Amid winter's chills and thrills, the fear of blending into the snowy landscape can lurk. To sidestep this, I invite you to ignite the scene with the fiery allure of the best copper eyeshadows. My curated list caters to those yearning to break free from classic browns, tans, and nudes, seeking a shimmering shift in their eye game. Copper, reminiscent of flickering flames, adds a dash of vibrancy and depth, setting eyes ablaze with a magnetic charm. The best part — people of all skin tones can pull this off, given they’ve picked a suitable shade of copper for them.

In my quest for the best, I sought formulations that captured copper's essence — vivid, lustrous, and enduring. I delved into a mix of textures, favoring creamy eyeshadow textures for their blendability and powder formulas for intense pigmentation. Testing each hue and finish, I embraced metallic shines for a bold statement and matte iterations for understated elegance. The versatility of this color transcends occasions, shimmering brilliantly at both casual gatherings and formal soirées.

Now, you can scroll ahead without a hitch, armed with insights, for copper eyeshadows for every occasion. Whether it's the glittering glow of a winter ball or the warmth of a cozy fireside chat, these eyeshadows will ensure your gaze stands out, radiating the warmth and luminosity of a flickering copper flame.

• 1
  Most Unique Formulation

  Julep Eyeshadow 101 Crème to Powder Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick

  Buy on Amazon

Amongst my top picks, Julep's Copper Shimmer is a standout in my eyeshadow collection. This eyeshadow stick boasts a shimmery orange-brown hue for a bold eye makeup. With a creamy formula that resists creasing and goes on smoothly, but delivers a non-greasy powder finish like most prefer! It features vitamins C and E, catering to nourish the skin of the eyelids. Additionally, the inclusion of candelilla wax facilitates a hassle-free application process. With over 30 shades available, including matte, shimmer, and metallic finishes, this versatile eyeshadow stick allows you to curate your palette for subtle or bold looks, ensuring you're ready for any occasion, day or night.

Finish: Shimmer

2

Best for Sensitive Eyes

Maybelline New York Expert Wear Eyeshadow Quads - Autumn Coppers

Buy on Amazon

Maybelline has become my absolute favorite brand, and one of their truly exceptional creations that I can't get enough of is the Expert Wear Eyeshadow Quads. Among them, the Autumn Coppers quad has secured its place as my top pick for the versatility of shades it offers. Renowned for its ultra-blendable jet-milled pigments, this eyeshadow delivers extraordinary color that lasts up to 12 hours with a silky finish. The versatility is unmatched, allowing for both simple and complex looks. It's a go-to choice for its impeccable blendability and a curated range of stunning shades.

Finish: Silky

3

Best Rich Pigment

e.l.f. No Budge Shadow Stick - Copper Chic

Buy on Amazon

The e.l.f. eyeshadow stick is a sublime makeup product that offers a long-lasting finish. Its formula doubles up as both — an eyeshadow and a liner — delivering a rich, buildable color payoff. With 12 multi-dimensional shades, it's a go-to for creating various looks, from everyday shimmer to striking smoky eyes. The twist-up design offers easy application, while the built-in sharpener ensures precision. Overall, it's a great choice for all skin types. I'd rate this description as a solid 4 out of 5 — it succinctly highlights the product's key features, benefits, and versatility, making it enticing for makeup enthusiasts.

Finish: Metallic

4

Best Transfer-proof

Mally Beauty Evercolor Eyeshadow Stick - Copper Caviar Shimme

Buy on Amazon

Looks like this eyeshadow stick by Mally Beauty is 'copper'-ating pretty well with your makeup needs! This product, in the shade 'Copper Caviar Shimmer' is a multitasking marvel that's as fierce as it gets. From sculpting to lining, it’s the queen of multitasking, offering smudge-proof and crease-proof glam in a sleek package. For my brown eyes, it's a game-changer, as it offers a color payoff that lasts from AM to PM, effortlessly transitioning from daytime chic to a smoldering night look. The shimmer finish adds a captivating depth that complements my brown eyes beautifully, making them pop with a touch of glamor.

