Some people prefer using a lip liner that is much darker than their lipstick shade to enhance the definition of their makeup look. And, while not everyone’s cup of tea, the best black lip liners are quite sought after by some makeup enthusiasts who understand the miracles they can create and how versatile their usage is in makeup. Especially for cosplays and Halloween-esque makeup looks, fine black lippers come in handy in creating vivid outlines and shapes that help the makeup come to life! Love emo and gothic makeup looks? You’ll need everything black in your makeup stash — lip-liners included. 

Now, being a makeup expert and beauty writer for years, I’ll admit that I had never actually tried black lip-liners before. Hence, when working on this article, I was quite excited to explore products from different brands, some of which impressed me quite a lot! The product reviews below entail insights from my experiences and research, as well as those of other customers worldwide, so you’ll get a good idea about them. So, let’s get right into it!

• 1
  Best Pigmentation

  NYX Professional Makeup Mechanical Lip Liner Pencil

  Buy on Amazon

Like literally every other lip product from NYX Professional Makeup, this black lip liner pencil impressed me quite a bit! Its fine tip aided in creating precise lines, and its retractable dispensation eliminated any need for a sharpener — something I always appreciate in lip liners! 

Moving on, its smooth formula glided quite effortlessly over the contours of my lips, without any spillage or smudges! Owing to these features, I found this to be quite convenient to use — like a product that you can apply on the go too! And, despite having a resilient formula, the liner worked well when I only applied some clear gloss on the center of my lips and gave a nice, gradient look that I aimed for. Cherry on the top? Its formula is quite long-lasting!

2

Creamiest Texture

Barry M Cosmetics Lip Liner Pencil

Buy on Amazon

A darker lip liner compared to others on the list, this pencil formula from Barry M has a creamy texture that smoothly glides onto the lips, allowing for an effortless application and easy blending. The black shade offers versatility that enhances various lip colors and styles with its bold and dramatic effect. Flaunt a classic red lip or a sultry dark look with this cream liner that will provide the perfect base for a polished finish. Its sleek pencil design makes it convenient for on-the-go touch-ups, fitting easily into any makeup bag or purse.

3

Best Long-lasting Formula

Ruby Kisses Auto Lip Liner

Buy on Amazon

This amazing lip liner pencil from Ruby Kisses offers not only precision but also convenience. It features a retractable design for seamless application without the need for sharpening. I love how its smooth formula glides onto the lips easily, delivering even strokes to enhance the lip shape. 

You can wear it alone for a bold statement or pair it with your favorite lipstick to create a look of extra depth — this lip liner pencil always delivers outstanding results. And, its intense black shade adds drama and dimension to any makeup look.

4

Best Budget-friendly

L.A. Girl Lipliner Pencil

Buy on Amazon

This versatile black lip pencil has a creamy texture that effortlessly glides onto the lips, ensuring smooth and precise application. You may outline your lips for extra definition or fill them in for a bold look using this lip liner for an intense color payoff. Its deep black shade is great for adding a touch of drama to your makeup look, thus complementing your lip color and style. And, it is formulated to prevent feathering and smudging, this lip liner pencil ensures your lip look stays flawless throughout the day.

5

Best Packaging

Italia Black Italia Eye Lip Liner Pencil - Set of 5

Buy on Amazon

This comprehensive set offers an array of five rich black shades, perfect for defining both eyes and lips with precision and style. Each pencil comes with a creamy formula that glides effortlessly onto the skin, thus helping with hassle-free smooth application. 

Italia’s black lip liner, when used to outline your lips for added definition, will deliver intense pigmentation and versatile results. The comes with a sharpener that gives a fine tip to the formula for precise application, while its compact design makes it travel-friendly and perfect for on-the-go touch-ups.

6

Best Smudge-proof Formula

ISMINE One Black Lip Liner

Buy on Amazon

This professional matte lip pencil offers a waterproof and long-lasting formula for smooth and natural-looking lips. With its rich black hue, it adds depth and intensity to any lip color or style. The creamy texture glides effortlessly onto the lips, ensuring precise application and seamless blending. 

You can use it to outline the lips for added definition or to fill them in for a bold mattifying finish as this lip liner pencil provides impeccable results that stay put throughout the day.

