Running a stroke of eyeliner on the lower and upper waterlines of the eyes has been a fail-proof story for ages now. For both beginners and professional makeup artists, using the best waterline eyeliners is a necessity, as it is a quick trick to make your eyes pop. It is recommended to rely on branded eyeliners that have conducted thorough research and then formulated safe products to amp up waterlines. Waterlines are naturally wet, sensitive, and delicate enough to require special attention during the application of eyeliners. This is where a good quality waterline eyeliner comes into the picture.

A single stroke of a good eyeliner on the rim of your eyes revives the exhausted and tired look of your eyes. This one stroke not only amps up the charm of your eyes, and your natural eye color, but also lends you a subtle look that can never go wrong. 

Waterline eyeliners, crayons, pencils, or kohl kajals allow others to “EYE-dentify” the beauty of your eyes at a glance. In addition, tightlining is also the most practiced way of brightening your eyes for creating a polished gaze. Mathias Alan, a celebrity makeup artist, says, “Tightlining is a technique of lining your eyes but actually going into the roots of the lash line on the top and making your lashes look thicker and denser without even the need to wear mascara.” Eyeliner pencils are crafted to comfortably sit on your waterline and thus make your lashes appear fuller and longer.

So, here we are with the products that help you raise your eye-makeup game in a simple way. Keep reading to explore the variety of liners we have narrowed down for you.

• 1
  Best Overall

  NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP RETRACTABLE EYE LINER - Brown

  Buy on Amazon

This RETRACTABLE EYE LINER from NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP is a twist-up eye liner pencil that comes in a beautiful shade of brown. It is a highly pigmented and smudge-proof eyeliner with a creamy formula that stays on your waterline for hours. This is a pencil that never asks for sharpening. Plus, it easily glides on the inner rims of your eyes, and you need not rub it multiple times for attaining a well-defined matte stroke. It is a cult favorite makeup essential that is highly suitable for tight lining your eyes. The brand offers multiple stunning shades of this product for people who love colored liners.

2

Best Vegan Formula

e.l.f. NO BUDGE PRECISION EYELINER - Black

Buy on Amazon

Renowned for its precise application and ultra-skinny gel formula, this NO BUDGE PRECISION EYELINER from e.l.f. ticks off all your eyeliner requirements. Its smudge-proof, and creamy formula runs on your waterline with ease. In addition, it is ultra-pigmented and enriched with skin-loving ingredients to magnify the beauty of your eyes within seconds of application. For acing the bold and daring eye-look, this eyeliner is worth investing in. With no need for any touch-ups, this vegan and cruelty-free eyeliner can be a perfect addition to your daily eye makeup.

3

Best Finish

URBAN DECAY 24/7 GLIDE-ON WATERPROOF EYELINER PENCIL - Smoke

Buy on Amazon

An eyeliner that has an intense color payoff, buttery application, and a long-lasting formula is on every makeup buff’s list. And, this 24/7 GLIDE-ON WATERPROOF EYELINER PENCIL from URBAN DECAY checks all the boxes and paves the way to the list of award winners. It is the best waterline eyeliner pencil that is waterproof, cruelty-free, and comes with a vibrant finish. With almost 50 percent of hydrating ingredients like cotton seed oil, jojoba oil, and vitamin E, this eyeliner’s ultra-creamy formula deserves applause. It has a sharpenable tip to help you pop your eyes out and hide your tiredness.

4

Best Shade Options

stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner

Buy on Amazon

The finely carved tip of this eyeliner by Stila delivers precise strokes, which makes it suitable for super-fine and subtle eye makeup. Its consistency is smooth and buttery, ensuring that it doesn’t pull or tug at the delicate skin of the waterline or eyelid — so the chances of irritation, itching, or swelling around the eyes is far less. Owing to the product’s highly pigmented formula, it provides an excellent color payoff, so you don’t have to keep redoing your eye makeup. Besides, the product is available in a variety of beautiful matte and shimmery shades to tart up your eye makeup.

