13 Best Drugstore Eye Creams to Treat All Under-eye Concerns

Written by Anoushka Sinha, Skincare Coach & Writer
Updated on Feb 12, 2024
Best Drugstore Eye Creams to Treat All Under-eye Concerns
The products curated for this article are independently chosen by the editorial team. If you make a purchase through the links mentioned below, we may receive a commission. Check out our product research & curation process

The depth of a person’s soul is proportional to that of his eyes, but dark circles, under-eye bags, and crow's feet should not come as a hindrance when trying to appreciate a person’s intrinsic beauty. Hence, having one of the  best under-eye drugstore creams is important to combat signs of premature aging that often get triggered due to intrinsic stress, poor nutrition and excessive exposure to pollutants. 

Our research indicates that because of the rapid rate of digitalization, the eyes are exposed to a lot more stress-inducing factors than they were a decade ago. Also, the skin around the eyes tends to be more nascent and tender than all over the body, which is why a little bit of emotional, psychological, or physical strain tends to affect their overall appearance.

With a proper eight hours of sleep, adequate amount of hydration, and unadulterated nutrition via eye creams, you can easily boost the process of recovery. In tandem, below are a few recommendations for people who have been tired of experimenting with homemade remedies and are unable to witness the desired results. 

Scroll down to know more!

13 Best Drugstore Eye Creams

A master product of the CeraVe skincare range is this eye repair cream. This product is one of the best drugstore eye creams because of its lightweight, non-greasy formula that further makes it easy to absorb and assimilate nutrients. To note, it is made with MVE technology that helps to strengthen the ceramide barrier of the super thin skin cells by supercharging the lipid concentration. Last but not the least, it not only reduces dark circles but also helps to get rid of under-eye bags, crow’s feet, and sunken eyes. 

Pros
  • Makeup-friendly
  • Suitable for all skin types
  • Boosts hydration
  • Soothes inflammation
Cons
  • Faulty packaging
  • Best for Oily Skin

    Cetaphil Hydrating Eye Gel Cream

    Cetaphil Hydrating Eye Gel Cream
  • The best drugstore eye cream for oily skin is here — the Cetaphil eye cream that is loaded with non-comedogenic ingredients and causes no bumps or zits. It contains licorice extracts and vitamin E that help to brighten and lighten the darkened skin beneath your eyes. Addedly, it not only replenishes the skin’s moisture barrier but also prevents drying due to external factors. To add more, it has a lightweight gel-based formulation that makes its absorption a hassle-free process. It also works miraculously for aging skin by accelerating hydration, firming fine lines, and relaxing crow's feet. 

    Pros
    • Unclogs pores
    • Illuminates dull eyes
    • Diminishes fine lines
    • Best suited for sensitive skin
    Cons
    • Takes longer to show results
  • Best for Beginners

    Lily Ana Naturals Eye Cream

    Lily Ana Naturals Eye Cream
  • The search for a drugstore eye cream with a flowery natural essence ends right here, as this one by Lily Ana Naturals is available in the captivating scent of rose and hibiscus. It not only diminishes dark circles but also firms the skin and prevents further creasing of the delicate under-eye area. It is further best suited for treating under-eye discoloration and smoothing out wrinkles. To note more, the product contains aloe extracts that are a treasure trove of vitamin E along with rosemary that helps fight photodamage (1)(2). To top off, it is vegan, free from artificial colors and fragrances, and hence a planet-friendly choice. 

    Pros
    • Lifts and firms skin
    • Controls sebum production
    • Soothes redness
    • Sweatproof
    Cons
    • Faulty pump
  • Best for Acne-prone Skin

    baebody Eye Gel

    baebody Eye Gel
  • The struggle to find an eye cream that genuinely addresses aging concerns is real, which is why the baebody eye gel is formulated with peptides that help with collagen formulation. It also contains a blend of amino acids that help to strengthen the walls of the skin proteins and maintain the nutrient concentration within the cells. (3)  It is undoubtedly one of the best drugstore eye creams for aging skin as it treats volume loss and helps treat discolouration along with firming the under-eye skin. 

    Pros
    • Boost radiance
    • Easily absorbent
    • Hypoallergenic
    • Non-irritant
    • Cruelty-free
    Cons
    • Stings during initial application
  • Best Choice for Sensitive skin

    Neutrogena RAPID WRINKLE REPAIR RETINOL Eye Cream

    Neutrogena RAPID WRINKLE REPAIR RETINOL Eye Cream
  • Another brainchild of the skincare brand, Neutrogena is this rapid repair eye cream. It is formulated with a deadly combination of retinol that is known for reducing the signs of photoaging and chronic aging, and hyaluronic acid that helps to keep the moisture level in the keratinous cells of the skin intact. It also provides a robust plumping formula that gives your skin an uplifted and rejuvenated look. For the best results, it is advised to couple the product with sunscreen during the daytime and a night repair cream at the day's end.

