Just because some products don’t work out for you doesn’t mean you must give up on the makeup you like. For mature skin, powder-based eyeshadows are troublesome products that get collected in the eyelid creases and give a chapped appearance. Hence, it becomes essential to look for the best cream eyeshadows for mature eyes that give a creaseless finish. 

Speaking of cream eyeshadows, UK-based makeup expert and founder of a renowned cosmetics brand Charlotte Tilbury says, “What’s so incredible about cream eyeshadow pots, apart from the texture just being divine and so easy to use is that you can get mesmeric eyes in just a couple of minutes, literally with a finger”.  Also, cream eyeshadows are quicker to apply and less messy than powdered eyeshadows. They have a luxurious consistency that gently moisturizes the eyelids and does not irritate mature skin. 

Nonetheless, they may still not work out for you if you get your hands on a cheaper quality product. Hence, we have listed the best cream eyeshadows on Amazon to help you make the right purchase.

• 1
  Editor’s Pick

  CHARLOTTE TILBURY Eyes To Mesmerize Cream Eyeshadow - Rose Gold

  BUY ON AMAZON
  BUY ON SEPHORA

A smooth, creaseless eye makeup is now possible with this Charlotte Tilbury eyeshadow. This long-lasting cream-based eyeshadow is best suited for mature skin, firstly because it is devoid of skin allergens, and secondly because it is highly pigmented and helps to sheath discoloration and conceal hooded eyes. Moreover, the vitamin E-enriched soft focus pigments of the shadow help to blur visible lines and provide an unmatched alluring finish. To note, just a few rubs of this fabulous eyeshadow with your fingers or a brush can help you achieve youthful-looking eyes. 

2

Best Smudge-resistant Formulation

Smashbox ALWAYS ON Cream Shadow - Barista

BUY ON AMAZON

BUY ON SEPHORA

Another cream eyeshadow with a straightforward glide-on formulation is the product mentioned above by Smashbox. The eyeshadow is highly pigmented and impregnable by sweat, water, transfer, smudge, and humidity up to a remarkable period of 24 hours. Moreover, this innovative makeup product does not crease, get cakey, or settle into fine lines, making it a compatible choice for people across all ages and climates. Lastly, the mousse-like texture of the product provides jaw-dropping results with just a single stroke and is also ideal to be used as an eyeliner. 

3

Best for All Ages

Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Waterproof Cream Eyeshadow Stick - Golden Amber

BUY ON AMAZON

BUY ON SEPHORA

The Bobbi Brown cream eyeshadow has been recognized and honored by the Allure Best of Beauty Awards in the year 2022 for its widespread popularity. The ergonomically engineered stick helps to provide an unmatched shimmery finish without making the eye makeup look overwhelming. Moreover, the product has a cream-based formulation that blends in a jiffy, thus nullifying the need for an applicator. Lastly, the product has a robust non-cakey, non-flaking, sweat-resistant formulation, and stays up to a span of 24 hours, being unaltered by rain, sweat, humidity, or water. What’s more? It is available in an alluring range of shades from bewitching browns and subtle nudes for acing both — nude makeup look and festive season look. 

4

Best Overall

Julep 101 Creme-to-Powder Eyeshadow Stick

Buy on Amazon

As the name suggests, this eye shadow stick by Julep has a buttery texture that gives a creaseless smooth finish on application. The product is enriched with candelilla wax and vitamins E and C, which make it glide easily on the eyelids, and soothe, brighten and slightly hydrate the skin. The product is available in many shimmery, matte, and metallic shades to suit every occasion and mood. It has a unique smudger sponge that can be used to apply primer or blend the product for a smoky look.

5

e.l.f. MONOCHROMATIC MULTI STICK

Buy on Amazon

If you don’t want to hoard makeup items and need a single product for different uses, then this multi-use color stick by e.l.f is perfect for you. This minimalistic color stick can be used as an eye shadow, blush, or lipstick. It is infused with nourishing ingredients like shea butter and vitamin E that give the product its balm-like feature and moisturize the skin. The cream eye shadow is available in subtle shades with a little shimmer, ideal for a no-makeup makeup look.

6

Best Overall

LUXAZA Classic Eyeshadow Stick Set - 6 Pcs

Buy on Amazon

This cream eye shadow stick by LUXAZA is a good choice for makeup beginners. Its silky texture makes it easy to glide and prevents it from collecting in eyelid creases or wrinkles. The vitamin C content in its formulation adds antioxidants to the skin, prevents signs of aging, and nourishes the eyelids. As stick-based products become blunt, this product comes with a built-in autorotation tube to sharpen its tip and a smudging brush. The product is available in many gorgeous shades for different occasions. Also, the product is free from parabens, sulfates, mineral oil, and synthetic fragrances.

