The skin around the eyes is very sensitive. So, it is not exactly equipped to bear the impact of eyeliner, let alone the ones with harsh ingredients. Their negative effects can be way worse if you have allergy-prone skin. While you don’t need to give up on that stunning winged look you love so much, it is wise to get your hands on the best hypoallergenic eyeliner to avoid reactions.

What distinguishes hypoallergenic eyeliners from others is that they have fewer ingredients, no artificial fragrance, and suit sensitive skin. Also, they are often derived from inert minerals milled into tiny particles. Such formulations are more gentle on your skin and prevent redness, inflammation, itchiness, and allergic dermatitis.

According to ophthalmologist Dr. Rupa Wong, “you can have allergic dermatitis to a (makeup) product you’ve been using for years. (With) allergic dermatitis… you develop a reaction 12-48 hours after you put (the product) on. That’s where it can be tricky to figure out what you’re allergic to”. While it is pivotal to check the ingredients and do a patch test, using top-notch eyeliners for sensitive eyes puts you on the safer side. Now that we’ve prepped you about hypoallergenic eyeliners, let’s hop on to see our list of product recommendations.

• 1
  Best Smudge-proof option

  Sandstone Scandinavia Hypoallergenic Eyeliner

  BUY ON AMAZON

Constant eye makeup touch-ups will no longer be needed when the Sandstone Scandinavia hypoallergenic eyeliner occupies a tiny space in your makeup kit. The super-saturated color pigment provides a long-lasting irresistible finish that does not fade away or peel off. Moreover, the product has a lightweight, comfortable texture and effortlessly glides onto the eyelids without any jerks or resistance. Addedly, the product does not cause any redness, itchiness, or inflammation, which makes it a compatible choice for sensitive skin. The best part? It is available in a varied range of shades ranging from bold blues to ravishing reds to sandy browns for people with varied color preferences to choose from.

2

Editor’s Pick

Neutrogena Precision Liquid Eyeliner with Honey & Coconut

BUY ON AMAZON

The Neutrogena eyeliner for sensitive eyes helps to achieve clean, precise lines without fraying away in a single stroke, which is why after having tried this product once, our panel of experts cannot stop obsessing over it. It also helps to recreate and reinvent innumerable eye makeup looks without getting runny or smudging throughout the day. To add on, it comes with an ergonomically designed precision tip that prevents the ink from getting spilled or drying out. The most magical thing about this product is that it helps to draw lines with ease even on aging skin and thus provides sunken eyes with a refreshed look. 

3

Best Overall

COVERGIRL Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Pencil

Buy on Amazon

 

For blurry strokes and a natural makeup look, this eyeliner by COVERGIRL works incredibly well. The crayon/pencil eyeliner has a flat tip that is useful for thick strokes, while its edges help create precise wings. It is retractable, so you can twist it up and use the product at your convenience. The product comes with a built-in sponge smudger that is useful in creating a smokey eye look. You can use it on your upper lash line as well as your waterline. This eyeliner is available in a range of stunning shades as well as green, blue, and burgundy to spruce up your makeup.

4

L'ORÉAL PARIS MAKEUP INFALLIBLE Never Fail Eyeliner

Buy on Amazon

You can create precise lines or natural-looking blur strokes the way you like with this incredible pencil eyeliner by L'ORÉAL PARIS. The product has a rich, creamy formula that glides like a dream. It comes with a built-in sponge that is useful in smudging the liner for a smokey look or creating a base for dark eyeshadows. However, once settled on your eyelids, the product does not smudge and stays put for long hours. The formulation contains olive oil and sodium hyaluronate that are gentle on the eyelids and hydrate the skin. These benefits make this product one of the best pencil eyeliners for sensitive eyes and skin.

5

REVLON ColorStay Eyeliner

Buy on Amazon

For a dramatic winged look that lasts all day, you should get your hands on this retractable pencil eyeliner by REVLON as its updated formula is waterproof and has long staying power. It has a fine tip and a built-in smudger for blurry as well as precise strokes. It is available in not only natural shades like brown and black but also exotic shades such as jade, teal, and sapphire to spruce up your makeup look. You can apply this product on your lash line as well as your waterline, as its ultra-silky formula glides like a dream. It has a luxuriously creamy texture, so you can blend the product using the smudger and use it as an eyeshadow base.

