15 Best Eyebrow Fillers for Feather-Like Brows

Written by Sayantani Deb, Makeup & Beauty Writer
Updated on Feb 09, 2024
Best Eyebrow Fillers for Feather-Like Brows
The products curated for this article are independently chosen by the editorial team. If you make a purchase through the links mentioned below, we may receive a commission. Check out our product research & curation process

Eyebrow shaders and eyebrow fill-in products are a great way to achieve that Instagram-worthy brow look. We have a list of the best eyebrow fillers that will help you get that balanced and symmetrical eyebrow shape. These sweet suggestions are a great choice to fill in those sparse spots and get rid of uneven brow length and size.

The below-listed brow products for thin brows can be a game-changer and will elevate your makeup look with just minimal effort. Another good thing about such tools is that they come in a variety of shapes, shades, and types. You can also select them based on the kind of appearance you want to obtain. Whether you want a dramatic and bold look or a subtle and natural-looking finish, there’s a product for every and all kinds of requirements.

15 Best Eyebrow Fillers

Maybelline is one of the most trusted brands and they seldom disappoint. The first on our list is a classic eyebrow pencil that is available in four shades.This is a must-have product where you can shape and blend your eyebrow with a shade closest to your brow color. It comes with a mechanical pencil on one side and you get a spoolie brush on the other end to brush the brow and get a soft and natural-looking brow. The pencil has a teardrop-shaped tip which makes it ergonomic-friendly and easy to use.

Pros
  • Affordable
  • 1.5mm microtip
  • Mechanical pencil
  • Teardrop-shaped tip
  • Precision
  • Easy to remove
  • Comes with a spoolie brush
Cons
  • None
  • Best for a Natural Look

    ANASTASIA BEVERLY HILLS Brow Definer

    ANASTASIA BEVERLY HILLS Brow Definer
  • Get gorgeous and perfectly defined brows when you use the Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Definer. It is an all-in-one retractable eyebrow pencil that comes with unique features like a triangular tip that effortlessly adds definition and detail while filling in your brows. Also, the versatile design offers 3 edge sises, giving you the freedom to create your brow look with ease. What's more is that the fine tips allow you to get natural-looking hairline strokes when used with a light hand.

    Pros
    • Innovative tip
    • Available in a wide range of colors
    • Natural finish
    • Easy to use
    • Travel-friendly
    • Doesn’t require a sharpener
    • Offers precise control
    • Smudge-proof
    Cons
    • Not fully waterproof
  • Most Longlasting Formula

    WUNDERBROW 1-STEP BROW GEL

    WUNDERBROW 1-STEP BROW GEL
  • If you want your eyebrows to stay put for a long time, then Wunderbrow’s eyebrow gels are your best option. They are long-lasting and keep your brows in place even after a whole night of partying or even a strenuous workout at the gym. This is one of the best brow tools as it is waterproof, smudge-proof, and has a range of swatch shades to select from. It can last for days and you won’t have to go through the hassle of re-applying . It also comes with a dual precision brush to define and groom your brows.

    Pros
    • Water-proof
    • Smudge-proof
    • Available in 5 shades
    • Vegan and cruelty-free
    • Lasts for days
    • Matte finish
    Cons
    • Expensive
  • Waterproof and Sweatproof

    NYX TINTED BROW MASCARA

    NYX TINTED BROW MASCARA
  • NYX’s tinted brow mascara will be perfect for you if you have light-colored eyebrows and are looking for a semi-permanent option to fill them in. Tinted brow mascaras can last for weeks and enhance your eyebrows by darkening them. They are extremely low-maintenance and you won’t have to worry about defining your eyebrow every day. It is made from premium quality materials that will ensure durability. You can go swimming or have a hectic day of workout after applying this tint and you won’t have to fear runny eyebrows.

    Pros
    • Comes in 5 shades
    • Sets in one swipe
    • Covers major brow concerns
    • Makes arches soft and smooth
    • Has a spoolie brush for application
    • Buildable coverage
    Cons
    • None
  • Best Cruelty-free Formula

    Grande BROW-FILL Volumizing Brow Gel with Peptides + Fibers

    Grande BROW-FILL Volumizing Brow Gel with Peptides + Fibers
  • Up your eyebrow game with Grande's BROW-FILL Volumizing Brow Gel. Prepare to get fuller and more defined-looking brows that have a soft yet flexible and water-resistant hold that will let you look flawless all day long. The formula is infused with volumizing fibers and conditioning peptides, giving you a natural look and making the application process effortless. Embrace the confidence of long-lasting, stunning brows with just a single swipe – because your brows deserve the best.

