13 Best Tubing Mascaras for a Lash Extension Effect

Written by Sayantani Deb, Makeup & Beauty Writer
Updated on Feb 15, 2024
Best Tubing Mascara
The products curated for this article are independently chosen by the editorial team. If you make a purchase through the links mentioned below, we may receive a commission. Check out our product research & curation process

Enhance the contour and allure of your eyes with the best tubing mascaras. They create a stunning effect like false eyelashes and give you a naturally defined and volumized look. Whether you want full volume and curl, or captivating length and slenderness, as per our expertise, we can assure you that tubing mascaras deliver all looks with no flaking, smudging, and running. Unlike conventional mascaras, these long-lasting mascaras do not smudge, even when you have super oily eyelids.

The innovative tubing technique builds volume and lengthens lashes in rich pigments. They use a polymer that sticks to your individual lashes like tiny tubes. These tubes do not flake easily, are water-resistant, and work great for sensitive eyes. The flakeless mascara stays on your lashes, preventing any residue from clogging pores and ducts. They do not fall in your eyes or get caught under the lids, even when you apply coats of mascara. As per our expertise, here is a list of some of the most high-performing clean mascaras that have a cruelty-free, vegan formula with no harmful chemicals.

What Mascara is Tubing Mascara?

Unlike traditional mascaras which coat your eyelashes with pigments, tubing mascaras wrap each lash in water-resistant, tube-like enclosures. The bold pigments and volume-building fibers thicken, separate, and dramatically lengthen lashes. It delivers maximum clump-free definition. Although the formula is easy to remove, it resists clumping. As the formula is not oil-based, tubing mascaras do not flake or smear.

13 Best Tubing Mascaras

Say goodbye to raccoon eyes with the new tubing formula from Essence. It volumizes and defines lashes without creating a mess. The buildable formula coats the lashes in an intense color that lasts all day long. With over 8000 global ratings on Amazon, a user has stated, "I am one of those people that no matter what mascara I wear, I have Racoon eyes within an hour or 2. Not this one. It came today and immediately tried it and Holy Moly, it's been 6 hours and nothing underneath the eye. I just re-applied too! For a darker look not because I had to. It's perfect, natural looking and I won't ever buy a different one again.

Pros
  • Smudge-proof
  • Flake-free
  • Clump-free 
  • Easy to remove
  • Safe for sensitive eyes
Cons
  • Not waterproof 
  • Best Long-lasting

    Blinc Amplified Tubing Mascara

    Blinc Amplified Tubing Mascara
  • Clinically tested to be non-irritating, the amplified tubing mascara from Blinc provides incredible volume and length and has water-resistant, sweat-proof, and smear-proof properties. It coats lashes with a glossy and volumizing layer that forms tiny water-resistant tubes around each lash. Our analysis of this product revealed that whether you are hopping from the office to your sweaty workout, or out to dinner, this black mascara will keep your lashes looking as perfect as when you first applied it.

    Pros
    • Long-wearing
    • Flake-free 
    • Easy to apply 
    • Smudge-proof
    • Fade proof
    Cons
    • Clumpy 
  • Best for Sensitive Eyes

    blinc blinc Original Tubing Mascara

    blinc blinc Original Tubing Mascara
  • The original tubing mascara from Blinc forms tiny, water-resistant tubes around your lashes. They bind your lashes and do not smudge, even when you cry or rub your eyes. Ideal for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers, this tubing mascara has an oil-free formula. It amplifies your eyelash's volume and length, providing you with dramatic lashes. Use it with a lash primer for a more enhanced look. The mascara also works great on lash extensions as it does not mess with the glue.

    Pros
    • Flake-free
    • Easy to apply 
    • Easy to remove
    • It does not irritate the eyes
    • Long-wearing
    Cons
    • Not quick-drying 
  • Best Easy-to-remove

    4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara

    4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara
  • Keep your eyelashes intact all day with a super long, thick, and curly finish. The 4D mascara from Mcukv gets evenly distributed on the bristles, delivering naturally dense lashes. The formula is deeply pigmented and creates beautifully dramatic and bold lashes with just a single application. We have found from using this product that it can be easily removed with lotion or warm water without the need for vigorous rubbing. Say goodbye to spidery, flaky, and unnatural-looking lashes.

    Pros
    • Long-lasting
    • Hypoallergenic
    • Waterproof
    • Quick-drying application 
    • Sweat-proof and humidity-proof
    Cons
    • Clumpy
  • Best Lengthening

    My Amazing Lashes Mascara

    My Amazing Lashes Mascara
  • Get intense length and volume without falsies or extensions with the help of this amazing waterproof tubing mascara. It has a gentle formula that does not irritate the eyes and is suitable for all ages and skin types. It contains lengthening fibers that give your eyelashes an instant boost in length and volume. Get a fake lash look with this volumizing mascara. A user has reviewed it, "This is the BEST mascara I have used in a long time. I have tried many, many mascaras. However this is the first time that my lashes look like falsies, it makes your eyelashes long and I have very short and thin eyelashes."