6

Best for Precise Wings

ALMAY Liquid Liner

Buy on Amazon

This liquid liner by Almay comes in a calligraphy-inspired inkwell bottle with a long, contoured-grip cap for a controlled application. It has a fine, felt applicator with a flex tip to create precise lines with ease. Despite being a dip-in liquid eyeliner, the applicator is easy to use, even for beginners. While the product gives an intense color pay-off, its fade-proof formula tops off this benefit. The product is mild and long-lasting, which makes it one of the best hypoallergenic eyeliners for sensitive eyes.

7

Best for Regular Use

Rare Beauty Perfect Strokes Matte Liquid Liner

BUY ON SEPHORA

Professionally curated eye makeup look minus the leaking and drying of the eyeliner ink is just a few strokes away with this Rare Beauty product. After having put the eyeliner to test, our team discovered that it does not cause any redness, attract residue, or trigger inflammation. It is also a non-negotiable choice for sensitive skin because it is devoid of skin allergens, fragrances, and alcohol. The best part is that the product is made up of vegan bristles, making it an ideal choice for people allergic to animal hair. Addedly, the product is tested ophthalmologically and dermatologically, and considered safe for people with contact lens wearers. Moreover, the product does not fade, feather, or flake, is unaltered by sweat, or water, and is thus best suited for regular use.

8

Best Easy-to Use

Neutrogena Nourishing Eyeliner

Buy on Amazon

What makes this eyeliner by Neutrogena special is that it has a nourishing formula with olive oil and rainforest shea butter, that not only glides smoothly but also moisturizes your skin. The formulation contains subtle light diffusers that reflect light away from your eyelids and make the whites of your eyes look brighter and more defined. It comes with a smudging sponge to blur out the strokes and get a natural makeup look. With these benefits, the product also works as an excellent eye makeup base for a smokey look, which makes it one of the best hypoallergenic eyeliners.

9

Most Versatile to Use

RevitaLash Cosmetics Defining Liner

BUY ON AMAZON

RevitaLash boasts of this hypoallergenic eyeliner as a product that can be applied in any way one’s heart desires. While one can use its fine tip to apply a simple, thin stroke over their eyelids or angle it for a dramatic cat-eye look, its creamy formula can also be smudged for a smokey look. The eyeliner also comes with a built-in sponge smudger that allows you to gently diffuse and soften the stroke for a natural finish. Plus, it comes with a built-in sharpener to scrape off excess product and achieve precision in your strokes.

10

ALMAY Eyeliner Crayon Contour

Buy on Amazon

For a stunning, ramp-ready makeup look, this crayon eyeliner by ALMAY is an incredible choice as it has fine flecks of shimmer for a luminous finish. While its creamy formula glides smoothly, it is also enriched with vitamin E to nourish the sensitive skin of the eyelids. It has an oil-free, non-greasy consistency that does not rub off and suits all skin types. The product comes with a built-in sharpener, so you can scrape off the excess and achieve precise lines. It comes in a range of natural and off-beat colors, ideal for different occasions.

11

BURT’S BEES Nourishing Eyeliner Pencil

Buy on Amazon

This amazing eyeliner pencil by BURT’S BEES has a nourishing formula enriched with jojoba oil, meadowfoam seed oil, and mango seed oil that gives it a creamy texture. Its glyceryl caprylate content gives the product humectant properties and makes it glide smoothly on your eyelids. The product is available in natural shades and enhances your eye color. This eyeliner is ideal for minimalistic, no-makeup makeup looks and is safe for frequent use. Also, it is free from parabens, SLS, phthalates, talc, or petroleum, which makes it one of the best hypoallergenic eyeliners for sensitive eyes.

12

Best Humidity Resistance

MARCELLE WATERPROOF EYELINER

Buy on Amazon

With the ultra-precise tip of this eyeliner pencil by MARCELLE, you can make precise strokes and dramatic wings without being a makeup pro. The product has a classy matte finish and is available in many natural and color-pop shades to suit different moods. Its formulation is waterproof, which increases its staying power and makes it stay put for a long time. The product is enriched with jojoba oil and vitamin E that make it glide smoothly while hydrating the skin on the eyelids. It is safe, mild, and one of the best hypoallergenic eyeliners for sensitive skin.

