9 Best Waterproof Setting Sprays That Surpassed My Expectations

Written by Sayantani Deb, Makeup & Beauty Writer
Updated on Feb 16, 2024
9 Best Waterproof Setting Sprays that Surpassed My Expectations
The products curated for this article are independently chosen by the editorial team. If you make a purchase through the links mentioned below, we may receive a commission. Check out our product research & curation process

I live in a place where the weather can't make up its mind. One minute it's scorching hot, the next it's pouring rain. It's like Mother Nature is playing a game of weather roulette. Now, I'm not one to let a little rain ruin my makeup masterpiece. That's where the best waterproof setting sprays come in.

I started using waterproof setting sprays because, let's face it, regular setting sprays were just not cutting it anymore. I got tired of looking like a melting wax figure every time a surprise rainstorm hit or when I worked up a sweat during the summer heatwave. So, I decided to take matters into my own hands and find the holy grail of setting sprays – the waterproof kind.

I went down the rabbit hole of online reviews and YouTube tutorials, I even asked my beauty-savvy friends for recommendations. I curated a list of the best waterproof setting sprays out there because, well, ain't nobody got time for makeup that slides off like a watercolor painting. I wanted a spray that could stand up to the elements, keep my makeup intact, and let me slay all day without worrying about touch-ups.

I reviewed each spray, considering factors like longevity, finish, and, of course, resistance to water. I even put them through the ultimate test – a dance party in the rain. After a thorough examination, I found my ride-or-die waterproof setting spray.

Now, I can confidently say that I prefer using waterproof setting sprays because they're my makeup's secret weapon against unpredictable weather and unexpected dance-offs. Life's too short for makeup mishaps, and my waterproof setting spray is the unsung hero keeping my face flawless, rain or shine.

9 Best Waterproof Setting Sprays

Crafted to endure the rigors of a demanding day or a vibrant night out, this setting spray boasts an impressive 16-hour staying power. Its oil-free formula ensures a natural finish without compromising on longevity, catering to all skin types. The non-drying formula is a testament to Urban Decay's commitment to delivering both durability and comfort. A fine skin mist sets makeup seamlessly, preventing smudging and ensuring a flawless look that lasts. I came across an Amazon review — This product is so awesome and worth the money.”

Scent: Fresh

Finish: Natural, translucent

Cruelty-free: Yes

Skin Tone: All

Pros
  • Transfer-proof
  • Smudge-proof
  • Buildable
  • Vegan
Cons
  • Poor packaging
  • Best for Sensitive Skin

    Covergirl Vitalist Look Lock Up Setting Spray

    Covergirl Vitalist Look Lock Up Setting Spray
  • Specially formulated to set makeup in place, this setting spray provides a reliable shield against smudging and fading, maintaining a fresh and polished look throughout the day. The neutral shade seamlessly complements various skin tones, making it a versatile choice for all. As a key player in the beauty routine, the Vitalist Look Lock Up Setting Spray not only extends makeup wear but also enhances its vibrancy. The lightweight and non-sticky formula is designed for comfort, leaving the skin with a natural feel while locking in the desired look. 

    Scent: Not mentioned

    Finish: Matte

    Cruelty-free: Yes

    Skin Tone: All

    Pros
    • Transfer-proof
    • Smudge-proof
    • Buildable
    • Vegan
    Cons
    • Poor packaging
  • Skindinavia The Makeup Finishing Spray

    Skindinavia The Makeup Finishing Spray
  • This finely crafted setting spray features a long-lasting and sweat-resistant formula, addressing the challenges faced by individuals with oily skin. The light mist, delivered in a fine spray, ensures even and effortless application, setting makeup in place while providing a flawless matte finish that lasts. Ideal for those seeking extended wear without the hassle of constant touch-ups, this dewy setting spray by Skindinavia acts as a reliable barrier against excess shine. The innovative formula not only enhances makeup longevity but also withstands perspiration, making it a go-to choice for those navigating active lifestyles. 

    Scent: Not Mentioned

    Finish: Natural

    Cruelty-free: Yes

    Skin Tone: All

    Pros
    • Dermatologically tested
    • Weightless
    • Smudge-proof
    • Suitable for sensitive skin
    Cons
    • The pump may get clogged often
  • Best Transfer-proof Formula

    Mehron Makeup Barrier Spray

    Mehron Makeup Barrier Spray
  • This innovative product goes beyond its primary function, acting as a protective barrier that helps seal and secure makeup in place. The setting spray enhances the longevity of makeup applications, preventing smudging and ensuring a flawless finish throughout the day or night. Mehron's formula is crafted to be gentle on the skin, providing comfort while effectively setting various makeup styles. Whether for everyday wear or special occasions, this makeup-setting facial spray is a dependable choice. It acts as a finishing touch that not only seals the makeup but also contributes to a vibrant and lasting look. I would rate it 5 out of 5 because my skin is super oily, causing makeup to get cakey, yet oddly, it makes my makeup last longer.

