14 Best Self-tanners for Sensitive Skin That Deliver Flawless Results

Written by Anoushka Sinha, Skincare Coach & Writer
Updated on Feb 13, 2024
Best Self-tanners for Sensitive Skin That Deliver Flawless Results
The products curated for this article are independently chosen by the editorial team. If you make a purchase through the links mentioned below, we may receive a commission. Check out our product research & curation process

Getting that golden, sun-kissed, and honey-like tan isn’t easy especially if you have sensitive skin. And, we do understand how dreadful it is to fall prey to sunburns and permanent skin damage when you sit under the sun or on your sunbed. So, hey! You need not fear when we are here! Today, we have got you the best self-tanners for sensitive skin. Believe us, they are incredibly good and deliver natural-looking results. There are a few more things that you need to know, like — their increasing demand, pros, cons, benefits, and of course, the right method of application. Let us first begin with how the self-tanners managed to attract large eyeballs. 

In the United States, tanning has become one of the most popular activities. However, cases of skin cancer, rashes, allergies, and dermatitis have been rising at a greater speed. Plus, tanning methods and salons too have come into existence to help you achieve the golden skin of your dreams (1). But, these tend to be expensive and intensive. As a result, there has been an increased demand for self-tanners. 

A majority of topical self-tanning products are enriched with dihydroxyacetone (DHA). These DHA formulations are found in the form of creams, moisturizers, lotions, gels, mousses, wipes, sprays, and mists. To note, DHA is basically a plant-derived sugar molecule that reacts with the amino acids present in the outermost layer of your skin and produces pigment when applied to the skin (1). Furthermore, tanners are balanced out by skin-nourishing ingredients like shea butter, coconut oil, and glycerin, and are not formulated with irritants like synthetic dyes, mineral oil, hydroquinone, or formaldehyde This is when you get a lovely sun-kissed effect without even going under the sun or falling prey to UV damage. Yes, we do know you are curious to know more about these magnificent products available at your fingertips. So, here you go!

Ahead is our all-inclusive list of some really good sensitive skin self-tanners that are worth the value. Take a look!

14 Best Self-tanners for Sensitive Skin

Enjoy a soft, sun-kissed look with COOLA's organic self-tanner. This firming lotion is enriched in anti-aging properties and is Non-GMO. The transfer-resistant product comes with a pina colada scent that instantly transports you to a beach. Made with 99% natural ingredients, the tan continues to build over days. The lotion is also enriched in caffeine which helps your skin look firmer and smoother. An Amazon user penned that she loves this product primarily because it doesn't make her hands orange. Moreover, it leaves no streaks on her skin. She further added that she is "happy with the results." 

Pros
  • Cruelty-free
  • Instant sun-kissed look
  • Little is more
  • Cruelty-free
Cons
  • Might leave the skin dry
  • Best with SPF

    JERGENS NATURAL GLOW Face Moisturizer

    JERGENS NATURAL GLOW Face Moisturizer
  • Our very first recommendation is this fantastic face moisturizer from the brand named Jergens Natural Glow. This moisturizer comes with a broad spectrum of SPF 20 to prevent harmful UVA and UVB rays from damaging your skin. What made this product earn the top spot on our list is the fact that it not only hydrates and protects the skin but also imparts a sun-kissed glow. In addition, it features a lightweight formula and possesses a fresh scent. Overall, it is the perfect product if you wish to tan at the comfort of your home.

    Pros
    • Oil-free
    • Pack of 2
    • Cruelty-free
    • Budget-friendly
    • Best face tanner for sensitive skin
    Cons
    • Very streaky
  • Best for Men And Women

    BEAUTY BY EARTH Self Tanner Tanning Lotion

    BEAUTY BY EARTH Self Tanner Tanning Lotion
  • The next on our list is Beauty by Earth’s tanning lotion for sensitive skin. It is enriched with clean and organic ingredients, such as shea butter, botanical extracts, and aloe vera that make it a safe and skin-friendly product to rely on for the perfect tan at home. Moreover, it features a medium to dark shade for all skin types. The best part — you can apply this lotion all over your body and face. 

    Pros
    • Vegan
    • Paraben-free
    • Lightweight
    • Gender neutral
    • Buildable formula
    • Non-greasy texture
    Cons
    • Thick consistency
  • Best Streak-free Finish

    ST.TROPEZ Classic Self Tan Bronzing Mousse

    ST.TROPEZ Classic Self Tan Bronzing Mousse
  • While researching for the best fake tan for sensitive skin, we came across this one from St. Tropez. It is a flawless tinted tanning mousse that has managed to earn more than 16 thousand ratings on Amazon. We bet you will also love its 100% clean, sulfate-free, long-lasting, lightweight, hydrating, and non-sticky features. Furthermore, this bronzing mousse is dermatologically tested and hence you need not worry about any side effects like redness or inflammation. 