    Pros
    • Feels comfortable
    • Looks natural
    • Easy to use
    • Conditions the brows
    • Available in multiple shades
    • Non-clumpy
    • Ideal for on-the-go touchups
    • Cruelty-free
    Cons
    • Expensive
  • Best Cream-based formula

    MILANI Stay Put Brow Color

    MILANI Stay Put Brow Color
  • With the help of Milani Stay Put Brow Color you can fill and sculpt your brows like a pro. It has a superior staying power and can last for at least 16 hours. It has a cream-based formula and comes in eight different colors. All you have to do is dip the angled brush into the tiny jar, take up a small amount of product and outline your eyebrows, and fill them in by applying in the direction of your hair growth. If you have excess product on your brows, then you can use the brush to scrape it off gently.

    Pros
    • Cream-based formula
    • Comes in 8 shades
    • Has a dual-ended brush
    • Affordable
    • 16 hours staying power
    • Cruelty-free and vegan
    Cons
    • The cream can dry up quickly
  • Best FIne-tip

    L’ORÉAL PARIS BROW STYLIST DEFINER

    L’ORÉAL PARIS BROW STYLIST DEFINER
  •  Simplify your makeup routine with L’Oréal Paris’ ultra fine self-sharpening brow pencil that comes with a mechanical and retractable tip. For those who want to a add a little bit of drama to their eyes, this is the perfect and the best product to draw on eyebrows. It draws on tiny brow hair and fills the sparse spots. There is a spoolie on the other end to brush and define the shape of your brows too. It’s available in 10 vast shades and just a few strokes, so choose your shade. Just simple strokes of combing and blending are enough to achieve a natural look.

    Pros
    • Has an ultra-fine tip
    • Draws tiny brow hair
    • Comes with a spoolie brush
    • Available in 10 shades
    • Waterproof
    • Easy to use
    • Easily blendable
    Cons
    • Tip can break easily
  • Best Transfer-proof Formula

    RIMMEL LONDON BROW THIS WAY

    RIMMEL LONDON BROW THIS WAY
  • The next on our list is Rimmel London’s intense brow pencil that can last up to 12 hours without transferring or fading. It has a triangular retractable tip to fill in your brows. You don't have to worry about the product smudging because the formula gets locked into the brow while it's drying. The formula is also buildable and is available in three rich colors. The sculpted look you're going to achieve from this brow pencil is going to make some heads turn for sure!

    Pros
    • Buildable formula
    • Comes with a spoolie brush
    • Has a retractable triangular tip
    • Transfer-proof
    • Fade-proof
    • Can last up to 12 hours
    • Instantly lifts the brows
    • Lightweight texture
    Cons
    • Small color range
  • wet n wild ultimatebrow RETRACTABLE BROW PENCIL

    wet n wild ultimatebrow RETRACTABLE BROW PENCIL
  • Have fabulous eyebrows all day long by using wet n wild’s triangular pencil tip. Whether you want to fill in sparse spots or draw tiny hair on your eyebrows, this natural eyebrow filler will do its best job to make your eyebrows look on point. It has rub-resistant pigments and won't smudge for a long time. On the other end of the pencil is a spoolie to brush and blend the color. The tip is retractable and provides the perfect precision to draw eyebrows.

    Pros
    • No need to sharpen the pencil
    • Triangular tip
    • Provides a good precision
    • Has a spool is
    • Cruelty-free
    • Paraben-free
    • Blends well
    Cons
    • Available in just 4 shades
  • Elizabeth Mott QUEEN of the fill Eyebrow Gel

    Elizabeth Mott QUEEN of the fill Eyebrow Gel
  • Elizabeth Mott’s eyebrow gel is beginner-friendly and fills the sparse areas easily. You don’t have to be a makeup pro to use an eyebrow gel. The tube is spiral shaped and also covers gray hair. This tinted brow gel is a truly unique, smudge-proof, and a natural eyebrow filler with film-forming polymer technology. It increases the volume of the brows while also maintaining excellent product quality. It is water and sweat-proof and comes in 5 different shades. Just brush it on and you are good to go!

