Unleash your inner magnetism with the best mascaras that don’t flake, empowering you to rock stunning lashes all day long. Picture this – you spend all your precious minutes perfecting your eye makeup, achieving a captivating look with precisely lined eyes and carefully blended eyeshadow. The final touch, however, lies in the power of mascara that will elevate your lashes, making them flutter and frame your eyes with elegance. But alas! The joy is short-lived, as you find yourself troubled by the all-too-familiar issue of flaking mascara. Those pesky flakes not only ruin your meticulously crafted look but also leave you feeling frustrated and let down.

Our contributor and a renowned cosmetologist, Ghanima Abdullah says, “You should replace your mascara every 3 months to avoid flaking. This is because mascara can dry out and become clumpy over time, which can lead to flaking. Even dry and hot climates can cause the mascara you apply to dry out excessively. Then again it will flake.”

We've all experienced the disappointment of mascaras that promise voluminous, defined lashes but end up flaking and smudging throughout the day. Our team did some research and carefully curated a list of mascaras that defy flaking and deliver impeccable results. Whether you desire length, volume, curl, or all three combined, we've got you covered. We'll also share some tips and tricks for buying the best non-flaking mascaras and how to use them to achieve the perfect look. Let's dive right in!

• 1
  Best Overall

  REVLON SO FiERCE! Mascara

  Buy on Amazon

The So Fierce! mascara from Revlon is ready to give you the fiercest lashes ever! It is infused with lash-lifting polymers and rice-bran wax that extends and magnifies your lashes to give them a voluminous and extravagant look. Similar to the look of lash extensions, your lashes will remain bold and captivating without the need for touch-ups for up to 24 hours. The innovative formula of this mascara coats each lash evenly and smoothly, ensuring a clean and defined look without any clumping. It's flake-proof, so there are no more worries about falling flakes. The special 252 multi-layer bristles of the wand will coat your lashes with real precision. This mascara is a winning combination of long-lasting wear, clump-free application, a smudge-proof finish, and intense color.

2

Best Non-Flaking Formula

L'ORÉAL PARIS LASH PARADISE

Buy on Amazon

Experience the ultimate lash transformation with this mascara from L'Oréal Paris which is known to be one of the best drugstore mascaras that doesn't flake. It effortlessly enhances the appearance of your lashes, giving a luscious look that elevates the overall allure of the eyes. Its advanced formula ensures a smudge-proof and clump-free finish, allowing you to enjoy long-lasting, defined lashes without any worries. Each application delivers an elongated effect that beautifully frames your eyes. The wavy fiber brush with over 200+ bristles coats each lash with an intense pigment for a full fringe effect. And the best part is that just one coat will give you good coverage.

3

Best Volumizing Formula

MAYBELLINE NEW YORK LASH SENSATIONAL SKY HIGH Mascara

Buy on Amazon

This mascara from Maybelline New York is your ticket to volumized, lengthened, defined, curled, and multiplied lashes, all in one incredible formula. Available in the shade "Very Black," it is time to take your lash game to the next level. Not only does this mascara provide exceptional volume, but it also gives a fantastic lengthening effect. It stretches your lashes to their fullest potential, creating a dramatic and eye-catching effect that enhances your natural beauty. The innovative formula coats each lash from root to tip, ensuring precise separation and a beautifully lifted curl. But wait, there's more! This mascara has a unique multiplying effect, making your lashes appear fuller and multiplied for an ultra-glamorous look. And the best part is that it doesn't flake and is waterproof.

4

Best for Sensitive Eyes

Neutrogena healthy lengths Mascara

Buy on Amazon

This remarkable mascara from Neutrogena will rid you of all your worries about the health of your lashes. Not only does it deliver with its performance, but it also cares for your lashes. Enriched with olive oil, vitamin E, and rice protein, it provides nourishment and strength to your lashes from within. Your lashes will feel soft, conditioned, and ready to dazzle. Its formula doesn't let the mascara clump, smudge, or flake. The soft-bristle brush combs through every lash from root to tip to give it that perfect look.

5

Best Lengthening Formula

Grande Cosmetics Conditioning Peptide Mascara

Buy on Amazon

This volumizing and lengthening mascara from Grande Cosmetics is enriched with peptides, panthenol, and natural waxes. While peptides work to strengthen and fortify lashes, making them look healthier, vitamin B5 locks in moisture to protect the lashes from breakage. The special brush design lifts and separates the lashes, creating a dramatic lash effect that is both voluminous and long-lasting. The mascara is also water-resistant, so you can wear it without worrying about it smudging or running. It is easy to remove with a makeup remover, so you can keep your lashes looking their best. It is also designed to resist flaking and smudging, ensuring your lashes stay flawless throughout the day. Enjoy the confidence of knowing your eye makeup remains intact, even during busy or active moments.