7

Best for On-the-Go Touch-ups

By The Clique Premium Lip Liner

Buy on Amazon

This versatile pencil is perfect for creating goth-inspired looks, Halloween makeup, or miming performances. Its rich black matte finish provides intense pigmentation for dramatic lip and face coverage, allowing you to confidently express your unique style. 

The creamy formula glides smoothly onto the skin, ensuring precise application and smooth blending. This pencil will deliver impeccable results that last throughout the day or night and you can use it to outline your lips for a bold statement or define your features for a captivating look.

8

Smoothest Formula

L.A. Colors Lipliner Pencil

Buy on Amazon

With its creamy formula, this lip liner pencil from L.A. Colors effortlessly glides onto the lips, providing smooth and even application. The deep black shade adds intensity and drama to any lip look, complementing a wide range of lip colors and styles. 

It has a retractable design, so you don’t have to bother with sharpening, and can get a smooth top and precise application with great ease. Hence, it is a good pick for on-the-go touch-ups. Formulated to prevent feathering and smudging, this lipliner pencil helps maintain a flawless lip look throughout the day.

9

Best Transfer-proof Formula

Layla Cosmetics Lip Liner Pencil

Buy on Amazon

This lip liner pencil features a rich and creamy formula that effortlessly glides onto the lips, allowing for smooth and even application. The deep blackberry tone adds depth and dimension to your lips, thus complementing a range of lip colors and styles. Of other products, you can truly count on this lip liner to prevent smudging and feathering.

Now that you have seen my product recommendations for the best black lip liners, glance through my buying guide to make an informed purchase.

Choosing the right black lip liner can enhance your overall makeup look and ensure your lips appear defined and polished. Here are some tips to help you choose the perfect black lip liner:

Consider Your Skin Tone: Skin tone plays a crucial role in selecting makeup shades, including lip liners. If you have fair skin, you might want to opt for a softer black liner or one with a hint of charcoal to avoid a harsh contrast. For medium to deep skin tones, a true black liner tends to stand out more vibrantly.

Texture: Lip liners come in various textures, including pencil, retractable pencil, and gel formulas. Choose a texture that you feel comfortable applying and that complements your preferred lipstick finish. Pencil liners offer precision and control, while gel formulas may smoothly glide on.

Finish: Consider the finish you desire. Matte lip liners help to create a classic look and work well to make clean lines. Alternatively, if you prefer a shiny or glossy finish, you might opt for a creamy or gel lip liner.

Longevity: Look for a long-lasting formula, especially if you're wearing the lip liner underneath lipstick or alone for extended periods. Waterproof or smudge-proof options can help prevent feathering or fading throughout the day.

Pigmentation: Ensure the lip liner has rich pigmentation for bold and defined lips. Test the product on your hand or wrist to check its opacity before purchasing.

Personal Preference: Ultimately, choose a black lip liner that you feel confident and comfortable wearing. Experiment with different shades and formulas to find what works best for you and complements your individual style.

By considering these factors, you can select a black lip liner that enhances your lips, complements your overall makeup look, and meets your preferences and needs.

1. Start by exfoliating your lips to remove any dead skin and create a smooth canvas. You can use a lip scrub or gently rub a soft toothbrush over your lips. Follow up with a hydrating lip balm to moisturize and soften your lips.

2. Begin by outlining your lips with the black lip liner. Start from the center (cupid’s bow) of your upper lip and carefully follow your natural lip line towards the corners. Repeat the same process on your lower lip. 

3. If you want to create the illusion of fuller lips, you can slightly overline them with the black lip liner. Focus on the outer corners and cupid's bow area while keeping the center of your lips more natural-looking.

4. After outlining, fill in your lips with the black lip liner. Use short, feathery strokes to ensure even coverage.

5. If you prefer a softer look, you can blend the black lip liner inward using a lip brush or your fingertip. 

6. Once you've applied the black lip liner, you can layer it with your chosen lipstick shade. Use a lip brush for precise application, especially around the edges.

7. After applying both the lip liner and lipstick, use a small concealer brush or a cotton swab dipped in makeup remover to clean up any uneven edges or mistakes. 

8. For added longevity, you can lightly dust translucent powder over your lips using a fluffy brush. This helps to set the lip products in place and reduce transfer.