    Pros
    • Non-clumping
    • Non-flaking
    • Water-resistant
    • Long-lasting
    • Quick-drying application 
    Cons
    • Not easy to remove 
  • Best Volumizing

    Kevyn Aucoin The Volume Mascara

    Kevyn Aucoin The Volume Mascara
  • The high-performing mascara from Kevyn Aucoin is crafted with a unique tubing technology to coat each lash with clump-free volume. The small detailing brush reaches into the roots to coat each lash from root to tip. Ideal for smaller eyes, hooded lids, and bottom lashes, it offers an effortless application experience. Infused with glyceryl stearate and jojoba oil, it provides smooth application and healthier lashes. When used with a primer, it delivers a perfect lengthening effect to the lashes.

    Pros
    • Long-wearing
    • Clump-free
    • Flake-free
    • Smooth application 
    • Easy to remove
    Cons
    • The quality is not good
  • Best Curling

    HEROINE MAKE by KISSME Mascara

    HEROINE MAKE by KISSME Mascara
  • This mascara has a new film-type formula with strong water and oil resistance. The advanced waterproof formula contains moment lock ingredients and memory shape polymer that keeps the volume and curl on your eyelash intact all day. Additional natural elements such as camellia oil, royal jelly extract, argan oil, and wild rose fruit extract keep the mascara healthy and long-lasting. Perfect for stubborn straight lashes, it lifts and curls them beautifully, keeping them properly in place.

    Pros
    • Waterproof 
    • Long-lasting
    • Clump-free
    • Humidity-proof 
    Cons
    • Hard to remove 
  • Best Water-resistant

    Black Thrive Mascara

    Black Thrive Mascara
  • Shape and create styling-looking lashes with ELAIMEI's quality tubing mascara. The formula glides smoothly and easily, delivering fuller and thicker multi-dimensional eyelashes. Achieve charming and natural-looking eye makeup by significantly lengthening, separating, and curling each lash with this lengthening mascara. An Amazon user has stated, "This is the perfect tubing mascara! I was a L’Oreal fan for years and then I found this. I hate regular mascara, it’s tough to remove and that drives me crazy. This? Warm water. Easy peasy. It adds a nice amount of length and volume- really, I’m in love with this stuff."

    Pros
    • Clump-free
    • Long-lasting
    • Flake-free
    • Suitable for all occasions
    • Gentle and safe formula
    Cons
    • Not enough pigmented
  • Best Buildable

    Blinc UltraVolume Tubing Mascara

    Blinc UltraVolume Tubing Mascara
  • The Blinc ultra-volume tubing mascara gives length and volume in just a single coat. Ideal for active lifestyles, it delivers problem-free, sleep-lasting wear that is effortless to remove. As indicated by our tests, this tube mascara gives you full and fluffy lashes with highly buildable volume and length in a natural matte finish. And it is so easy to remove, just wet and press your fingers to your lashes to remove the mascara without the need to rub. This mascara is soon going to be your favorite tubing mascara

    Pros
    • Long-wearing
    • Water-resistant
    • Oil-free formula
    • Safe for sensitive skin and contact lens wearers
    • Sweat-proof
    Cons
    • Not flake-free
  • Best Lifting

    tarte tartelette™ tubing mascara

    tarte tartelette™ tubing mascara
  • Tarte's tubing mascara with micro-tubing technology is like a cashmere wrap on your lashes. The lengthening tubes wrap each lash seamlessly without weighing them down. It is clinically proven to provide length, volume, and curl. The thin, conical bristles separate and lift each lash for ultra definition. The formula is infused with conditioning shea butter, castor oil, and lifting plant waxes to help lashes reach full growth. One of the users has reviewed it, "Each tube lasts a long time. It does not dry out. I love this mascara and wouldn’t use anything else! My lashes are finally long!

    Pros
    • Clump-free
    • Long-wearing
    • Flake-free
    • Sweat-proof
    • Lifting and lengthening
    Cons
    • Not easy to use
  • Half-Caked Totally Tubular Mascara

    Half-Caked Totally Tubular Mascara
  • Half Caked's tubular mascara has a cone-shaped plastic applicator that evenly coats every lash, elongating them. It instantly volumizes and lengthens the lashes with its unique tubing formula. Gently work the mascara wand from the base of your lashes to the tips to get a wispy lash extension look. For a dramatically full, fluttery lash look, apply a second coat before the first one dries. One of our favorite mascaras, the formula is neither too wet, nor too dry with intense dark, black pigments.

    Pros
    • Flake-free
    • Transfer-proof
    • Sweat-resistant
    • Easy to remove 
    • Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers 
    Cons
    • It does not hold the curls
  • SHEGLAM 2 In 1 Black Waterproof Mascara

    SHEGLAM 2 In 1 Black Waterproof Mascara
  • This is an all-in-one volume and length mascara that gives you freedom and versatility. It comes with a dual-ended applicator brush with a patented curved brush at one end and an hourglass-shaped brush on the other. The curved brush lifts, lengthens, curls, and separates the lashes while the hourglass-shaped brush gives you instant eye-opening results with shocking volume. After trying out this product, we have found that the 2 different wands offer you effortless mascara application and perfect lashes every time.