6

Best for Definition

essence Lash PRINCESS false lash effect mascara

Buy on Amazon

Next up is a mascara from essence that will give you a false lash look without any hassle. Prepare to be amazed as this mascara works its magic, delivering phenomenal length and volume to your lashes. The conic shape fiber brush sculpts individual lashes for definition & volume, without any clumps or globs. This mascara is gluten-free and cruelty-free, so you can feel good about using it. The formula is also long-lasting, so you can go about your day without worrying about your mascara flaking or fading. Swipe on a single coat for a casually chic and softly volumized look, or layer on 2-3 coats for an intense, captivating, and glamorous effect that's perfect for a night out on the town!

7

Best Pigmentation

Elizabeth Arden Standing Ovation Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Let your lashes do all the talking with Elizabeth Arden's Standing Ovation Mascara in the shade "Intense Black". This mascara is more than just a part of your makeup routine – it is the confidence boost that you didn't know you needed! It has a smooth formula that paints your lashes a deep black shade while also pampering them, leaving them feeling soft and conditioned. Plus, it's formulated to be a trusty friend that won't let you down – the smudge-free and flake-free properties ensure that your gorgeous look stays flawless and put all day long.

8

Secret Xpress HEAVY FULL FIGURE Mascara

Buy on Amazon

This mascara from Secret Xpress is perfect for anyone who wants to achieve long, thick, and voluminous lashes. The one-of-a-kind 4D silk fiber formula coats each lash individually, instantly enhancing their thickness and providing a fuller appearance. You can say goodbye to sparse and thin lashes and its long-lasting formula ensures that your lashes stay intact throughout the day. Enjoy the confidence of smudge-proof lashes that maintain their fullness and length, no matter what activities you engage in. Due to the non-irritating ingredients used, the mascara is kind to the eyes and is safe for use even if you are wearing contact lenses.

9

Best Cruelty-free Formula

pretty VULGAR Faux Reals EXTREME VOLUME MASCARA

Buy on Amazon

Prepare to steal the spotlight and flaunt your breathtaking, smudge-proof lashes that are bound to make an unforgettable impression. Give them a load of drama with Pretty Vulgar's Faux Reals Extra Volume Mascara – it comes in a sleek black tube and is the ideal way to get enchanting lashes that are comparable to falsies, that too just in one swipe. Additionally, the formula is clean, cruelty-free, and flake-free, ensuring your lashes stay impeccable all through the day and night.

10

Vivienne Sabó Cabaret Premiere Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Next on our list is this astonishing mascara from Vivienne Sabó. The meticulously crafted formula makes it flake-free and transfer-proof. This lightweight mascara provides a soft and natural look, so you can wear it daily. Its smudge-proof and clump-free formula keeps your lashes flawless throughout the day, ensuring that your look remains impeccable. It adds great length to your lashes, making them appear longer and more defined. Designed for easy application, the petite wand ensures that it coats every lash. With just a single coat, you can achieve beautifully defined and voluminous lashes that make a statement. For an even more striking effect, simply layer on additional coats to create a bold, fanned-out lash appearance that will turn heads.

11

Best Hypoallergenic Formula

Bestidy TWINKLE STARLIGHT LONG CURL MASCARA

Buy on Amazon

Level up your lash game with this impressive mascara by Bestidy. It uses advanced 4D silk fiber technology to create stunning length and volume for your lashes. Prepare to be amazed as each lash is coated with precision, delivering a dramatic and eye-catching look. This mascara is designed to provide a smooth and clump-free application. The special brush separates and defines each lash, ensuring a flawless and even distribution of products. It is formulated to stay put without smudging or flaking, so your lashes remain bold and beautiful from morning until night. Its waterproof formula ensures that your eyelashes stay gorgeous through rain, sweat, and even tears. And when you are done for the day, simply wash it off with warm water or remove it with your favorite makeup remover or cleanser.

12

Best Thickening Formula

Too Faced BETTER THAN SEX MASCARA

Buy on Amazon

Slay those lashes like never before with this amazing mascara from Too Faced! With just a few swipes of the hourglass-shaped wand, your lashes are transformed into absolute stunners. It's like magic in a tube! Not only does the mascara give you volume, but it also adds length and curl to your lashes. To add to the magic, it thickens your lashes while also ensuring that they don't look overdone. It's smudge-proof, clump-free, and long-lasting, so you don't have to worry about raccoon eyes halfway through the day. Whether you're hitting the dance floor, surviving a rainstorm, or sweating it out at the gym, this mascara stays put and keeps your lashes looking flawless.

