Embarking on a journey towards non-toxic eyeliners wasn't just a cosmetic choice for me; it was a conscious decision to prioritize my health and the environment. The realization that traditional eyeliners often contained harmful chemicals sparked my curiosity and concern. I delved into the world of non-toxic alternatives to shield my delicate eye area from potential irritants and toxins.

Curating the best non-toxic eyeliners became a personal mission, driven by the desire to share my findings with others seeking a safer, more sustainable beauty routine. Extensive research led me to brands committed to using natural ingredients and avoiding harmful chemicals like parabens and phthalates. I considered factors like pigmentation, longevity, and cruelty-free practices, ensuring that the curated selection met high standards of performance and ethics.

My recommendation for these best non-toxic eyeliners stems from the conviction that beauty shouldn't come at the expense of well-being. By advocating for products that align with both personal and environmental health, I hope to inspire others to make informed choices for their beauty regimens. The shift to organic eyeliners not only enhances our appearance but also contributes to a healthier, more sustainable beauty landscape.

• 1
  Best Smear-proof

  Lavera Soft Eyeliner Pencil

  Buy on Amazon

This richly pigmented brown shade adds a subtle, natural definition to your eyes, complementing various skin tones. The pencil's smooth and creamy texture glides on effortlessly, allowing for easy application and blending. Whether you're creating a soft, everyday look or a smoldering evening gaze, this eyeliner delivers versatile and long-lasting results. Enriched with natural ingredients, Lavera's formula is gentle on the delicate eye area, making it suitable for sensitive eyes. The convenient pencil design of this brown eyeliner ensures precise control, allowing you to achieve your desired intensity with ease.

Key ingredients: Jojoba, shea butter, vitamins E and C, and sunflower oil

Color: No. 02 Brown

Finish type: Natural

Size: 0.038 oz

Quick tip:

Blend the soft pencil line with a smudging brush to create a subtle, smoky effect, adding depth and intensity to your gaze.

2

Best Creamy Texture

Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil

Buy on Amazon

Mineral Fusion Eye Pencil in Coal is a sophisticated and hypoallergenic black eyeliner designed to enhance your eyes with velvety smooth precision. Infused with soothing chamomile, meadowfoam, and vitamin E, this formula not only defines but also nurtures the delicate eye area. The blend of natural ingredients ensures a gentle application suitable for sensitive eyes. The long-lasting formula offers enduring wear, making it ideal for all-day use. Complementing this eye pencil is the Mineral Fusion So Classy Volume Mascara in black infused with natural ingredients, that not only enhances lash volume but also conditions and strengthens lashes for a lush and healthy look.

Key ingredients: Chamomile, meadowfoam, and vitamin E

Color: Coal

Finish type: Natural

Size:0.04 oz

3

Best Smooth Application

Fifth & Skin Better'n Ur Eyes Eyeliner Pencil

Buy on Amazon

This eyeliner guarantees a smooth application, ensuring a seamless and comfortable experience. Crafted with a commitment to quality, it provides a stunning, long-lasting look without compromising on skin-friendliness. The rich black shade adds depth and definition to your eyes, complementing any makeup style. Hypoallergenic properties make it suitable for even the most sensitive eyes, providing a worry-free experience for those with delicate skin type. Fifth & Skin's dedication to natural ingredients ensures that their eyeliner enhances your beauty without compromising on health.

Key ingredients: Nourishing botanical ingredients

Color: Black

Finish type: Natural

Size: 0.30 oz

4

Best Waterproof Formula

Mia Adora Liquid Eyeliner

Buy on Amazon

This eyeliner ensures all-day wear, providing a reliable solution for various styles such as winged, cat eye, or smudged looks. The gel liner felt tip, with its high pigment intensity, allows for precise application, while the waterproof feature ensures tear-proof and smudge-resistant makeup. Mia Adora's commitment to a non-toxic formula prioritizes the health of your skin without compromising on performance. The pen design eliminates the need for a pencil sharpener and the hassle of stamps, offering a convenient and mess-free application.

Key ingredients: Castor oil

Color: Black

Size: 0.0176 oz

5

Most Highly-Pigmented Formula

ZUZU LUXE Snow Eyeliner

Buy on Amazon

This eyeliner captivates with its pristine white hue, adding a luminous and ethereal dimension to your eyes. ZUZU LUXE, known for its commitment to clean and cruelty-free beauty, delivers a formula that is both gentle and high-performing. The Snow Eyeliner glides on smoothly, allowing for precise application and creative versatility in your eye makeup looks. The rich pigmentation ensures a bold statement while maintaining a refined and sophisticated finish.

Key ingredients: Jojoba oil 

Color: Snow

Finish type: Natural

Size: 0.04 oz

6

Best Sweat-resistant

BaeBlu Natural Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Pencil

Buy on Amazon

This eyeliner offers a harmonious blend of rich pigmentation and hypoallergenic properties, catering to even the most sensitive eyes. The jet-black shade provides a classic and versatile option for defining your eyes with precision. BaeBlu's commitment to organic ingredients ensures that this pencil is free from harsh chemicals, making it a safe and gentle choice for everyday use. The smooth application allows for easy and effortless gliding, creating a flawless finish that lasts throughout the day. 