    Pros
    • Easy to apply
    • Quick-drying formula
    • Streak-free finish
    • Ideal for beginners
    • Tan lasts up to 10 days
    Cons
    • Stains the clothes
  • Best Dark Tanner

    b.tan disco candy tan

     b.tan disco candy tan
  • B.tan’s disco candy tan is a fool-proof dark and non-irritating self-tanner for sensitive skin. Our team also glanced through the reviews and comment section of this product and discovered that it is free from parabens and doesn’t contain any artificial ingredients or fragrances. It is infused with 100% natural DHA and has no nasties. In addition, let us tell you that it smells like candies and develops a dark tan in just an hour post-application. 

    Pros
    • Vegan
    • Cruelty-free
    • Sweat-proof
    • Transfer-resistant
    Cons
    • Little sticky texture
  • Best for Sensitive Skin

    Miami Gorgeous Self-Tanning Mousse

    Miami Gorgeous Self-Tanning Mousse
  • Miami’s Gorgeous self-tanning mousse is enriched with the goodness of argan and coconut oils and pure vitamins like A, C, and D. In addition, it features a radiant bronzing complex to help you achieve the desirable tan shade with utmost ease. After putting it to the test, users loved its streak-free results. To note more, this mousse is also fast absorbing, delivers natural-looking results, and is suitable for all skin types. 

    Pros
    • Paraben-free
    • Gluten-free
    • Pocket-friendly
    • Nourishes the skin
    • Dries quickly
    • Suitable for men and women
    Cons
    • Unpleasant scent
  • BOTANIC TREE Faux Glow Sunless Tanning Lotion

    BOTANIC TREE Faux Glow Sunless Tanning Lotion
  • Based on our team’s first-hand research, we found out that Botanic Tree’s faux glow tanner is undoubtedly the best sunless tanner for sensitive skin for a couple of reasons. Firstly, it is paraben and cruelty-free. Secondly, it is suitable for all skin tones and types. Lastly, it is loaded with the soothing, moisturizing property of shea butter and aloe vera. In addition, this lotion is very easy to apply and doesn’t leave behind orange-ish hues.

    Pros
    • Absorbs quickly
    • Hydrating
    • Long-lasting results
    • A little goes a long way
    Cons
    • Sticky texture
  • Best Skin-loving Ingredients

    body drench QUICKTAN

    body drench QUICKTAN
  • The beauty of Drench’s Quicktan lies in the list of its natural and organic ingredients, such as aloe vera, sea kelp, black walnut, orange extract, etc. We also glanced through the features of this product and were surprised to see that it is gentle and highly effective. It is also rich in antioxidants and works well in nourishing, moisturizing, and soothing your skin. Undoubtedly, users have awarded it as the best sunless tanner for sensitive skin.

    Pros
    • Great coverage
    • Affordable
    • Long-lasting results
    • Dermatologically-recommended
    • Quick absorbing
    Cons
    • Streaky
  • Best for All Skin Types

    + Lux Unfiltered N°12 Bronzing Face Drops

    + Lux Unfiltered N°12 Bronzing Face Drops
  • For all those looking out for a fragrance-free, vegan, cruelty-free, and the best facial self-tanner for sensitive skin, look what we found for you — + Lux Unfiltered N°12 Bronzing Face Drops. Our investigation demonstrated that this tanning product is enriched with skin-benefitting ingredients, such as hyaluronic acid, coconut water, pomegranate extract, vitamin E, and passion fruit oil. All these ingredients are blended well to turn your complexion bronze. Not just that, the face drops also keep your skin glowing and hydrated.

    Pros
    • Sulfate-free
    • Gluten-free
    • Mess-free application
    • Best for all skin types
    Cons
    • Unpleasant smell
  • Best Non-greasy Formula

    VICHY LABORATORIES Capital Idéal Soleil Moisturizing Self Tanning Milk

    VICHY LABORATORIES Capital Idéal Soleil Moisturizing Self Tanning Milk
  • Creamy consistency, hydrating formula, and streak-free results are the three main reasons why we recommend you to buy this alluring moisturizing self-tanning milk from the brand named Vichy Laboratories. Our findings show that this sensitive skin-approved self-tanner is recommended by dermatologists. Moreover, it is loaded with vitamin E and Vichy volcanic water. Plus, it is safe, clean, and develops quickly.  Addedly, it also builds up easily with multiple applications so that you can achieve a lovely sun-kissed glow effortlessly. 

    Pros
    • Natural-looking tan
    • Paraben-free
    • Non-greasy texture
    • Allergy-tested
    Cons
    • Difficult to spread
  • Best Lightweight Formula

    Sun Laboratories Strictly Faces

    Sun Laboratories Strictly Faces
  • Here comes another best face tanner for sensitive skin from Sun Laboratories. Our research also indicates that this self-tanner is the go-to product for an instant tanned glow. Secondly, dermatologists recommend this product to everyone who wishes to attain a darker skin tone without any fear of rashes or allergies. What we also liked about this face tanner is its sugar-based formula and organic and paraben-free ingredients that leave your skin feeling utterly refreshed! 