Finish: Shimmer

5

Best Copper Eyeshadow for Blue

Amy's Diary Dark Brown Eyeshadow Palette

Buy on Amazon

Amy's Diary Dark Brown Eyeshadow Palette offers a pro-grade selection of 9 intensely pigmented shades, a canvas for artistic expression or everyday elegance. Ideal for parties or casual wear, it accentuates eyes effortlessly, especially for a captivating halo eye effect. In my experience, its smudge-proof formula stood the test of time, without flaking or creasing — even during intense activities. However, while it performed well on my eyes, a greater variety of shade textures could enhance its versatility. Overall, it's a high-quality, cruelty-free palette fit for diverse occasions, perfect for makeup aficionados seeking long-lasting, vibrant eye looks with room for even more creative exploration.

Finish: Shimmer

6

Best Creamy Formula

Laura Mercier Women's Shimmer Caviar Stick Eye Color - Copper

Buy on Amazon

Much like the rich delicacy it's named after, Laura Mercier eye shadow offers a copper shade, which I think is worth the price tag. This premium brand serves up eye shadows that are just as rich and indulgent as the finest caviar. From shades like copper, metallic, and bronze, to tan, they offer abundant colors delivering intense, buildable pigment that stays flawless for up to 12 hours. Whether you're craving a smoky liner or a lid full of striking impact, these sticks cater to your creative whims. Ideal for all skin types, they're a decadent necessity for those seeking a lush and lasting eye shadow experience for their green eyes!

Finish: Metallic

7

Best Luxe Brand

NARS Quad Eyeshadow - Orgasm

Buy on Amazon

NARS Quad Eyeshadow epitomizes premium beauty in my makeup routine, being a go-to brand for exceptional quality. This palette delivers rich, highly pigmented colors in a single stroke, thanks to its Pigment Power Suspension technology — intense and long-lasting. Its addictive velvety texture effortlessly blends for a smooth, enduring finish. After testing it first hand, I felt the shade 'Orgasm' suits various eye colors, especially enhancing hazel and green eyes, offering versatility as shadow or liner, wet or dry. This innovative, long-wear formula keeps the finish vibrant. For an enduring, vibrant eye look, this four-in-one eyeshadow is a definite must-have.

Finish: Shimmer

8

Best Copper Eyeshadow Set

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK The Casual Collection Copper & Khaki 14 Multi-Finish Eyeshadows

Buy on Amazon

Copper eyeshadows have an undeniable charm, their warm, inviting tones add a captivating allure to any eye look. The Laura Geller set captures the same with it’s versatile and numerically vast shades. Packed with shimmer and matte shades, this palette crafts both bold statements and everyday elegance. Embracing copper tones and khaki hues, it's a universal language for all eye colors and skin tones. These shadows aren't just pigmented; they're silky wonders, effortlessly blending on lids, promising crease-proof color that lasts. It's your ticket to an endless array of eye looks, a palette that invites you to play, experiment, and define your style in mesmerizing shades of copper and khaki.

Finish: Matte, shimmer, and natural

9

Best for Dry Skin

RMS Beauty Eyelights Cream Eyeshadow - Spark

Buy on Amazon

The RMS Beauty Eyelights Cream Eyeshadow truly captivated me, especially its dazzling metallic spark shade with delightful copper tones, perfect for wintry nights. Infused with organic green tea and quinoa extracts, it nourished my delicate eye skin, and gave a luminous, light-reflective finish. Upon application, the blend was seamless, though I discovered layering intensified its brilliance for a bolder evening look. I also occasionally paired it with a deeper eyeliner to enhance the copper shimmer — and it worked pretty well! Overall, I'd rate it a good 4.7 out of 5; it's a fantastic product with eco-conscious packaging and, with a touch more pigmentation, would steal the spotlight effortlessly.

