Nothing opens up the eyes and instantly accentuates the countenance like a good mascara and a well-brewed cup of coffee. So, as you plan to gravitate towards a more natural and polished appearance, we have got you covered with the best mascaras for redheads. Whether you are a natural redhead or got a red dye job to your blonde or brunette mane, it is quite important to match your lashes to your hair.

Based on our observations, the regular black hues or chocolate browns of the lashes are prone to starkly standing out against red tresses. So, after trying out some shades on the redheads in our beauty team, we have come up with this list of the ones that not only complement in terms of shades but also are worth the investment. A pro tip: For your red or gingerly lashes, go for tints of burgundy, auburn, or chestnut colors. 

Ahead, we showcase the compilation of mascaras that gently brush and curl your lashes while adding volume to them. As per our expertise, these high-definition and makeup artist-approved mascaras are a must-have for all redheads or anyone with cool undertones looking to experiment with a dash of color.

• 1
  Best for sensitive eyes

  MAYBELLINE NEW YORK Lash Sensational Sky High- Washable True Brown

  BUY ON AMAZON

The drugstore favorite, MAYBELLINE NEW YORK’s freshest addition to the mascara category is truly sensational with its lengthening and volumizing features. Imbued with the goodness of bamboo extract, the mascara fibers and its flex brush allow long and fuller lashes, from roots to tips. The shade True Brown, is a perfect red-toned color for painting your lashes in a single stroke. The best part is how the formula feels lightweight and does not flake or smudge over time.

2

Best applicator

L’Oréal Paris Makeup Voluminous Original: Deep Burgundy

BUY ON AMAZON

Look no further than the L’Oréal Paris mascara in the shade deep burgundy for the ideal and flattering hues of red and purple. Not only is this trending shade perfect for red lashes, but also works efficiently to bring out green eyes. The volumizing formula softens the lashes without clumping them. The maximizing brush gently separates and builds the lashes to give a naturally thicker appearance. You can enjoy longer and fuller lashes to amp up the look with a couple of coats.

3

Best for oily skin

COVERGIRL Lash Blast Volume: Brown

BUY ON AMAZON

Get maximum with minimum! You only need a few gentle strokes to get voluminous and fuller lashes in an instant with Covergirl’s mascara. This mascara comes in six colors and its iconic brown is just the one for painting them red-gingerly lashes. The buildable formula lengthens the lashes with each stroke without creating any clumps or flakes. The mascara stays put for long hours without smearing or smudging and is hassle-free to reapply or remove.

4

Best for Dry Skin

Eyeko Black Magic Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Enhance your lashes with Eyeko Black Magic Mascara—an ally for redheads seeking cruelty-free allure. This vegan mascara goes beyond aesthetics, offering smudge-proof and fade-proof perfection. Infused with Keratin and Shea Butter, it conditions the lashes, ensuring both glamor and care. Immerse yourself in the transformative power of a mascara designed to complement red hair, elevating your beauty routine with a cruelty-free, vegan formula that not only defines lashes but also nourishes them for a luscious, long-lasting finish.

5

Best colors

Just for Redheads Mascara Naturelle: Ginger Cocoa Naturelle

BUY ON AMAZON

A mascara range curated especially for redheads. What’s not to love? Just for Redheads presents its Naturelle mascaras in lovely cocoa, ginger, brown, and red hues. In this special club, redheads, even blondes, or anyone looking to get their lashes tinted can hop in. The unique brush offers extensive curl and length while volumizing the lashes. The full coverage formula is waterproof, smudge-proof as well as hypoallergenic, to suit everyone.

6

Best buildable formula

MAYDEAR Mascara for Eyelashes: Brown

BUY ON AMAZON

Another brown mascara that deserves a spot on your beauty shelf is the one by MAYDEAR. The silky and lightweight texture of this mascara makes the lashes appear dense and long instantly and leaves a long-lasting effect on your lashes. Amplify the eye makeup with a few strokes that work to thicken and plump your lashes. Without any lumps, the protective formula will leave your lashes looking soft and elastic.

7

Best with Natural ingredients

MINERAL FUSION Volumizing Mascara: Chestnut

BUY ON AMAZON

Shower some love on your lashes with the voluminous mascara by Mineral Fusion. The recipe is a luxurious fusion of botanicals, including white tea and aloe vera that nourish and moisturize the lashes, while painting them in the loveliest chestnut hues. Compliment your makeup and hair with this natural-looking mascara that quickly adds fullness and length to the lashes. Your application will go on smoothly through the day, without flaking, caking, or smudging. Amp your everyday look with lush lashes!

