When it comes to drugstore cosmetics, I realized that not all products are manufactured consistently or identically, especially if the products are meant to complement every skin tone. But when I started applying these products to know the quality standards, I was stunned. These easy-to-apply cream eyeshadows are really creamy and slide over my eyelids without tugging or pulling on my skin. Even social media handles are raving about their creamy and light textural effects on the skin.

After using powder shadows for a while, I realized that there is hardly little fallout to worry about with cream eyeshadows. “Your eye makeup says so much about you and your style,” says Laura Mercier to those who prefer using conventional eye makeup palettes. After trying and testing out the safest and most dependable cream eyeshadows on the market, I have put together a list of the 15 best drugstore cream eye shadows, including some oldies and others newer-to-the-market bestsellers for you. You may never go back to "conventional" eyeshadow palettes after trying these multifunctional creamy and cream-to-powder formulations.

• 1
  Best All-rounder

  Alleyoop 11th Hour Cream Eyeshadow

  Buy on Amazon

When I tried Alleyoop 11th Hour Cream Eyeshadow it gave an incredible payoff. For ultimate shine and longevity in wear, you must have this in your kit. The twist-up mechanism gave me the advantage of easy application and I could easily carry it any bag for travel and wear. Throw away the hassles of carrying a big palette when you can have this quick fix in your pocket anytime. It's crafted with jojoba oils for that creamy and smooth finish that gave me a glistering look all day.

2

Best Variety-based Eyeshadow

DE'LANCI Smokey Grey Black Eyeshadow Palette

Buy on Amazon

Though carrying big palettes is not what I like, it's irresistible to not use this palette. The variety in shades and glitters allows you to sport any eyeshade with ease. Carrying this smokey grey-black palette is convenient with its portable design. It has a velvety texture to it that gave me long-lasting wear and high pigmentation without fallout. The shades in the palette can be mixed and matched for neutral and party wear looks any day.

3

Best Non-Comedogenic Eyeshadow

e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyeshadow Bite-Size Eyeshadow

Buy on Amazon

e.l.f. Cosmetics Eyeshadow Bite-Size Eyeshadow is one of my top picks for its sheer and stylish palette. When tried, it glided on my skin with ease and gave a raw shimmery glow to my eyes. The ingredients are claimed to be chemical-safe and stayed on for a long time. When using this eyeshadow palette, I prepped my eyes with an eye primer to set the base evenly. Then I applied my fave eyeshadow shade with a steady hand, and voila! A soft and glistening shade remained on my eyelids for quite some time. You too can get yourself a sizzling hot look for your date with this eyeshadow.

4

Best Drugstore Cream Eyeshadow For Mature Eyes

Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Cream Matte Natural Eyeshadow

Buy on Amazon

After some great shimmer shadows suggestions, I tried the neutral shades of  Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Cream Matte Natural Eyeshadow. When applied, I realized that its perfect for daily and office wear. The ingredients like shea butter, rosehip, vitamin E, and jojoba oil created a skin-softening and moisturizing experience for me. The product provided a natural and smooth finish. The cream eyeshadow with its anti-aging properties also helps seal wrinkles and crease lines.

5

Best Longevity

Maybelline Eyestudio ColorTattoo Metal 24HR Cream Gel Eyeshadow

Buy on Amazon

I don't wear makeup every day, but when headed for a party getting the right tone of glitz and longevity can be hard. But when I tried Maybelline’s Eyestudio ColorTattoo Metal 24HR Cream Gel Eyeshadow it created an intensely saturated color that was vibrant and eye-catchy. The cream-gel formula settles onto my skin conveniently, and the vibrant color stayed put through the night. I found it perfect for nighttime wear for the satisfying glow it gave me.

6

Revlon So Fierce Prismatic Eyeshadow Palette

Buy on Amazon

As I read through the 5k reviews on the product, I realized I had to try it out for its feedback. Revlon So Fierce Prismatic Eyeshadow Palette is the best drugstore cream-based eyeshadow on my list for its pearly and crystal finish. It adds the right amount of multi-dimensional color and pops with intensity when applied. Just like the name suggests, it helps maintain my fierce and chic side with the intense glow it offers. Psst.. the purple shade looks very pretty on cool shade outfits.