Finish: Metallic

10

Best for Oily Eyelids

Honeybee Gardens Pressed Powder Matte Rusted Copper Eyeshadow

Buy on Amazon

Honeybee Gardens' Rusted Copper Eyeshadow adds a radiant pop to fair skin tones, bestowing a warm, earthy allure. Specifically curated for enhancing blue and green eyes, this shade captivates with its rich, rustic hue. It's a go-to choice for those seeking to elevate their eye game, delivering a bold yet sophisticated look that effortlessly transitions from day to night. The shade, with its warm undertones, complements fair skin beautifully, adding depth and allure to eye makeup effortlessly.

Finish:  Matte

11

Zuzu Luxe Mineral Eyeshadow - Sahara

Buy on Amazon

Just like its name evokes the essence of the Sahara, this eyeshadow embodies warmth, depth, and endless beauty. Zuzu’s Luxe Mineral Eyeshadow boasts a delightful formula enriched with botanical ingredients like soothing chamomile and rejuvenating jojoba oil, ensuring a blendable application. Perfect for brown and hazel eyes, it enriches their depth with soft shimmers and intense mattes. These shadows create captivating looks. Though the compact isn't refillable, their refill option allows eco-friendly customization in magnetic palettes, making it a sustainable choice for vibrant, expressive eye makeup.

Finish: Shimmer

12

Kiko Milano Water Eyeshadow - Copper

Buy on Amazon

From one of my favorite makeup brands, Kiko Milano, comes the Water Eyeshadow — a game-changer with instant color release and versatile wet or dry application. This revolutionary eyeshadow’s mix of spherical powders delivers remarkable color, extreme coverage, and enduring luminosity. Its creamy texture enables stunning multi-dimensional makeup, boasting bright, pure shades. Enriched with moisturizing elements, it feels weightless and gentle on the lids. Personally, my experience with this eyeshadow has been exceptional, earning a solid 4.5 out of 5. Its vibrant hue and seamless application make it a staple for both everyday looks and special occasions.

Finish: Glossy

13

Moira Everlust Shimmer Cream Shadow - Copper

Buy on Amazon

Last but certainly not least, the Moira’s Cream Shadow deserves its moment in the spotlight! Its creamy texture is a dream to apply, offering a shimmering radiance that's simply enchanting. Personally, while I adored its luminous finish and ease of use, a touch more lasting power would elevate the experience. The shade range, though captivating, could use a broader spectrum for more diverse looks. Nevertheless, the blendability and shimmer effect makes it a go-to for quick glam. With minor enhancements in longevity and shade variety, this cream shadow could easily steal the show in any makeup collection.

Finish: Shimmer

Check the buying guide below for insights to make the perfect selection tailored to your preferences.

Choosing the perfect copper eyeshadow can truly elevate your look, enhancing your eyes and adding a touch of warmth and allure. Here's a comprehensive guide to help you select the right shade and finish that suits your style and complements your features.

1. Consider Your Skin Tone: For fair skin, embrace light copper shades featuring delicate peach or rose undertones, as they don’t look too loud on the skin’s canvas. Medium skin tones call for mid-tone copper shades that strike a balance between warmth and depth, complementing the complexion harmoniously. Darker skin tones are enhanced by rich, deeper copper hues or the allure of metallic tones, as that enhances their eye beauty by adding depth and luminosity.

2. Undertones Matter: For cool undertones, opt for copper eyeshadows featuring pink or taupe undertones as they harmonize beautifully with cooler skin tones, lending a flattering contrast. Meanwhile, for warm undertones, shades infused with orange or golden undertones accentuate the warmth in your complexion, offering a radiant and complementary look.

3. Choose the Right Finish: Copper eyeshadows come in various finishes:

Matte: Ideal for creating depth and defining the crease, matte-finished copper shades are perfect for a subtle, everyday look.

Metallic/Shimmer: These shades add a stunning luminosity to your eyes, perfect for evening looks or when you want a bold statement.

Satin: A subtle sheen that's less intense than metallic but not completely matte.

4. Eye Shape And Size:

Small Eyes: Lighter copper shades applied to the inner corners can make your eyes appear bigger and brighter.

Hooded Eyes: Opt for shimmer or metallic copper tones applied to the center of the lid to make your eyes pop.