    Pros
    • Easy to apply
    • Dries quickly
    • Ideal for all skin types
    • Lightweight formula
    Cons
    • Prone to leakage
  • Dave's Professional Self Tanner

    Dave's Professional Self Tanner
  • The best tanning lotion for sensitive skin is right at your screen. Yes, we are talking about Dave’s Professional self-tanner. Based on our observations, this lotion is crafted from skin-enhancing ingredients, such as organic and natural argan oil, aloe barbadensis gel, jojoba oil, and sesame. Furthermore, it has been field tested and designed for all skin types. So, anyone who desires for a medium to dark tan, this is a great option to consider. 

    Pros
    • Good scent
    • Very moisturizing
    • Natural-looking results
    • Easy-to-spread formula
    Cons
    • Slow results
  • Clarins Self Tanning Milky Lotion

    Clarins Self Tanning Milky Lotion
  • You are just one product away from achieving the sun-kissed glow of your dreams. Yes, we are talking about Clarins self-tanning milky lotion. Our analysis of this product revealed that the tanning lotion lends you long-lasting results. In addition, it comes with a luxurious blend of glycerin, natural fig extracts, and aloe vera to make you glow luminously from within. Overall, the product is organic and melts on your skin like butter. 

    Pros
    • Buildable
    • Recyclable packaging
    • Non-staining
    • Provides 24-hours hydration
    Cons
    • Pricey
  • Coco & Eve Sunny Honey Bali Bronzing Foam

    Coco & Eve Sunny Honey Bali Bronzing Foam
  • While researching for the best self-tanners for sensitive skin, we came across this one from Coco & Eve. It is a luxe tanning mousse backed with anti-cellulite, antioxidants, and moisturizing properties. What left us impressed was the fact that it doesn't leave behind any blotches or nasty streaks. Another plus point of investing in this product is its ingredients. It is infused with botanicals, raw virgin coconuts, and amino acids to moisturize your skin and blur stretch marks and pigmentation.

    Pros
    • Vegan
    • Non-sticky formula
    • Leaves no streaks
    • Dries quickly
    • Cruelty-free
    Cons
    • Prone to leakage

    That's all folks! This was our comprehensive list of some top-notch sensitive skin-friendly self-tanner products that you can splurge on without any second thoughts. Now, let us run you through our detailed buying guide and a few steps to use them correctly. 

    How to Choose the Best Self-tanner for Sensitive Skin?

    Here are a few aspects that you should consider before snapping up a self-tanner for sensitive skin - 

    Skin Type: Always analyze your skin type before purchasing any of the fake tanners. Some of them are meant only for mature skin, acne-prone skin, pasty skin, premature aging skin, and dry skin types. You can vouch for any of the gradual tanners or a tanning mist that do not cause skin irritation.

    Types of Tanners: Investing in the best hypoallergenic self-tanner is easy when you know what you want. Hence, ensure that you jot down the purpose of buying one before starting your hunt. Understand the various types of tanning products available and then pick the one that suits you the best. There are tanning mousses, wipes, sticks, sprays, drops, body tanners, and facial self-tanner for sensitive skin. If you possess dry skin, pick tanning lotions or moisturizers to hydrate your skin. On the other hand, professional or frequent users may invest in mousse, sprays, and mists as they tend to be more strong, light in weight, dry quickly, and develop the tan faster than the rest. So, go through the pros and cons and then buy the one that complements your needs.

    Ingredients: Always check the list of non-active and active ingredients before you splurge on a self-tanner for sensitive skin. They should be enriched with natural and organic ingredients. A few of the skin-enhancing ingredients are mentioned below: 

    - Oils: Argan, primrose, rosehip, mandarin, olive, coconut, and jojoba oils are known for their hydrating and moisturizing properties. Hence, it is great if your self-tanner contains any of these natural and organic oils. 

    - Aloe Vera: It softens, soothes, nourishes, rejuvenates, and moisturizes your skin deeply, and gives you the desired subtle glow. 

    - Shea Butter: This is yet another effective ingredient that takes good care of your skin. It not only helps in softening and smoothening your skin but also plays a key role in leaving your skin moisturized.  

    Formula And Texture: Make sure you vouch for a gentle self-tanner for sensitive skin. It should be free from harmful chemicals, artificial substances, synthetic ingredients, and faux fragrances. You can invest in a body lotion with gradual formula and buildable color. Secondly, you should stay away from products that contain parabens, sulfates, and phthalates. 