7

Cream Stay Shadow Stick by Glo Skin Beauty

Buy on Amazon

When I tested the Cream Stay Shadow Stick by Glo Skin Beauty on the back of my hand, the shade had a very rich and smooth pigment behind it. When I applied it on my eyelids, the pigment lasted for almost 10 hours in single use, keeping intact and giving me a metallic eye look. Even though the eyeshadow selection has various shades, all come in a glitter finish leaving you asking for more in neutral tones. It's the best drugstore cream eyeshadow stick for the convenience of use and the result is astonishing.

8

Crème Eyeshadow Palette by Revlon

Buy on Amazon

This cream palette is incredibly simple to use and blend, and if you're rushing late for work or a party and only have a few minutes (my procrastination habit is plaguing me), this eyeshadow is a fantastic answer. Furthermore, the finish left my lids with a glowy and captivating eyeshade when I applied it. I tested it alone, over a primer, and with a powder palette over base for more depth and character, and each combination produced fantastic results.

9

Almay Velvet Foil Cream Shadow

Buy on Amazon

Packaged in an acrylic tube comes the Almay Velvet Foil Cream Eye Shadow. When I opened the package, it was difficult to remove the product from the tube. But, the pigment and texture are mind-blowing. It is soft as cotton and the shades are buildable. Try deepening the shade for an intense glow. Additionally, the tube is infused with Vitamin E and botanical blends that make it suitable for long wear and are suitable for dry skin.

10

Luxaza Brown Neutral Metallic Eyeshadow Stick

Buy on Amazon

As I was looking for a drugstore eyeshadow that truly lasts through anything, I found Luxaza Brown Neutral Metallic Eyeshadow Stick. This ingenious product is waterproof, meaning it’ll stay on through the heat, humidity, sweat, and tears, you name it. It did not require a single re-touch-up unless you frequently rub your eyes. The stick works as an eyeshadow pen and eyeliner due to its thick tip. It comes with an in-built brush for blending so that you don't dirty your fingertips when traveling or out

11

Sushieki Eyeshadow Stick + Double End Eyeshadow Brush

Buy on Amazon

As I'm someone who likes great deals, I found the ultimate one where I get six eyeshadow sticks at the cost of two. The Sushieki Eyeshadow Stick + Double End Eyeshadow works at your whim whenever desired. It has a twist-up mechanism throwing the need to have a sharpener in hand away forever. Not only does the pigment shine bright it lasts for 5-6 hours in the end without reapplication. The set is perfect to gift a friend if they starting their journey in the makeup space.

12

Any Wear Creme in Anna by Mommy Makeup

Buy on Amazon

Any Wear Creme in Anna by Mommy Makeup is a perfect choice if your sensitive skin stresses out or breaks out with application of any new makeup products. The multitasking creme-to-powder formula consists of zero-to-nothing in chemicals or parabens that may cause itchiness or dry skin. It moistures the top layers and can be worn as anything you like (blush, eyeshadow, highlighter). This can be a great addition to your kit if you like multifaceted eyeshadow products.

Shades:

While some kits have more colors than others, there are a few key hues to look for. To begin, a medium transition shade will be needed to blend between the crease and the lid. To create depth in the eyes, go for one deeper neutral color, such as dark brown or dark grey. Finally, a lighter shade will be needed to emphasize the area above the crease and blend your shadow up into your arches.

Matte vs. Shimmery:

Some kits contain only matte colors, while others contain only shimmering shadows, and several contain both. Choosing between matte and sparkly eyeshadows comes down to your choice. Shimmer and glitter shadows, on the other hand, work well for highlighting, whilst flat hues are frequently used as a basis. We recommend having a matte alternative on hand for mixing and color development.

Versatility:

When you're on the road and have limited room in your makeup bag, a neutral kit with a multi-use formula will come in handy. Eyeshadows are frequently designed to be multi-purpose, allowing you to utilize them on your face or body. I like to use some of my pink shadow tones as blush and some glitter hues as a highlighter on the high points of my cheeks. Deeper shadows can be utilized to contour as well.

As someone who rummages through her kit for variety and creamy texture-based eyeshadows, it gets hard to keep track of multiple palettes. I was relieved when I wrote about the best drugstore cream eyeshadows that gave me insights on how to get the best value in eyeshadows. One of my favorite choices would be Alleyoop 11th Hour Cream Eyeshadow for its distinct features. It comprises every good quality you need in your eyeshadow, making it the best option. The above-mentioned cosmetics range is carefully read through and is picked especially as per your well-wishes. May you find this list as a helping hand in your tough decision of choosing the best eyeshadow. Happy Shopping!