7

FOCALLURE Shimmer Cream Eyeshadow Stick Kit - 2 Pcs

Buy on Amazon

You can stop worrying about uneven finishes with this cream eyeshadow by FOCALLURE, as it provides a precise, creaseless lining. The product is highly pigmented, gives a beautiful matte finish, and is available in a range of stunning shades. Its consistency is perfect for smoky eyes. For best results, you need to apply a small amount of the product on the corners of your eyelids and blend diagonally upwards to complete the look. This travel-size product is great for quick touch-ups.

8

Oillase Eyeshadow Stick Set - 12 Pcs

Buy on Amazon

If you like natural-looking translucent eye makeup, this color stick by Oillase is the right choice. It has a lightweight, creamy texture that sits comfortably on your eyelids. The product has an intense pigment that does not fade or smudge easily. As the product quantity is decent, its tips are narrow, you can make precise strokes with better control. It comes with a soft-bristle brush at the bottom used to smudge and enhance the eye shadow or apply an eye primer.

9

alleyoop 11th Hour Eyeshadow Stick - espresso self

Buy on Amazon

BUY ON ALLEYOOP

For bold shades and intense pigments, this color stick from alleyoop is a good choice. The product has a narrow tip, which is ideal for precise strokes and doubling up as an eyeliner. It is incredible for people who don’t like their eye shadow spreading toward the brow bone. The product is infused with jojoba oil and other natural oils that reduce the appearance of wrinkles and creases, nourish the skin, and seal-in natural moisture. The product has a built-in sharpener that scrapes off the excess amount for controlled usage.

10

it COSMETICS SUPERHERO No-Tug Shadow Stick

Buy on Amazon

The nourishing components of this eye shadow stick by it COSMETICS distinguish it from other products. It contains a tri-peptide complex and ceramides that deeply hydrate the skin and reduce the appearance of wrinkles and fine lines. The hydrolyzed collagen content boosts elasticity and gives a youthful appearance, while the caffeine content brightens up the eyelids. The product gives an excellent crease-free finish and is an incredible eyeshadow for mature skin. It is available in a wide range of stunning shades that are shimmery, metallic, and classic matte.

Cream Eye Shadow Palette:

• 1
  Amazon’s Choice

  REVLON Illuminance Crème Eye Shadow

  Buy on Amazon

This highly-pigmented eye shadow palette by REVLON has four stunning shades with a creamy texture. The product glides easily over the eyelids with a brush applicator or fingertip and is suitable for mature skin. As it is buildable, you can start with a small amount of product for a natural look and layer up if you desire a bolder look. The palette is ideal for quick on-the-go touch-ups and comes with a convenient built-in mirror.

2

e.l.f. Bite-Size Eyeshadow

Buy on Amazon

This eye shadow product by e.l.f is ultra-pigmented, suitable for both subtle and bold looks. It has a creamy texture and smooth application, which gives a crease-free finish to mature skin. The palette contains matte, metallic, and shimmery shades to suit every occasion and mood. Despite a cream-based compact base, the finish is powdery and does not feel sticky on the eyelids. To top it off, the product is free from parabens, sulfates, phthalates, triclosan, triclocarban, and other harmful chemicals.

3

W7 MIGHTY MATTES NATURAL NUDES MATTE EYE COLOR PALETTE

Buy on Amazon

If you often forget to use an eye primer, then this cream eye shadow palette by W7 is an incredible choice for you. The palette comes with 12 nude colors and a double-sided eyeshadow brush for applying and blending the product. The colors are available in light, and dark matte shades, each separately suitable for day or night makeup. The product is buildable, so you can layer up for an intense color payoff.

4

Best for Sensitive Skin

Physicians Formula Matte Monoi Butter Eyeshadow

Buy on Amazon

This eyeshadow by Physicians Formula gets its luxuriously silky texture from Tahitian monoi butter, murumuru butter, cupuacu butter, and tucuma butter. These nourishing ingredients act as excellent humectants to deeply moisturize, soften and protect the skin, while also improving skin elasticity(1). The product is also infused with vitamins and antioxidants to enhance its benefits. The palette comes with blush nude shades that give a matte finish, perfect for a natural makeup look.

5

REVLON So Fierce Prismatic Eye Shadow Palette

Buy on Amazon

For glam, ramp-ready makeup looks, we highly recommend this prismatic eye shadow palette by REVLON. The product comes with four stunning metallic shades with a suspended gel technology that makes it glide smoothly and can be applied easily using fingertips. It is an excellent product for gradient eye makeup as it is infused with crystal-like pigments that give a polished, multidimensional appearance. Its crease-proof formula makes it one of the best cream eyeshadows for mature eyes.

• 1

  MAYBELLINE NEW YORK COLOR TATTOO EyeShadow

  Buy on Amazon

If you want bold, bright eye makeup, then this cream eyeshadow by Maybelline is an incredible product choice. The product has a shimmer-infused vibrant metallic color and a plush, creamy texture for a stunning finish. Its ink technology ensures that the product gives an intense color pay-off, and a little goes a long way. You can use this buildable product with your fingertips, and shape and layer up as you like. The plush consistency ensures that the product gives a creaseless finish, which makes it one of the best cream eyeshadows for mature eyes.