Prominent Eyes: Matte copper shades on the outer corners can help minimize the prominence.

5. Matching with Attire And Occasion: During the day, opt for softer, understated copper shades to achieve a natural, everyday look. For evening or nighttime wear, elevate your look with deeper, more vibrant copper tones or explore metallic finishes to create a glamorous and striking effect. Adjusting the intensity of the copper eyeshadow allows for a seamless transition from a casual daytime look to an alluring evening style, offering versatility in complementing various occasions and settings.

6. Experiment with Application: For a swift and effortless style, sweep a sole hue of copper across the lid, creating an instant, polished appearance. Alternatively, delve into a more intricate eye design by blending diverse copper tones, weaving dimension and depth for a captivating and detailed eye look that's uniquely yours.

7. Consider Eye Color: For blue eyes, deeper copper tones or those with orange undertones offer a striking contrast, amplifying the eye color's intensity. Brown eyes are incredibly versatile, and virtually any shade of copper complements them, enhancing their depth and richness. Green or hazel eyes benefit from copper tones infused with golden or bronze hints, intensifying the green or hazel hues for a captivating look. When seeking the best copper eyeshadow for green eyes, opt for shades that specifically highlight and accentuate the green tones, incorporating golden or bronze undertones for a stunning, eye-catching effect.

8. Quality Matters: Prioritize high-quality eyeshadows for superior pigmentation, blendability, and lasting power, ensuring a flawless application that retains vibrancy throughout the day for stunning eye looks that stand out effortlessly.

9. Upgrading looks: Delicate skin deserves the gentle touch of makeup, and nothing accentuates its beauty like a bold eyeshadow palette tailored for lightweight formulas and smooth applications. An array of intensely pigmented copper shades awaits, offering an intense color payoff while remaining blendable — a dream for beginners seeking an effortless yet striking look. This color-coordinated copper eyeshadow palette boasts a creamy texture, perfect for a seamless blend of shades, whether it's the radiant bronze hue or the subtle coppery tones. Paired with a fluffy eyeshadow brush, this collection promises a flawless application, enhancing the eyes with a blend of shades that's both sophisticated and beginner-friendly.

Remember, while these guidelines can help narrow down your choices, makeup is an art form, and personal preference is key. Don't be afraid to experiment and find what makes you feel confident and beautiful. Take your time, test different shades, and have fun exploring the versatility of copper eyeshadows to find your perfect match.

To achieve stunning copper eye makeup, start with a primer to ensure a smooth base and enhance the eyeshadow's longevity. Here are quick application tips:

1. Preparation: Apply an eyeshadow primer or concealer to even out the eyelid tone and help the copper shade adhere better.

2. Transition Shade: Begin by applying a neutral transition shade in the crease to create depth and blendability.

3. Copper Application: Pat or gently swipe the copper eyeshadow onto the lid using a dense brush or your fingertip for intense pigment.

4. Blending: Blend the edges of the copper shade with a clean, fluffy brush to soften any harsh lines and achieve a seamless transition.

5. Accentuation: For added depth, apply a darker matte shade to the outer corner or crease, blending it softly with the copper.

6. Highlight: Add a touch of a lighter shimmer shade or highlighter to the inner corner of the eyes to brighten and lift.

7. Eyeliner And Mascara: Line the eyes with complementary eyeliner and finish with mascara for a defined and polished look.

Sharing a few tips to enhance the longevity of eyeshadows, our contributor Salena Loasby, a Professional Makeup Expert, says, “If you want to rock a copper eyeshadow look that lasts through the day or night, use a lid primer first. Let it set then apply your shadow with a patting and rolling motion, rather than dusting it. This way it sinks into the lid primer giving a true depth of colour that will last for literally the whole day or night!”

Remember, less is often more. Build up the intensity gradually and blend meticulously for a flawless finish. Experiment with different techniques and have fun discovering the versatility of copper eyeshadows!

Contributor: Salena Loasby, Professional Makeup Expert - Salena Makeup and Hair