13

Honest Beauty 2-in-1 Extreme Length Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Create lashes that demand attention and admiration with this 2-in-1 mascara from Honest Beauty. This makeup essential combines the best of both worlds – a lash primer and a mascara, resulting in a mesmerizing lash transformation. Prepare to be enchanted as it effortlessly enhances the length and amplifies the volume of your lashes, creating a truly mesmerizing and magnetic look. Beyond its splendid performance, this mascara also nourishes and conditions your lashes, leaving them healthier and more resilient. With its EWG-verified certification, you can have complete confidence in the clean and safe formula that adorns your lashes. Embrace a conscious beauty lifestyle with this vegan and cruelty-free mascara, showcasing your commitment to ethical choices.

14

Neutrogena healthy volume Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Made with sweet almond and olive oil, this conditioning mascara from Neutrogena offers up to 400% fuller lashes. It helps nourish and build the lashes, making them look naturally thick and luscious. Say goodbye to clumps, smudges, and flakes, as this mascara offers a long-lasting formula that stays put throughout the day. The super-sized volume brush coats each lash with bold, volume-building color from the outside. And at the same time, the rich waterproof formula penetrates the lashes from the inside and helps plump the core of each lash. Get a striking lash look with ease and confidence when you use this product.

15

Mineral Fusion Volumizing Mascara

Buy on Amazon

See for yourself to believe the astounding lash transformation with this special mascara from Mineral Fusion. It has been created by experts with a formulation that adds volume, thickness, and length to your lashes for a stunning and impactful look. Natural ingredients like white tea and aloe vera not only nourish but also condition your eyelashes. The rich, jet-black color enhances the depth and intensity of your lashes, making them appear fuller and more defined. The clump-free and smudge-proof formula ensures long-lasting wear, keeping your lashes flawless throughout the day. The precision brush effortlessly coats each lash from root to tip, allowing for precise application and maximum impact. Elevate your eye makeup game with this mascara and embrace the mesmerizing power of beautifully enhanced lashes.

Choosing the right mascara can make a significant difference in achieving flawless, smudge-free lashes that last throughout the day. Here are some important aspects to look for when selecting your ideal mascara:

Lash effect: Different mascaras offer different applications, such as lengthening, volumizing, or curling. Choose a mascara that aligns with your preferences and the look you want to achieve. Some mascaras even combine multiple effects, offering versatility and customization.

Formula: The formula of the mascara plays a crucial role in preventing flaking. Look for mascaras that are specifically labeled as "flake-free" or "long-wearing." These formulas are typically designed to resist smudging and crumbling, ensuring that your lashes stay intact and clump-free.

Smudge-proof and Waterproof: Smudge-proof mascaras are less likely to transfer onto the skin around your eyes, preventing the dreaded raccoon-eye effect. Waterproof mascaras are particularly beneficial for humid climates, rainy days, or if you tend to have watery eyes. Therefore, go for mascaras that are smudge-proof and waterproof to ensure longevity.

 

Brush Design: The brush design plays a significant role in achieving a clean and even application. Brushes with densely packed bristles or unique shapes, such as hourglass or comb-like brushes, can help ensure precise application and minimize clumps. If you are blessed with long, curled lashes, a mascara wand with a voluminous brush will create captivating, fluttery lashes. And, if you have shorter lashes then a slim, rubber wand will provide effortless grip and precise application.

Allergen-free and Ophthalmologist Tested: If you have sensitive eyes or wear contact lenses, consider mascaras that are hypoallergenic, allergen-free, or tested by ophthalmologists. These mascaras are formulated to minimize the risk of irritation and are suitable for those with sensitive eyes.

Now, let's find out the best way to apply the mascara.

Here's a step-by-step guide to help you achieve flawless, flake-free lashes:

Step-1: Clean Your Lashes

Ensure your lashes are clean and free from any residual makeup or oils. This provides a smooth base for the mascara application.

Step 2: Curl your lashes

Curl your lashes using a curler. If you don’t have an eyelash curler, then wet your lashes and push them up with your fingertips.

Step 3: Wipe off Excess Product

Gently wipe off any excess product from the wand using a tissue or the edge of the tube.

Step 4: Begin at the Base:

Placing the mascara wand at the base of your lashes. Wiggle the wand back and forth slightly to ensure that it coats the roots of your lashes.

Step 5: Sweep Upwards

Using a slow and steady motion, sweep the wand upwards toward the tips of your lashes.

Remember to coat both the top and bottom sides of your lashes for a more thorough application. To further separate and define your lashes, gently comb through them with a clean lash comb or a clean, disposable mascara wand.

In this article, we have mentioned some of the best mascaras that don't flake. This means you won't have those annoying little specks falling onto your cheeks throughout the day. These mascaras work wonders for your lashes, giving them that full, long, and separated look. You don’t have to worry about clumps or messy situations anymore, you'll be rocking flawless lashes like a pro! What's even better is that these mascaras stay put. They won't smudge or smear, so you can go about your day with confidence, knowing your eye makeup is on point. Get ready, it's time to make your eyes shine and feel fabulous!

Contributor: Ghanima Abdullah, Cosmetologist, The Right Hairstyles