    Pros
    • Waterproof
    • Long-lasting
    • Clump-free
    • Buildable formula
    • Lightweight
    Cons
    • Not easy to remove
  • Tubing Mascara

    Tubing Mascara
  • Create softer and fuller-looking lashes with this advanced thickening formula. It dries quickly, allowing you to shape and set the lashes without any smudging or flaking. The large brush head of the built-in wand covers each lash, lengthening and thickening them for an intense volumizing effect. This tube mascara has 4D fibers that transform your lashes from light to dramatic without clumping the lashes. One of the Amazon reviews stated, "I have super oily skin & can never wear mascara to the gym because it runs. I wore this yesterday and didn't run at all! Comes off just like it is advertised. I was skeptical but I'm in love with this mascara & will never turn back!"

    Pros
    • Waterproof
    • Sweat-proof
    • Long-lasting
    • Flake-free
    • Easy to remove 
    Cons
    • Clumps

    Since tubing mascaras contain polymers that do not break down easily with the natural oils in the face, they do not smudge or run. Applying a tubing mascara is similar to that of a normal mascara with only one exception. When applying a second coat with it, you should apply it before the first coat dries. The excess product can be easily removed by gently dabbing with a Q-tip moistened with water.

    How To Choose The Best Tubing Mascara?

    To choose the best tubing mascara, follow these simple steps:

    • Formula: The first thing to keep in mind when selecting a tubing mascara is its formulation. Check whether it uses tubing technology. The package will denote that the formula uses tube or tubular technology.
    • Features: A tubing mascara doesn't smudge, smear, run, or flake like the traditional formulas. The polymers used in the formula stick to each lash and do not budge easily. It gives your lashes volume and curl and stays for long periods.
    • Brush Type: The tubing mascaras come with different types of brushes to deliver different lash looks. Volumizing formulas come with a large, thick brush, curling formulas come with a curved brush, and lengthening formulas have a skinny brush. The formulas that provide full coverage, and natural lash looks come with a tapered brush. Choosing the correct brush type is an essential part of selecting the right mascara for your desired look.
    • Ease of Removal: The beauty of tubing mascaras is its easy removal. It can be removed with just a little warm water without the need for any makeup remover. With gentle pressure and water, the tubes come off easily. 
    • Customer Reviews: Customer reviews will let you know the performance quality of the mascara. Also, you can know whether the mascara you have picked up is a true tubing mascara or not. They will also inform you about how easy or hard the removal process is.

    Conclusion

    Say goodbye to the hassle of choosing a mascara that doesn't smudge or clump your lashes the minute you apply it. Now, you can have both with the best tubing mascaras. They provide you with a full lash fringe that's feathery soft and weightless on your eyes. These tubing mascaras ensure your flawless look lasts throughout the day and well into the night. The lightweight formulas feature intense coloration and the built-in applicators deliver perfect lash separation. They coat each lash evenly preventing clumping. 

    Drawing from our experience, we can say that the best part about tubing mascaras, apart from their no-smudging quality, is the ease of removal. They can be removed easily with a little warm water without any harsh, damaging rubbing. So get one of these smudge-proof mascara and confidently face every moment with lashes that are as captivating and defined as when you first applied the mascara. They are soon going to be your go-to everyday mascara.

    FAQ's

    What is the best tubing mascara that doesn't clump?
    Some of the best tubing mascaras that do not clump are Essence Bye Bye Panda Eyes Tubing Mascara, Kevyn Aucoin The Volume Mascara, and Black Thrive Mascara Waterproof.
    Does Maybelline have a tubing mascara?
    Yes, the Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara is a tubing mascara.
    Is tubing mascara less damaging?
    Yes, tubing mascaras are less damaging when it comes to their removal. Tubing mascaras can be easily removed with water, light pressure, and a piece of cloth. They do not need any tugging or rubbing which keeps your eyelashes safe.
    Is tubing mascara cry-proof?
    Yes, tubing mascara is cry-proof, sweat-proof, smear-proof, and humidity-proof.
    Does tubing mascara come off easily?
    Yes, tubing mascaras come off easily by gently wiping them with just a little warm water.

    Why Trust Pinkvilla

    Sayantani, the author, is a certified makeup expert and today she has brought her readers a list of the best tubing mascaras. Based on her personal experience of struggling to find a mascara that doesn't smudge and can be easily removed without hurting the eyes, her search has brought her to tubing mascaras. She is floored by the top performance of these tubing mascaras and wants her readers to experience the same. Before recommendation, she has gone through each product's ingredient list, performance quality, and customer reviews to bring you the best of the best.

    Our product experts study the specifications of every product we suggest and try them out to bring what’s proven to be worthy of your money, time, and energy. We also have subject matter experts from various fields like Fashion, Skincare, Haircare, Home Decor, and Health and fitness on board to make sure our suggestions are credible and trustworthy. You can trust Select to be your faithful shopping guide for all the right reasons!

    Author BIO
    reviewer
    Sayantani Deb
    Makeup & Beauty Writer

    Sayantani is a certified hair and makeup professional turned writer with 2+ years of experience in the same genre. Ap More