8

Best quality

Clinique Lash Power Mascara: Dark Chocolate

BUY ON AMAZON

While putting on mascara is the best thing, removing it can take a toll. If you are also searching for a mascara that can be easily cleansed, look no further than Clinique’s lash power mascara. This formula effortlessly gets washed off with warm water, while offering a staying power through sweat, tears, and rain. The long-lasting mascara adds volume and length to the lashes. The indulgent dark chocolate is a perfect brown to blend in with your redhead tones.

9

Best vegan product

PACIFICA Stellar Gaze: Stardust brown

BUY ON AMAZON

Another cool brown mascara under our radar is in the shade Stardust by PACIFICA. This skin-loving formula is infused with coconut oil and vitamin B. These non-toxic ingredients hydrate the skin while lengthening, volumizing, and strengthening each lash. The formula is great for build-up as it doesn’t flake or clump and stays on for long hours. The natural mascara is free of harsh chemicals and suitable for sensitive skin too.

10

Best for Easy removal

Eyeko Lash Alert: Brown

BUY ON AMAZON

A perfect addition to your everyday morning makeup, enter Eyeko mascara. Infused with caffeine this formula is great for instantly opening up tired or sleepy eyes. The presence of biotin and arginine is essential for nourishing the lashes, making them feel soft. Brighten your eyes while blending them with your natural appearance with the warm brown shade. Enjoy a fresh flutter of long and dense lashes, that will last you the whole day.

11

Best curling effect

e.l.f. Lash 'N Roll Mascara: Deep brown

BUY ON AMAZON

For a major lashing-curling moment, trust the lash ‘n roll mascara by e.l.f. With its unique curved silicon brush, this product promises instant eye-opening, lifting, and curling effects. Devoid of any clumping, smudging, or flaking, the formula goes on smoothly while gently separating the lashes. This cult-favorite mascara in the shade of deep brown will add a natural tint to your lashes, complementing the redheads.

12

Chella Good Drama Mascara: Burgundy

BUY ON AMAZON

Get your glam on the go with Chella’s burgundy mascara. This high-definition, lengthening mascara is all about adding that dramatic flair to your look. Infuse with vitamins C and E this recipe lends nourishment and glides smoothly without clumps. Bring maximum volume to your lashes and amp your makeup with a natural finish with this brown-red-hued shade. With minimal coats, your lashes will look bolder and ready for the day.

After exhausting our list of top-notch mascaras in red, brown, and burgundy, for a perfect match to redheads, let’s head on to the mini buying guide. Read on to learn a few hacks about how to choose and apply mascara.

Color: The first thing that comes to mind when choosing the right match for your pale or gingerly lashes is the color. A prominent black stands out, that’s why you need to opt for shades of brown, red, and burgundy. Go for a color that best matches your natural tone rather than a deeply pigmented color. A lighter shade will enhance your natural appearance. 

Staying power: How well your mascara stays put on your lashes is an essential aspect of weighing your options. A smudge-proof, water-proof, sweat, and tear-proof mascara will ensure that your lashes look fresh, long, and voluminous throughout the day. 

Formula: Lastly, look for the ingredients that encompass the mascara recipe. If you have sensitive skin, make sure the formula is hypoallergenic and approved by dermatologists. Your mascara should also be easily removed with warm water or micellar water for a hassle-free experience. 

Wand: The bristles are made of plastic, silicones, or nylon along with varying shapes and curves. Look for a nice wand that separates the lashes and applies mascara without clumping or irritating the eyes. 

Applying mascara doesn’t seem like rocket science, however, the right steps can help you achieve fuller and long-lasting lashes. 

Step 1: Use a lash curler to firmly curl and lift your lashes. 

Step 2: Apply a lash primer for better-enhanced results and create a base for the mascara.

Step 3: once the primer has dried, begin coating your mascara with the wand. Ensure that your wand is tightly close to the roots and gently wiggle the brush upwards. 

Step 4: Apply as many strokes as required for your desired finish. 

Mascaras are all about enhancing and amping your look with or without glam makeup. A few strokes of mascara can instantly open up the eyes and lift the lashes. This makes wearing the right shade highly important. We have copped the best mascaras for redheads so your lashes can cherish their true color. Look for volumizing and length-building mascaras that effortlessly create magic. For a dramatic date look or an everyday work look, get the gorgeous natural finish that goes well with your red locks.