    Pros
    • Delivers life-like hair texture
    • Covers gray areas
    • Fills sparse areas
    • Water-resistant
    • Smudge-proof
    • Cruelty-free
    • Long-lasting
    • Hassle-free application
    • Gives a natural look
    Cons
    • Expensive
  • Best Waterproof Formula

    Apooliy EYEBROW CONTOURING

    Apooliy EYEBROW CONTOURING
  • You get not one but four pencil tips in this eyebrow pencil. It is waterproof, sweat-proof, and doesn't smudge or fade even after long hours of wearing it. This is one of th best eyebrow makeup for no brows because it has a unique tip with four pencils. It's like a fork and you can draw the contour of your eyebrow and color the insides along your brow shape evenly. This provides a natural and defined look. It comes in five different shades and is easy to remove as well. 

     

    Pros
    • Doesn't fade easily
    • Waterproof
    • Unique tip
    • Easy to apply
    • Delivers a natural look
    Cons
    • Tube can dry quickly
  • Best Eyebrow Kit

    REVLON COLORSTAY BROW KIT

    REVLON COLORSTAY BROW KIT
  • Revlon’s innovative brow kit stands apart from the rest of the other brow gels and pencils because not only does it give you the color you want but it also comes with a lightweight conditioning wax and two brushes — one you can use to line and draw precise strokes and the other for shaping. First, apply the brow floor with a dry brush. Then, use the dual-ended brush to draw precise lines while using the spoolie to brush and remove excess color. Lastly, apply the conditioning wax to set the color and keep your brows intact. There you go - perfectly precise eyebrows within a few minutes!

    Pros
    • Comes as a kit
    • Has a dual-ended brush
    • Comes with a spoolie
    • Long-lasting
    • Ideal for all brow types
    • Waterproof
    • Affordable
    Cons
    • Limited shades
  • iMethod PERFECT EYEBROWS IN SECONDS

    iMethod PERFECT EYEBROWS IN SECONDS
  • Get perfectly arched eyebrows by using iMethod’s eyebrow stamp and eyebrow stencil kit. Featured on many major sites, this is the perfect brow stamp kit that includes 10 stencils (5 pairs). This kit also has an eyebrow pomade which is ike a mix between a gel and a wax. It has a creamy texture and it helps in creating sharp and well-defined lines. It lasts a long time and it is smudge-proof. It comes in 10 different shades and has become TikTok’s latest obsession. Get your hands on this best eyebrow kit for sparse brows and enhance your makeup skills.

    Pros
    • Has 5 pair of stencil shapes
    • Long-lasting
    • Provide a natural finish
    • Comes with a zipper pouch
    • Sponge applicator is included
    • Vegan and cruelty-free
    Cons
    • Expensive
  • COVERGIRL EASY BREEZY BROW

    COVERGIRL EASY BREEZY BROW
  • Covergirl’s volumizing brow gel comes in three shades and it suits all skin types. The gel is infused with argan oil and biotin. With the promise of lasting for more than 24 hours, the eyebrow gel won’t fade away easily. It is also transfer-proof. This is a great tinted gel makeup for sparse eyebrows and it can cover up the empty areas effortlessly. It will tame and provide volume to thin eyebrows. It will define your brows and nourish them with the benefits of argan oil and biotin.

    Pros
    • Waterproof
    • Lasts up to 24 hours
    • Infused with argan oil
    • Covers sparse spots
    • Affordable
    • Lightweight
    Cons
    • Limited shade range
  • WINKY LUX Uni-Brow Pencil

    WINKY LUX Uni-Brow Pencil
  • This is a one-of-a-kind and easy brow filler with a universal multi-toned pencil that promises to blend well with every shade of brown brows. The skin shade doesn't matter as long as your brows are brown. Apply lightly if you want a natural look and go all crazy if you want that intense dramatic look. One end is pointed and has a pencil to fill in sparse patches. The other end has a spoolie to brush the grows and remove excess color. If you can't decide which shade to go with, then go for Winky Lux’s one shade for all brown brow shades and achieve that ultra-groomed finish.

