has moisturizing ingredients that won’t cause any harm to your skin.

    Pros
    • Glides on smoothly
    • Transfer proof
    • Color-rich
    • Easy-to-use
    • Comes in two finishes
    • Moisturizing ingredients
    Cons
    • Runs out fast
  • Skone Cosmetics Insanely Intense Tattooed Eyeliner

    Skone Cosmetics Insanely Intense Tattooed Eyeliner
  • The go-to eyeliner is preferred by cosmetologists around the world for its rich and ultra-pigmented formula. The liquid-felt tip eyeliner allows you to draw the sleekest line you can possibly imagine and it is a must-have item for any beauty enthusiast’s stash! The quick-drying formula, on the other hand, ensures that the product doesn’t transfer onto your lid for a clean look. Furthermore, the waterproof formula makes it a savior on a pool day or beach vacation.

    Pros
    • Ultra-pigmented
    • Smudge-proof
    • Waterproof
    • Stays in place
    • Quick drying
    • Long lasting
    Cons
    • Liquid felt tip could be better
  • Marcelle Velvet Gel Waterproof Eyeliner

    Marcelle Velvet Gel Waterproof Eyeliner
  • The velvet gel eyeliner comes in 7 intense shades to provide you with the best eye looks that you yearn for! The hypoallergenic formula makes it a great product for people with sensitive eyes and the moisturizing ingredients ensure that the product glides on smoothly for a precise line. The long-lasting formula stays on the lid for more than 24+ hours letting you enjoy a dramatic look all day long. Not to miss, the colored liquid eyeliner is fragrance-free to ensure that people sensitive to smell can also use it.

    Pros
    • Waterproof
    • Transfer proof
    • Hypoallergenic
    • Smudge-proof
    • Glides on smoothly
    • Fragrance-free
    • Lasts for 24+ hours
    Cons
    • Difficult to get the product out
  • Hypoallergenic

    COLORGRAM Artist Formula Cream Liner

    COLORGRAM Artist Formula Cream Liner
  • The cream liner comes in a shimmery finish to get you ready for the party in a jiffy! The lightweight and moisturizing formula glides over your lids smoothly without smudging or being cakey. Available in 8 shades, the cruelty-free products serve you different purposes on various occasions. These colorful eyeliners have a precise definition and move over your eyelid smoothly without any lag. The hypoallergenic and unscented formula further makes the product a great addition to the stash for people with sensitive skin.

    Pros
    • Cruelty-free
    • Hypoallergenic
    • Unscented
    • Lightweight
    • Longwear
    • Precise definition
    Cons
    • Dry consistency

    How to Choose the Best Color Eyeliners?

    a) Formula- Picking up the best formula depends on your requirements. If you sweat a lot, go for a waterproof formula. Similarly, if you have an oily eyelid a liquid smudge-proof eyeliner will be the best option for you. Special features like- ophthalmologist-tested formula, hypoallergenic formula, and cruelty-free formula work the best for your eyes. If you have sensitive eyes, it is wise to pick those to be on the safer side.

    b) Pigmentation- Look for a well-pigmented eyeliner that won’t require reapplication. An eyeliner with an amazing color payoff will give you an intense look with a pop of color making you ready for any event in a jiffy!

    c) Texture- The creamier the texture is, the easier for you to control the eyeliner. A smooth texture allows you to get the best look out of any makeup product. Other than that, they will glide over your eyelid smoothly for a butter-like finish.

    How to Use the Best Color Eyeliners?

    1. Start with priming the eyelid with an eyeshadow primer to make your eyeliner stay for longer than it is meant to!

    2.  Next, apply some loose powder to set it lightly.

    3. Apply the eyeshadow first, or you can just keep the eyelid bare.

    4. Take your eyeliner and go wild and creative for a rich and intense look.

    5. If you want the eyeliner to stay for a bit longer than it should and want an amazing color payoff out of the product, take a little bit of eyeshadow of the same color to dab over the liner to make it pop lightly.

    6. Lastly, finish off with coats of mascara.

    These best color eyeliners are your doorway to getting intense eye looks that won’t smudge, transfer, or fade. A little eyeliner along the lashline can indeed change the look! Spruce your makeup game by grabbing this richly pigmented product to bring all the attention to your eyes unapologetically! Hope this carefully curated list has been a great guide to you! Have you picked your favorite one yet?

    FAQ's

    Which color of eyeliner looks more natural?
    Any eyeliner that complements your eye color, looks the best on your eyes! And also it will look natural. For example, brown eyes people can go with green eyeliner, similarly, green eyes people can go for brown eyeliners.
    Which is better black or brown eyeliner?
    While brown eyeliner helps you create a no-makeup makeup look, black eyeliners are best to create the sharpest wing and dramatic eyeliners.
    What color eyeliner looks best on pale skin?
    Any eyeliner with a cool undertone will look best on pale skin, such as blue, purple, green, mauve, etc.

    Why Trust Pinkvilla

    Sayantani, our in-house makeup expert, claims that colored eyeliners can add a dash of boldness and creativity to traditional eye makeup looks. They add a subtle pop of color that can be playful or dramatic, according to the look you’re going for. After giving all the liners a try, she couldn’t help but fall in love with COVERGIRL’s Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner. It effectively accentuated her eyes, gaining her endless complaints. Additionally, it’s cruelty-free and comes in a wide range of attractive shades.

    Our product experts study the specifications of every product we suggest and try them out to bring what’s proven to be worthy of your money, time, and energy. We also have subject matter experts from various fields like Fashion, Skincare, Haircare, Home Decor, and Health & Fitness onboard to make sure our suggestions are credible and trustworthy. You can trust Pinkvilla to be your faithful shopping guide for all the right reasons!

    Author BIO
    reviewer
    Sayantani Deb
    Makeup & Beauty Writer

    Sayantani is a certified hair and makeup professional turned writer with 2+ years of experience in the same genre. Ap More