    Pros
    • Best suited for normal skin
    • Treats hard-ingrained wrinkles
    • Fades away crow’s feet
    • Combats dark spots
    Cons
    • May make the skin scaly if overused
  • Best for Dry Skin

    L'OREAL PARIS EYE DEFENSE Eye Cream

    L'OREAL PARIS EYE DEFENSE Eye Cream
  • The powerful antidote to combat the after-effects of late-night Netflix binges is this L’Oreal eye cream. Another superstar from L'Oreal Paris, this product contains the goodness of hyaluronic acid that helps with moisture retention and preserving the skin’s natural barrier. It also contains retinol which eases signs of aging like wrinkles, crow's feet and dark circles. All in all, it re-energizes the skin around your eyes and prevents further loss of moisture due to environmental aggressors. 

    Pros
    • Free from artificial colors and fragrance
    • Eases fine lines
    • Improves skin tone
    • Lightweight and easily absorbent
    Cons
    • Might cause redness
  • Best for Aging Skin

    OLAY ULTIMATE EYE CREAM

    OLAY ULTIMATE EYE CREAM
  • Another splendid product from the house of Olay is this ultimate eye cream. The cream is formulated with benzoyl peroxide that helps with the oxidation of bacterial proteins. To note more, it is available in a pretty pink shade with the minor properties of a concealer to help with makeup application. For the best results, apply a pea-sized amount of the product and let it rest for 2-3 minutes on the affected surface. Tada, you have unlocked the secret to glowing, luminous skin. 

    Pros
    • Depuffs puffy eyes
    • Restores loss of elasticity
    • Retains moisture
    • Elevates shine
    Cons
    • Tends to become cakey
  • Best for all Ages

    ROC MULTI CORREXION 5 IN 1 ANTI-AGING Eye Cream

    ROC MULTI CORREXION 5 IN 1 ANTI-AGING Eye Cream
  • Finding an anti-aging eye cream with the emollient properties of a moisturizer is difficult, hence the ROC multi correxion cream is there to the rescue. The product just like its name corrects multiple concerns like uneven skin tone, creasing and volume loss below the eyes. It is also ideal for usage across people of all genders and ages. To add more, it contains shea butter that has superb anti-inflammatory properties along with ascorbic acid that helps fight free radicals and external pollutants. Overall, this product is the best pick for people with stubborn dark circles. 

    Pros
    • Rectifies dullness
    • Firms sagginess
    • Non Comedogenic
    • Non Greasy
    • Reverses sun damage
    Cons
    • Causes flaky eyelids
  • Best Portable Option

    VELAMO ADVANCED RETINOL Eye Stick

    VELAMO ADVANCED RETINOL Eye Stick
  • A portable and efficient solution for those unwanted under-eye bags and polyhued patches beneath your eyes is the Velamo advanced eye stick. It has an undefeatable composition of retinol and peptides that help to reverse the signs of aging and also strengthen the lipid concentration of the skin cells. Addedly, it features a twist-and-turn mechanism that prevents the product from drying. Lastly, to witness the product's true potential, it is advised to run the stick twice a day around your eye area. 

    Pros
    • Aids in moisturizing
    • Enhances skin’s texture
    • Tightens wrinkles
    • Water-resistant
    Cons
    • May cause allergies
  • Best for Short-term Results

    FILORGA OPTIM-EYES

    FILORGA OPTIM-EYES
  • Filogra Laboratories brings to you an eye cream scientifically formulated with the superpowers of hyaluronic acid, peptides, and polyphenols to help achieve a refreshed and rejuvenated look. It not only fights against aging signs but also increases the supply of melatonin around the eye area thereby, assuring a sound and undisturbed sleep. Furthermore, this non-comedogenic cream is available in a lightweight texture and hence, one of the preferred choices of dermatologists in the category of the best drugstore eye creams for sensitive skin. 

    Pros
    • Combats redness
    • Eases fine lines
    • Tightens pores
    • Uplifts sunken eyes
    Cons
    • May cause itching
  • EIGHT SAINTS ALL IN Eye Cream

    EIGHT SAINTS ALL IN Eye Cream
  • The users of this All In eye cream have indeed felt that the product is blessed with the divine powers of eight saints that makes it a non-negotiable choice to combat expression lines, wrinkles, dark circles and crow's feet. To be noted, the eight miraculous saints include caffeine, cucumber, hyaluronic acid, peptides, jojoba oil, glycolic acid, vitamin E, aloe extracts and shea butter, which have splendid moisturizing and astringent properties. To top it all off, it is one of the best drugstore eye creams for combination skin as it improves skin cell turgidity, provides potent sun protection, and does not clog pores.

    Pros
    • Free of artificial colors
    • Safe for day and night use
    • Anti-inflammatory
    • Has a refreshing scent
    Cons
    • Can cause darkening if overused
  • CLINIQUE All About Eyes

    CLINIQUE All About Eyes
  • An eye cream that also works as a primer to make your eye makeup stay longer? Yes, please! To be noted, this Clinique eye cream, with a floaty texture, effortlessly depuffs puffy eyes along with easing signs of aging like wrinkles, under-eye creases, and crows feet. It also contains green tea extracts that have amazing anti-inflammatory and anti-bacterial properties along with mulberry extracts that strengthen and protect the skin against photodamage.