Key ingredients: Hydrating oils

Color: Black

Finish type: Natural

Size:0.4 oz

7

Best Lasting Definition

ILIA - Clean Line Liquid Liner

Buy on Amazon

This cruelty-free and vegan formula upholds ILIA's commitment to ethical and sustainable practices, allowing you to enhance your eyes guilt-free. The jet-black shade delivers bold and precise lines for a striking and defined look. The clean beauty ethos of ILIA ensures that this liquid liner is free from harmful chemicals, providing a safe option for your delicate eye area. The fine brush tip allows for easy application, whether you're aiming for a subtle everyday look or a more dramatic effect. Pairing seamlessly with ILIA's clean beauty ethos is The Necessary Eyeshadow Palette in Cool Nude, featuring a curated selection of cool-toned, neutral shades that blend effortlessly for a sophisticated and timeless eye look.

Key ingredients: Charcoal powder

Color: Midnight Express, classic black

Size: 0.01 fl oz

8

Best Smudge-resistant

Well People Fresh Lines Liquid Eyeliner

Buy on Amazon

This longwear liquid eyeliner is formulated with a hydrating and smudge-resistant formula, ensuring a clean and defined look without compromising comfort. The rich black shade adds intensity to your eyes, making them stand out with a professional finish. The innovative formula not only enhances your eyes but also nourishes the delicate eye area.

Key ingredients: Aloe, sunflower seed oil, and rosemary

Color: Black

Finish type: Matte

Size: 0.08 fl oz

Quick Tip:

For best results, start drawing the line from the inner corner of the eye, moving outward, and adjusting the thickness as desired.

9

Best Travel-friendly

Pacifica Beauty Longwear Pastel Blue Eyeliner Pencil

Buy on Amazon

This pencil boasts a no-skip formula, ensuring a precise application that effortlessly glides on for a flawless finish. The pastel blue hue adds a pop of vibrant and pigmented color to your eyes, perfect for creating graphic and artistic looks. Infused with the goodness of vitamin E and coconut oil, this eyeliner not only delivers striking results but also nourishes and cares for the delicate eye area. Pacifica Beauty's commitment to clean and ethical beauty is evident in this product, providing a cruelty-free option that enhances your eyes with both style and compassion. 

Key ingredients: Vitamin E and coconut oil

Color: Ocean

Finish type: Glossy

Size: 0.038 oz

10

Best for All Skin Types

Burt's Bees, Defining Eyeliner

Buy on Amazon

This eyeliner, infused with nourishing ingredients, offers a smooth application that glides on with ease. The gilded sage shade, a captivating earthy tone, adds a touch of sophistication to your eye makeup. Burt's Bees, known for its commitment to natural products, ensures that this defining eyeliner is made with gentle, skin-loving healthy ingredients. The formula is designed to enhance your eyes while avoiding harsh chemicals, making it suitable for sensitive skin types. Whether you're going for a subtle everyday look or a more dramatic effect, Burt's Bees defining eyeliner delivers lasting color and definition. 

Key ingredients:

Color: Gilded sage

Finish type: Metallic, natural, satin

Size: 0.005 ounce

Now that you have seen my product recommendations for the best non-toxic eyeliners, glance through my buying guide to make an informed purchase.

Choosing a non-toxic eyeliner involves considering various factors, including ingredients, formulation, brand reputation, and personal preferences. Here are some tips to help you select the best non-toxic eyeliner:

• Read the Ingredients List:
  • Look for eyeliners with non-toxic and organic ingredients. Avoid products containing parabens, phthalates, sulfates, synthetic fragrances, and other potentially harmful chemicals.
  • Opt for eyeliners that use plant-based or mineral ingredients, such as jojoba oil, shea butter, aloe vera, and mineral pigments.
• Certifications:
  • Look for products that carry certifications from reputable organizations, such as USDA Organic, Ecocert, or COSMOS. These certifications ensure that the product meets specific standards for organic and natural ingredients.
• Fragrance-Free:
  • Choose fragrance-free eyeliners, as synthetic fragrances can contain harmful chemicals. Fragrance-free options are generally safer for sensitive skin and eyes.
• Hypoallergenic:
  • If you have sensitive eyes, consider hypoallergenic eyeliners. These products are formulated to minimize the risk of allergic reactions.
• Cruelty-Free:
  • Choose eyeliners from brands that are cruelty-free and do not test their products on animals. Look for the Leaping Bunny or PETA cruelty-free logo on the packaging.
• Allergen-Free:
  • Check for common allergens in the ingredient list, especially if you have known allergies. Allergen-free formulations reduce the risk of irritation and adverse reactions.
• Water-Based Formulas:
  • Consider water-based eyeliners, as they are often gentler on the eyes compared to oil-based or wax-based formulas. Water-based eyeliners are also less likely to contain potentially harmful and artificial ingredients.

Remember that personal preferences play a role in choosing the right non-toxic eyeliner. Always check the product details and choose an eyeliner that aligns with your values and skin sensitivities.