    Scent: Not mentioned

    Finish: Liquid

    Cruelty-free: Yes

    Skin Tone: Universal

    Pros
    • Blocks moisture
    • Ultra-long wear
    • Transfer-proof
    • Vegan
    Cons
    • Strong smell
  • Best Lightweight Formula

    Luna Long Lasting Setting Fixer Spary

    Luna Long Lasting Setting Fixer Spary
  • Its micro-fine skin mist delicately envelops the face, ensuring an even and feather-light application that feels virtually weightless on the skin. This setting spray caters to all skin types with its non-drying formula, providing a natural finish that enhances the overall makeup look. As a standout in the world of Korean beauty products, LUNA's Long Lasting Setting Fixer Spray serves as a reliable ally for those seeking enduring makeup results. The longevity-promoting properties of this micro-fine setting mist make it an essential step in any makeup routine, locking in the desired look for an extended period. 

    Scent: Not mentioned

    Finish: Natural

    Cruelty-free:

    Skin Tone: All

    Pros
    • Skin-friendly ingredients
    • Lightweight
    • Sweat-proof
    • Transfer-proof
    Cons
    • Takes a while to dry
  • Best Non-sticky Formula

    One size On Til Dawn Mattifying Waterproof Setting Spray

    One size On Til Dawn Mattifying Waterproof Setting Spray
  • Developed by the renowned Patrick Starr, this dewy setting spray delivers a transformative and long-lasting finish. The innovative formula not only mattifies the skin but also boasts waterproof properties, making it a resilient choice for various occasions. Ideal for those seeking a shine-free look, the facial spray ensures makeup stays impeccable from dusk till dawn. Its fine mist application provides an even and weightless coverage, setting the makeup seamlessly. A reviewer on Amazon said — “My makeup looks fresh and lasts all day, no touching up required except for lipstick.”

    Scent: Lemon and citrus

    Finish: Matte

    Cruelty-free:

    Skin Tone: All

    Pros
    • Absorbs oil
    • Tightens pore
    • Lightweight
    • Non-sticky
    Cons
    • Costly
  • Best for All Skin Types

    Model in a Bottle Makeup Setting Spray

    Model in a Bottle Makeup Setting Spray
  • This setting spray is designed to cater to all skin types, offering a smooth and flawless matte finish that elevates the overall aesthetic. The innovative formula ensures makeup stays in place throughout the day, resisting smudging and fading. The fine skin mist application provides an even and lightweight coverage, allowing for a comfortable and natural feel on the skin. Ideal for those who desire a matte complexion, Model in a Bottle Makeup Setting Spray acts as a reliable ally in any beauty routine. Its versatility and effectiveness make it a go-to choice for individuals seeking a setting spray that delivers on its promise of durability, ensuring makeup perfection from application to the end of the day.

    Scent: Fresh

    Finish: Matte

    Cruelty-free: Yes

    Skin Tone: All

    Pros
    • Cruelty-free
    • Suitable for all skin types
    • Proper packaging
    • TSA-friendly
    Cons
    • Unpleasant scent
  • Best for Daily Use

    Skin Illustrator Blue Marble Water Proof Makeup Setting Spray

    Skin Illustrator Blue Marble Water Proof Makeup Setting Spray
  • Crafted to set and seal makeup, this spray acts as an impermeable shield against environmental factors, ensuring longevity, and preventing smudging or fading. Particularly crucial in the film and entertainment industry, it is revered for creating a waterproof seal that withstands challenging conditions. Its versatile application proves indispensable for artists working on sets, where makeup needs to endure extended hours and diverse challenges.

    Scent:  Not mentioned

    Finish:  Not mentioned

    Cruelty-free:  Not mentioned

    Skin Tone:  All

    Pros
    • Perfect for sensitive skin
    • Gentle
    • Lightweight
    • Great for daily use
    Cons
    • Not transfer-proof
  • Best Grease-free Finish

    Saat Insight Ultra Setting Real Fixer

    Saat Insight Ultra Setting Real Fixer
  • This innovative formula excels in creating a waterproof and mask-proof shield, ensuring makeup durability under various conditions. Ideal for those seeking a long-lasting solution, it controls oil and provides a weightless makeup sealer. The fine mist application enhances comfort, setting makeup seamlessly while maintaining a natural appearance. Whether facing humidity or mask-wearing challenges, this ultra-fine mist stands out as a reliable facial mist, combining innovation and effectiveness for a flawless and enduring makeup experience.

    Scent: Fresh

    Finish: Matte

    Cruelty-free: Yes

    Skin Tone: All

    Pros
    • Mask-proof
    • Easy-application
    • Grease-free finish
    • Vegan
    Cons
    • Starts transferring after a few hours

    Now that you have seen my product recommendations for the best waterproof setting sprays, glance through my buying guide to make an informed purchase.

    What to Look for in a Waterproof Setting Spray?

    When choosing a waterproof setting spray, there are several factors to consider to ensure that it meets your specific needs. Here are some key features to look for:

    Waterproof And Long-lasting Formulation: Check for a dewy setting spray specifically formulated to be waterproof or water-resistant. Look for products that offer long-lasting results to keep your makeup in place throughout the day, even in challenging conditions.