    Pros
    • Soothes redness
    • Calms inflammation
    • Treats skin discolouration
    • Swim-resistant
    Cons
    • Faulty packaging in some products.
  • TRU ALCHEMY Eye Elixir

    TRU ALCHEMY Eye Elixir
  • This product by True Alchemy is indeed an elixir for treating aging concerns with regards to one's eyes. It is formulated with caffeine that depuffs eye circles and has powerful antioxidant properties. If you are looking for a product that instantly tightens the skin under the eyes, lends a rejuvenating appearance and smoothens tough skin creases then, the above product is an undebatable choice. Plus, it is fragrance-free, sulfate-free and artificial color-free, making a great choice for people who have just begun to witness the early signs of aging.

    Pros
    • Blurs stubborn wrinkles
    • Cools the eye area
    • Lightens dark circles
    • Reverses photodamage
    Cons
    • Turns rusty on opening

    Choosing the best drugstore eye cream from a number of options available in the market can be a real hustle hence, we bring to you a buying guide to facilitate your decision making. 

    How to Choose the Best Drugstore Eye Cream?

    Here are a few factors to consider before vouching for the best drugstore eye creams - 

    1. Composition of Ingredients: The eye cream you are planning to buy should be free from parabens, sulfates, and phthalates. Instead, it should contain ingredients like hyaluronic acid, aloe extracts and jojoba oil that help to boost moisture. It should also not contain alcohol, mineral oil, artificial colors and fragrances, as they can lead to eye infections and allergies. 
    2. Presence of Skin Brightening Agents and SPF: The eye cream should have an ideal percentage of vitamin C as it helps fight free radicals and oxidative stress — one of the major reasons for melanogenesis and skin discolouration. It should also have a high percentage of glycolic acid to fight sun damage. Other than this, the presence of titanium dioxide further helps fight UVA, UVB and UVC rays. 
    3. Compatibility with the Skin Type: The drugstore eye cream should be compatible with the skin type of an individual. For dry skin, dermatologists recommend a product with a higher percentage of hyaluronic acid as it is a superb humectant, while for oily skin, it is advised to use a formula with a percentage of salicylic acid that gently exfoliates the dead skin and prevents zit formation. 

    Conclusion 

    The skin around our eyes is more nascent than the rest of the body and hence needs specialized attention and care. Also, in such a rapidly changing scenario, where environmental change is directly proportional to the deterioration of our skin’s health, eye creams serve as a blessing in disguise. However, a good eye cream should be enriched with humectants that not only help to level up hydration and improve skin cell turgidity but also ensure a robust amount of sun protection. To note, ingredients like vitamin C, titanium dioxide and zinc oxide sheath the tender skin against photodamage and inhibit the process of premature aging, making them an essential ingredient in eye creams.

    Now, since you are aware about the benefits of using these magical elixirs, our top recommended best drugstore eye creams can prove to be useful in reducing under-eye concerns effortlessly. So, without further ado, add one to your cart, because you know you need it! Happy shopping!

    FAQ's

    What are the benefits of using a drugstore eye cream?
    Using drugstore eye creams can help to keep the under-eye skin hydrated, and strengthen the delicate skin with gradual use.
    What ingredients should I look for in a drugstore eye cream?
    An ideal drugstore eye cream should contain a composition of active ingredients like hyaluronic acid, ceramides, retinol and peptides. It should also contain vitamin E which is a treasure trove of antioxidants and helps in preventing moisture loss.

    Why Trust Pinkvilla

    Anoushka, the budding journalist, is also our in-house expert. The certified beauty expert has done complete research and studies to curate this list of the best drugstore eye creams that eliminate dark circles and puffiness in a cost-effective manner. 

    Our product experts study the specifications of every product we suggest and try them out to bring what’s proven to be worthy of your money, time, and energy. We also have subject matter experts from various fields like Fashion, Skincare, Haircare, Home Decor, and Health & Fitness onboard to make sure our suggestions are credible and trustworthy. You can trust select to be your faithful shopping guide for all the right reasons!

    1. Medicinal importance of Aloe Vera 

    https://www.researchgate.net/publication/233818204_Medicinal_and_cosmetological_importance_of_Aloe_vera

    2. Rosemary (Rosmarinus officinalis L., syn Salvia rosmarinus Spenn.) and Its Topical Applications: A Review

    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7284349/

    3. Metabolism and Functions of Amino Acids in Skin Barrier 

    https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32761577/

    Author BIO
    reviewer
    Anoushka Sinha
    Skincare Coach & Writer

    Anoushka is certified in Professional Skincare and is a Mass Media (Journalism) graduate from Mumbai University. As a More