    Pros
    • Paraben-free
    • Vegan
    • Long-lasting
    • Innovative
    • Waterproof
    • Easy to use
    • Easy to remove
    Cons
    • Expensive

    Select the best brow filler based on your skin and hair color and your brows will thank you for looking after them. You are just one step away from posting “eyebrows on fleek” on your picture!

    How to Choose the Best Eyebrow Filler

    For all the brow babes and boys who don't know how to choose the best eyebrow thickened makeup, we have a few guidelines to help you out:

    • Lightweight: Opt for an eyebrow shader that's not heavy. A heavy eyebrow fill-in won't last a long time. 
    • Quality: Select the best quality pencil or gel that won’t make your eyebrow makeup cakey and patchy. Choose a hypoallergenic eyebrow filler that won’t cause any itching or irritation. 
    • Formula: Always buy a smudge-free formula that won’t clog your brows. Furthermore, if you are someone who has oily skin, is always out in the sun, or goes swimming often, then find a formula that's water and sweat-proof.
    • Convenience: If you want something quick and easy to use, then powder and pencil fillers will be the best for you as they are hassle-free. 
    • Usage: If you want to cover your gray hair and sparse patches, then a gel, tint, or pomade will be perfect for you.

    A fuller eyebrow can change your entire makeup look for the best and you won't be disappointed. All you have to do is purchase one of the best eyebrow fillers and you are all set to define your brows effortlessly, precisely, and flawlessly. Before you directly apply the filler on your brows, make sure you use a spoolie to brush your brows in the upward motion. Furthermore, there are so many shapes and colors you can try if you are feeling a little wild and experimental. Whether your brows are thick and bushy or thin and scanty, eyebrow contouring will make a huge difference to your appearance.

    FAQ's

    What eyebrow filler lasts for days?
    Eyebrow tints, gels, and pomades are known to last for weeks. Buy a liquid formula if you don't like filling your eyebrows every morning.
    What can I use to fill gaps on my eyebrows?
    You can fill the gaps with the help of eyebrow pencils, powders, gels, and tints. Make sure you buy one that matches your hair and skin color. Use a spoolie soon after to brush and set it in place.
    How do you fill in sparse eyebrows fast?
    Sparse eyebrows can look bad on many people. It can be a result of over-plucking or using harsh chemical products on your face. That's why you can fill those patches with the help of pomade or tinted eyebrow gels.
    How do you fill in your eyebrows and make it look natural?
    Eyebrow pencils and gels are the best way to fill in your eyebrows and make it look natural. The thing with eyebrow fillers is that you can use it as per your demands. If you want a darker dramatic look, then go heavy on the powders and pencils. If you want a subtle natural look, then go easy with the fillers. It's as simple as that.
    How can I make my thin eyebrows look thicker?
    One of the easiest ways to make your eyebrows look thicker is to fill them in with a brow product, like a pencil, powder, or pomade. Try to create the illusion of natural brow hair by using light feathery strokes. Another trick is to use a brow gel and brush your eyebrow hairs upward. This will help you in achieving a thicker and more voluminous look.

    Why Trust Pinkvilla

    Our in-house makeup specialist Sayantani says that eyebrow fillers are a versatile solution to achieving well-defined and polished brows. The product enhances their natural appearance, filling in sparse areas and giving them a better shape. After using all the products, she was amazed at the results that Maybelline’s Total Temptation Brow Definer had to offer. It blended in perfectly with her brows and gave them a natural look. Also, it comes in 4 different shades which is an additional bonus!

    Our product experts study the specifications of every product we suggest and try them out to bring what’s proven to be worthy of your money, time, and energy. We also have subject matter experts from various fields like Fashion, Skincare, Haircare, Home Decor, and Health & Fitness onboard to make sure our suggestions are credible and trustworthy. You can trust Pinkvilla to be your faithful shopping guide for all the right reasons!

    Author BIO
    reviewer
    Sayantani Deb
    Makeup & Beauty Writer

    Sayantani is a certified hair and makeup professional turned writer with 2+ years of experience in the same genre. Ap More