13

Best Smudge-resistant

PHYSICIAN’S FORMULA EYE BOOSTER GEL EYELINER TRIO

Buy on Amazon

 

This retractable gel eyeliner by PHYSICIAN’S FORMULA is enriched with botanicals and vitamin E that hydrate and condition sensitive eyelids. What gives this product an edge over others is that its lash-strengthening properties enhance the appearance of your eyelashes, while beautifully defining your eyes. Also, the silicone resin in the product enhances its staying power so you don’t have to re-apply it throughout the day. The eyeliner is available in matte, shimmery, and satin-finish shades to suit different occasions. You can use the product for precise strokes or diffused, soft lines for a natural look.

14

BaeBlu Natural Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Pencil

Buy on Amazon

For a smooth, tug-free glide, this product by BaeBlue is one of the best hypoallergenic eyeliners. It is made with clean, organic ingredients and is free from parabens, toxins, gluten, and petroleum, which makes it safe to use. The product is enriched with jojoba oil and castor oil that make it glide easily and moisturize the skin on the eyelids. You can use its brown shade for a defined, no-makeup look or the black shade for a bolder look. It is free from harsh chemicals, artificial dyes, and fragrances and is one of the best eyeliners for sensitive skin.

15

Best Budget-friendly

Erinde Eyeliner Pencil Set - 12 Pcs

Buy on Amazon

These pencil eyeliners by Erinde have a mild formula, enriched with skin-friendly ingredients that is easy on sensitive skin. Each eyeliner is highly pigmented and gives an intense color pay-off. It blends effortlessly, so you can use it as an eyeshadow base for your smokey eye makeup. With its precise tip, you can create sharp strokes or smudge the product for a softer, natural look. The eyeliner is safe to use on your upper lash line as well as your waterline. What sets it apart is that it doesn’t crease your eyelids, which makes it one of the best hypoallergenic eyeliners for sensitive eyes.

Now that we’ve seen our product recommendations, let us understand how to choose the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes with this buying guide.

You may be tired of dealing with red, itchy, and irritated eyes every time you wear eyeliner. If you have sensitive eyes or allergies, finding the right eyeliner can be a daunting task. Here are a few factors to consider before you choose the best hypoallergenic eyeliner.

Avoid Irritants: What distinguishes hypoallergenic makeup products from others is their unique formula. These products are free from many irritants that can trigger allergic reactions. These include artificial fragrances, artificial dyes, mica, essential oils, chemical exfoliants, retinol, benzyl alcohol, and some harsh chemicals. However, these include products that may trigger reactions for some but are beneficial for others. Hence, understand your allergies before making a purchase. Some harmful ingredients that everyone must avoid include parabens, SLS, SLES, formaldehyde, and petroleum.

Fewer Ingredients:  When it comes to cosmetics, some chemicals cannot be avoided in manufacturing. Nonetheless, eyeliners or other makeup products with fewer ingredients have a lesser probability of triggering allergic reactions than products that have many ingredients.

Tug-free Glide: Eyeliners that do not glide smoothly can worsen the condition of sensitive eyes and skin. Hence, it is important to look for products with a soft and creamy texture that does not require you to rub excessively to get a color payoff.

Humectant Properties: Not just for sensitive skin, but moisturizing ingredients are great for all skin types. This is why eyeliners that contain shea butter, jojoba oil, sodium hyaluronate, glycerin, olive oil, rosehip oil, etc. are always a good choice.

Easy And Versatile Application: Highly blendable Eyeliners can be used as an eyeshadow base for smokey eye makeup. Also, some eyeliners can double up as kohl and be safely applied to the waterline on your eyes. Hence, it is always beneficial to look for products that have versatile applications and are also beginner-friendly.

Ethically Sourced: Products made with vegan, responsibly sourced ingredients that have not been tested on animals are always a conscientious choice. Also, these products have an upper hand over others when it comes to your safety.

Hypoallergenic is a term often freely used by makeup brands without any factual backing. Nonetheless, by understanding your skin requirements and referring to our buying guide, you can make an informed purchase that you won’t regret. The above-mentioned hypoallergenic eyeliners are highly reviewed by users and are ideal for sensitive eyes and skin. Ensure you go through the ingredients list thoroughly and only then get your hands on any product. Happy shopping!