    Directions of Usage: Always go through the directions of usage. Do not apply or use any product without prior knowledge. Make sure you do not rely on self-tanners way more than necessary. If you experience any kind of rash, allergy, or irritation, consult with a doctor immediately. 

    After taking note of the above aspects, run through the steps of using self-tanners for sensitive and delicate skin.

    How to Use Self-tanners Safely And Effectively?

    Following are the steps to use the best self-tanner for sensitive skin in the right manner for effective and desired results -  

    Step 1: First prepare your skin. Exfoliate it thoroughly with a scrub. Moisturize your hands, ankles, feet, and wrists if they are very dry or rough. 

    Step 2: Apply the self-tanner on your body or face (as directed) in circular motions. 

    Step 3: Ensuring that there are no missed patches, spread the cream/lotion/ moisturizer/mousse evenly. 

    Step 4: Wait until the applied product gets absorbed completely. Let it rest for some time or as instructed. 

    Step 5: Rinse it under the shower. A medium golden glow will start developing in 4 to 8 hours. 

    Step 6: Layer it for attaining a deeper or darker shade. 

    Conclusion

    That was all about the best self-tanners for sensitive skin that deliver flawless results. Trust us, with these at your hands, nothing can stop you from achieving the phenomenal golden tone and healthy glow of your dreams. We carefully created this list for you and your needs keeping in mind the sensitivity of your skin. So, you don’t have to feel hesitant or scared to indulge in these products. Simply add one to your cart and attain a beachy sun-tanned look just by sitting at home. Happy shopping!

    FAQ's

    Can a self-tanner cause a rash?
    Yes. A self-tanner can cause a rash or allergic reactions because of the tanning formulations. It may also cause itchiness and skin dermatitis.
    Why is my fake tan making me itch?
    Itchiness is generally a symptom of very sensitive skin. So, vouch for a self-tanner that is gentle and packed with natural ingredients.
    Do self-tanners age your skin?
    Yes. Self-tanners and sun contact may accelerate the aging of your skin.
    What is the best self-tanner for older skin?
    The best self-tanner for older skin is one that contains natural and organic ingredients that moisturize and soften the skin.
    Why does fake tan sit in my pores?
    Your fake tan might be comedogenic and possess an oil-based formula, that’s the reason why it sits in your pores.
    Is self-tanner safe for sensitive skin?
    Yes, self-tanners are safe for sensitive skin. They contain natural and organic ingredients.
    What is the safest fake tan?
    The safest fake tan is one that is free from parabens, sulfates, phthalates, and any harmful ingredients.
    Why do I get a rash when I fake tan?
    It might be because of the formulation that doesn't suit your skin. Choose a sensitive-skin-friendly fake tan to avoid rashes.
    What is the most natural self-tanner?
    The most natural self-tanner is the one that is infused with essential oils, aloe vera, and shea butter.
    Should I moisturize before applying sunless tanners?
    Yes. After you exfoliate, apply a moisturizer and then apply the sunless tanner for effective results. This is to hydrate dry patches on your skin.
    When’s the best time to apply a fake tan?
    The best time to apply a fake tan is in the evening and then leave it overnight.
    What do I wear to bed after self-tanning?
    You may wear loose-fitted and dark-colored apparel to avoid staining.
    Can self-tanners for sensitive skin provide a natural-looking tan?
    Yes. Self-tanners for sensitive skin provide a natural-looking tan. One of the best tanners is Beauty by Earth Self Tanner, which is vegan and free from harmful ingredients.
    How long does it take for a self-tanner to develop on sensitive skin?
    A self-tanner might take 4 to 6 hours to develop on sensitive skin and last for a week.
    How often should I apply a self-tanner for sensitive skin to maintain a tan?
    You may apply a self-tanner for sensitive skin after every 3 to 5 days to maintain a tan.

    Why Trust Pinkvilla

    We sent Anoushka, our skincare expert, on a mission to locate the best self-tanners for sensitive skin. She carried out in-depth research so that you can attain that golden, sun-kissed, and honey-like tan of your dreams just by sitting at home. Out of this massive list, her top pick is Beauty by Earth’s tanning lotion which is vegan and paraben-free. For all those who wish to get impeccable tanned skin, her list is what you need to peep into for picking up the best of the best product. 

    Our product experts study the specifications of every product we suggest and try them out to bring what’s proven to be worthy of your money, time, and energy. We also have subject matter experts from various fields like Fashion, Skincare, Haircare, Home Decor, and Health & Fitness onboard to make sure our suggestions are credible and trustworthy. You can trust select to be your faithful shopping guide for all the right reasons!

    1. A Review of Common Tanning Methods

    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4345932/ 

    Author BIO
    reviewer
    Anoushka Sinha
    Skincare Coach & Writer

    Anoushka is certified in Professional Skincare and is a Mass Media (Journalism) graduate from Mumbai University. As a More