2

Natural Ingredients

Lauren Brooke COSMETICS Crème Eyeshadow - Dulce Le Che Matte

Buy on Amazon

This cream eyeshadow by lauren brooke COSMETICS is like a compact balm infused with jojoba oil, shea butter, rosehip oil, and vitamin E, which nourish, moisturize, and condition the eyelids. At the same time, these ingredients help reduce the appearance of wrinkles and fine lines. Unlike other makeup products, it is made with a 99.7 percent certified botanic base and is fortified with vitamins, minerals, and pigments. Its indulgent organic vanilla scent makes the makeup routine interesting and delightful.

3

BURT'S BEES Color Nurture Cream Eye Shadow

Buy on Amazon

As the name suggests, this compact eyeshadow by Burt’s Bees has a creamy texture with nourishing properties of sunflower seed wax, caster oil, and jojoba esters that moisturize the skin and reduce the appearance of wrinkles and fine lines. It has a very silky texture and blends like a dream, which makes it perfect for mature skin. You can also use this product as a highlighter on your nose and cheekbones. The product is safe and free from phthalates, SLS, parabens, or petroleum.

Now that you’ve seen our product recommendations, let us take a look at the buying guide, application steps, and benefits of cream eyeshadows so you can make an informed purchase.

Consistency: Unlike dry, powder-based products, your cream-based eyeshadow should have a smooth, emollient consistency. The formulation should be such that the product glides smoothly and easily on the eyelids without tugging or pulling the skin. Such products are highly blendable, so you can skip the makeup brush and apply it using your fingertips. Look for a product that is smudge-proof, fade-proof, has a long-staying power, and sits comfortably on the eyelids. 

Color And Pigmentation: For mature skin, it is best to look for neutral and natural-looking colors such as light brown, nude, blush pink, peach, etc. for a youthful makeup look. Also, look for products that give a rich color pay-off, so a little goes a long way. While metallic and subtle shimmery tones are great, avoid shades that are too sparkly and over-the-top, as they make one look older. Also, such colors can worsen the appearance of wrinkles. 

Excellent Finish: For mature skin, it is pivotal that the cream eyeshadow gives a creaseless finish for a younger look. Avoid products that get collected in your eyelid creases and wrinkles. Look for buildable products, so you can apply a small amount for a sheer finish and layer up for a bolder finish. 

Ingredients: With eyeshadow products, drying ingredients such as mica, talc, and silica are often unavoidable. Hence, to neutralize their effects, look for products infused with nourishing ingredients such as jojoba oil, shea butter, rosehip oil, castor oil, sunflower oil, hydrolyzed collagen, peptide complex, and vitamin E. Products that provide subtle protection from sun damage and free radicals and have a botanical base are always incredible. Also, look for products free from phthalates, parabens, sulfates, SLS, and mineral oil as they have harmful side effects.

The application of cream eyeshadow is far easier than powder eyeshadows. Nonetheless, every product is different, so read the application instructions on the packaging before getting started. Here are a few simple steps to go about it:

Step 1: To begin with, prep your eyes with an eyeshadow primer.

Step 2: If you are using a soft-bristle brush, dip the tips in the product and start applying them on the corner of the eye closer to the lash line. Blend upwards using diagonal strokes. Avoid using the cream eyeshadow on the brow bone as it looks too shimmery and unnatural. 

If you are using your fingertip, go for the ring finger as it is the safest to use near the eye area. Just like the brush, dip the product and blend upwards. 

Step 3: To set the product, you can use a powdered eyeshadow of the same shade and top it off. Or, you can do so with a setting spray. However, many cream eyeshadows become dry after application, so feel free to skip the last step.

Glowy Finish: While powder-based eye shadows are good for a matte finish, they look cakey on mature eyes, despite being infused with metallic pigments and shimmer. On the other hand, cream-based products give a stunning, glowy look alongside a matte finish. 

Quick Touch-ups: Cream eyeshadows can be easily applied using fingertips or directly if the product comes as a stick. Hence, they are ideal for quick touch-ups, unlike powdered products that require precision. 

Blendable: Cream-based products glide effortlessly and smoothly, unlike their powdered counterparts. 

Moisturizing: Powder-based products are not meant to moisturize. Nonetheless, cream eyeshadows may nourish, hydrate, and condition the eyelids to reduce the appearance of wrinkles and creases.

So, there you have it. The above-mentioned list of the best cream eyeshadows for mature eyes is highly reviewed by users and is available on Amazon. If you are new to makeup or to using cream-based eyeshadows, we recommend using our buying guide, application steps, benefits, and specific product features before making a purchase. Happy shopping!