5

Creamiest Formula

Haus Laboratories By Lady Gaga: Eye-Dentify Gel Kohl Eyeliner

Buy on Amazon

With its eye-opening color payoff and vibrant finish, this Kohl eyeliner by Haus Laboratories steals everyone’s hearts! Despite being a pencil-based product, the consistency of its formula is like a gel eyeliner — soft, smooth, and buttery. This allows you to line your eyes effortlessly and with a single stroke you can get a bold, exotic, and feline aesthetic. While you can diffuse this eyeliner for a smokey eye look, it has a sharpenable tip, so you can also use it for a simple, fine-lined look every day. 

6

Best for Sensitive Eyes

VASANTI COSMETICS Kajal Waterline Eyeliner - Intense Black

Buy on Amazon

Nothing can beat the effect of a black kajal that defines the eyes beautifully. For a natural-looking finish and full-lash appearance, this unscented Kajal Waterline Eyeliner Pencil from VASANTI COSMETICS is what you need in your makeup vanity. It is one of the best waterline eyeliner pencils for sensitive eyes. It is a non-retractable pencil that is cruelty-free, vegan, and free from kohl. It comes in 9 gorgeous shades and 4 finishes to fulfill every eye makeup dream of yours. Its easy-to-glide and long-lasting creamy formulation make it a must-have.

7

Easy-to-apply

Annabelle Waterline MATTE KOHL EYELINER - Blackest Black

Buy on Amazon

A winning creamy formula, quick application, matte finish, intense color pay-off, and smooth texture sum the goodness of Annabelle WATERLINE MATTE KOHL EYELINER. Its blackest black shade and thick diameter will make your eyes bright, bold, and beautiful. Just one stroke of this eyeliner on your waterline, and you need not worry for 4 hours straight. Available in 2 different shades — matte and luminous, this eyeliner has to be your go-to eye makeup essential to intensify the charm of your eyes.

8

Best Hypoallergenic

MARCELLE Velvet Gel Waterproof Eyeliner - Emerald

Buy on Amazon

This emerald Velvet Gel Waterproof Eyeliner from MARCELLE promises vibrant saturation for those bold and high-impact looks. It is a crayon eyeliner with a sharpenable ultra-precise tip that runs smoothly on your water lines as well as your eyelids.  Infused with the goodness of jojoba oil and vitamin E, this liner can make your eyes look more glamorous and well-defined all day long. Snag this eyeliner right away, as with just one creamy stroke, you can achieve any fancy look. In addition, it is waterproof and long-lasting.

9

Best Antioxidant-rich Formula

Jillian Dempsey KHÔL EYELINER

Buy on Amazon

Popularly known for its smudging abilities, Jillian Dempsey KHÔL EYELINER has all heart. All the credit goes to its in-built smudger, natural antioxidants, zero preservatives, and plant-derived ingredients. You can trace the presence of hydrating and organic jojoba oil, rejuvenating marula oil, and moisturizing shea butter with its smooth glide, and soft finish. You will also sheerly love its super smooth application. Secondly, it is not formulated with parabens, petrochemicals, and sulfates. 

10

essence extreme lasting eyeliner pencil - Black

Buy on Amazon

For wearing eyeliner on your waterline all day long, you need proof. And, this Extreme Lasting Eyeliner Pencil from essence is all set to promise everything that you are looking for. It is sharpenable, vegan, cruelty-free, and paraben-free and lends you an opaque finish type. It glides on your waterline with no effort and hence makes the application process an easy-breezy task. All the credit goes to its silky-smooth formula with zero preservatives, acetone, or alcohol.

11

Easy Application

INGLOT Kohl Pencil 01

Buy on Amazon

Moisturizing, highly pigmented, easy blending, and smudge-proof application are a few reasons that make INGLOT Kohl Pencil 01 a win-win eye makeup product. It is soft and supple on your water lines and dries off quickly. For a fuller lash look, you can run it through your upper waterline. However, it can be transferred to your lower waterline, delivering a softer and more subtle look. The active ingredients allow you to blend it seamlessly and prevent a messy look.