    Spray Type: Consider the spray type that suits your preferences. Some setting sprays come in aerosol cans, while others come in pump or mist form. Choose a type that you find easy to apply evenly.

    Finishing Effect: Determine whether you want a flawless matte finish, dewy, or natural finish. Different setting sprays offer various finishes, so choose one that complements your skin type and desired look.

    Non-comedogenic And Hypoallergenic: Opt for a setting spray that is non-comedogenic and hypoallergenic to reduce the risk of clogged pores and skin irritation. This is especially important if you have sensitive or acne-prone skin.

    Alcohol Content: Consider the alcohol content in the setting spray. While alcohol can help with setting and drying, too much can be drying to the skin. Look for a balanced alcohol-free formula that provides staying power without causing excessive dryness.

    Ingredients: Check the ingredient list for components that may be irritating to your skin. Some setting sprays contain ingredients like essential oils or fragrances, which can be problematic for individuals with sensitive skin.

    Compatibility With Makeup: Ensure that the setting spray is compatible with the makeup products you use. Some setting sprays work better with certain foundations, powders, or other makeup items.

    Ease of Application: Look for a setting spray that is easy to apply and doesn't leave a sticky or heavy feeling on the skin. A fine skin mist that evenly covers the face is ideal.

    Price: Compare prices and consider the value for money. While some high-end brands may offer excellent quality, there are also budget-friendly options that provide effective results.

    By considering these factors, you can choose a waterproof setting facial spray that best suits your preferences and ensures your makeup stays in place, even in challenging conditions.

    Conclusion

    After extensive experimentation and research, my verdict on the best waterproof setting sprays is crystal clear. Urban Decay's All Nighter Waterproof Setting Spray emerges as the undisputed champion in the realm of makeup longevity. Its formidable formula creates an impermeable shield, locking in my makeup through rain, sweat, and tears. The fine mist evenly blankets my face, ensuring a flawless finish that withstands the elements. Not only does it deliver on its promise of water resistance, but it also boasts impressive staying power without compromising comfort. Other contenders may hold their ground, but Urban Decay's All Nighter surpasses them all in providing an unparalleled level of protection and endurance. As I navigate my day confidently, I can trust that my makeup remains impeccable, thanks to the steadfast performance of this exceptional setting spray. It has undoubtedly become my go-to ally for a flawless, water-resistant makeup finish that stands the test of time.

    FAQ's

    Does waterproof setting spray work better than powder?
    Waterproof setting spray and powder serve different purposes. While powder helps control shine and sets makeup, a waterproof setting spray forms a protective barrier against moisture. The choice depends on the desired outcome; for long-lasting wear in challenging conditions, a waterproof setting spray tends to be more effective than powder alone.
    Do waterproof setting sprays clog pores?
    High-quality waterproof setting sprays are formulated to be non-comedogenic, meaning they shouldn't clog pores. Look for products labeled as such, ensuring they provide a protective barrier without compromising skin health. Always follow proper skincare routines to maintain a clear complexion while enjoying the benefits of a waterproof setting spray.
    When should you apply a waterproof setting spray?
    Apply a waterproof setting spray as the final step in your makeup routine. Once your makeup is complete, hold the spray about arm's length away and mist it evenly over your face. This locks in your makeup, creating a water-resistant barrier that helps it withstand environmental factors throughout the day or night.
    How does a waterproof setting spray work?
    A waterproof setting spray works by forming a protective layer over your makeup. Typically, it contains polymers and film-forming agents that create a barrier on the skin. This barrier repels moisture, making the makeup resistant to water, sweat, and other environmental factors, ensuring long-lasting wear and a fresh look.
    Are waterproof setting sprays suitable for sensitive skin?
    Many waterproof setting sprays are formulated to be gentle and suitable for sensitive skin. Look for products labeled as hypoallergenic or designed for sensitive skin. It's advisable to patch-test before full application to ensure compatibility, as individual sensitivities can vary.

    Why Trust Pinkvilla

    In pursuit of an impeccable makeup routine, Sayantani embarked on a quest to find the ultimate waterproof setting spray. Recognizing the importance of a reliable product in maintaining a flawless look, her review journey began by meticulously researching various brands and formulations. Testing each spray under diverse conditions, from rain to humidity, she evaluated their longevity, smudge resistance, and overall performance. Detailed comparisons highlighted the pros and cons, empowering her readers to make informed choices. Through this review, she aimed to streamline the selection process, offering a comprehensive guide to the best waterproof setting sprays for those seeking makeup perfection in any weather.

    Our product experts study the specifications of every product we suggest and try them out to bring what’s proven to be worthy of your money, time, and energy. We also have subject matter experts from various fields like Fashion, Skincare, Haircare, Home Decor, and Health & Fitness onboard to make sure our suggestions are credible and trustworthy. You can trust Select to be your faithful shopping guide for all the right reasons!

    Author BIO
    reviewer
    Sayantani Deb
    Makeup & Beauty Writer

    Sayantani is a certified hair and makeup professional turned writer with 2+ years of experience in the same genre. Ap More