12

CHANEL STYLO YEUX WATERPROOF Eyeliner

Buy on Amazon

An eyeliner that is resistant to water, humidity, and oil is still a dream of millions of makeup enthusiasts. But let us tell you that this CHANEL STYLO YEUX WATERPROOF is all you need in your kitty to get a versatile liner. It has an intense black color and a retractable tip promising ultra-precise application. In addition, its smooth texture gives you a chance to smoothly run it into the inner rims of your eyes. This is one of the best waterproof waterline eyeliners that doesn’t smudge and is soft due to its silicone-enriched formula.

13

Kmeamty Gel Eye Liner Pencil Set

Buy on Amazon

No matter how many eyeliners you own, you still fall short of them. But with Kmeamty Gel Eye Liner Pencil set, you can satiate your hunger for vibrant liners. This set of 12 vibrant colors can be used as both eyeliners and eyeshadows. With a rotating core, the application of this vegan formula becomes quite simple.  These liners glide on your waterline smoothly and give you a chance to smudge with ease for attaining smokey eyes. You should note that these pencils do not smudge on their own. The mousse-like texture, creamy formula, and super-pigmented color make it a must-have product.

14

Julep Beauty When Pencil Met Gel All-Day Waterproof Eyeliner - Blackest Black

Buy on Amazon

The aura of blackest black waterline eyeliner is so overwhelming that you just cannot resist adding one to your cart. And, this When Pencil Met Gel All-Day Waterproof Eyeliner from Julep Beauty is something that will make you fall in love with black all over again. It is a high-performance liner with more than 20 shimmer and matte shades. In addition, this liner has a bold color payoff that allows you to ace the smokey eye game without any fuss. It is enriched with finely milled pigments and a blend of special wax for saturated color and gentle glide.

Waterline pencils or eyeliners are worth populating your kitty with. These sleek makeup products have the power to drastically transform your look in a blink of an eye. To help you make better purchasing decisions, we have jotted down a useful buying guide.

Here are a few aspects to note before purchasing eyeliner for everyday use. 

 

Ingredients: Always ensure that you are well aware of the ingredients that suit your eyes. Avoid eyeliner that is enriched with harsh toxins or makes you teary. Pick a liner that is formulated with lash-conditioning ingredients like jojoba oil, shea butter, cotton seed oil, and vitamin E.

Type of Eyeliner: There are various types of branded and drugstore waterline eyeliners available in stores to suit the needs of a beginner as well as a professional makeup artist. There are liners that are retractable, non-retractable, and self-sharpening with a twist and application technique. Whereas some of the liners come in a crayon/pencil-like appearance so that you can sharpen them according to your own necessities. Both types tend to be good and convenient. However, crayon or pencil-type eyeliners last longer. Choose one as per your need and usage.

Color: There is a wide range of shades to choose from. Widely purchased eyeliner color is black and white. White liners help in brightening your eyes, whereas black liners define the rim of your eyes beautifully. You may also choose to apply a stroke of green, brown, or blue to magnify the glory of your winged eyeliner or eyeshadow.

Texture: Always make sure that your eyeliner has a smooth and soft texture that gently glides on your waterline. Stay away from those which compel you to apply three or four strokes to attain a perfect finish.

Features: Always go through the features of the eyeliner as per your preferences. If you are more into attaining smokey eyes, make sure you pick an eyeliner that is easily blendable. For a long-lasting stroke, pick a long-wear, smudge-proof, and transfer-proof liner. You may also choose waterproof eyeliner to maintain your look all day long. However, an eyeliner that lasts up to 4 to 6 hours is safe and reliable.

With the best waterline eyeliners, you can seamlessly skimp off the mascara and yet make your eyelashes appear fuller, longer, and dense. These liners are definitely the most valuable players in your makeup vanity. Even if you choose to flaunt a no-makeup look, these seek and travel-friendly tubes and pencils come to your rescue to enhance your natural complexion. So, relying on a waterline eyeliner for tightlining your lash line is definitely a great idea to uplift your makeup look within minutes. Secondly, kajals or liners amp up the glory of your waterlines, as well as eyebrows in a jiffy.