Makeup is a mere facilitator as true beauty reflects from the joy in your eyes! And, there’s nothing more heartbreaking than the makeup itself causing your eyes to redden, swell, and overflow with tears. Fortunately, the best hypoallergenic mascaras designed for sensitive eyes and skin have got you covered. These products enhance the features as you’d expect from ordinary mascaras by preventing any irritation or side effects they may cause. 

Mascara is a product one would hold on to even if one were to give up all other makeup products. “Even for those days that I do not feel like doing very elaborate makeup, I end up applying a few layers of mascara and the look changes in a matter of minutes”, says American-Brazilian beauty entrepreneur Camilla Coelho. It is an essential item to achieve a basic no-makeup makeup look, and people with sensitive eyes should not be stripped of this privilege! 

Hence, to help you find fantastic mascaras made with gentle, non-irritant formulations, we have curated a list of our favorite products you can add to your cart. Scroll away to see our best picks for hypoallergenic mascaras to lengthen, volumize and spruce up the appearance of your lashes. 

 

• 1
  Best Overall

  poppy austin mascara

  Buy on Amazon

Composed of nourishing plant extracts, this creamy hypoallergenic mascara by Poppy Austin is eight times gentler than regular chemical-based cosmetics. The formula contains argan oil and rich fatty acids that intensively moisturize your eyelashes, boosting growth and making them longer and fuller. Moreover, it has a comforting, creamy consistency that does not clump and goes on smoothly over your lashes. With this product, you don’t have to worry about getting those dreaded raccoon eyes as the formula does not smudge or flake after drying. 

 

2

Best Natural Finish

gaya WONDERS mascara

Buy on Amazon

By leveraging the buildable formula of this mascara by Gaya, you can give a volumized appearance to your lashes that will magically spruce up your entire look. And, unlike other cheap formulas that leave a clumpy residue on your lashes, this product gives a beautiful, natural-looking finish. Furthermore, what makes the product one of the best mascaras for sensitive eyes is that it is formulated with gentle botanical extracts such as carnauba wax, camellia oil, and castor oil, that don’t trigger irritation. Besides, these ingredients promote the growth of your lashes to give them a dramatic length. 

 

3

Most Pocket-friendly

Tetyana 4D SILK FIBER EYELASH MASCARA

Buy on Amazon

For thicker, and fuller eyelashes, get your hands on this waterproof mascara for sensitive eyes by Tetyana. The product employs the fine and intricate bristles of its applicator wand for accentuating your eyes in a jiffy. This is one of those mascaras that you can wear at the gym, for outdoor cardio or when traveling long distances and stay rest assured that it will not melt away with your sweat. Also, the dense, richly pigmented formula of this product gives the illusion of kohl-lined eyes which we absolutely love! 

 

4

Best Lasting Power

LGSZGDCN Mascara

Buy on Amazon

This brown hypoallergenic mascara is perfect for natural no-makeup makeup looks and for people with light-colored hair. Owing to the thin formula of the product, your lashes don’t get a clumpy appearance and the application becomes effortlessly smooth. Moreover, the conically-sculpted fiber brush allows you to apply the product efficiently and evenly, from the inner to the outer corners of your eyes. Besides, you cannot get enough of the adorable cat design of the container of this mascara.

 

5

Best for Volumizing

ALMAY Thickening Mascara

Buy on Amazon

You are unlikely to find a more pocket-friendly mascara for your dry, sensitive eyes with a plethora of benefits than this one by Almay. Formulated with aloe extracts, urea, and carnauba wax, the product moisturizes your lashes and goes on smoothly for effortless application. In addition, the product is rich in vitamins A, B5, C, and E that protect your lash area from external aggressors. And, you don’t have to carry this along in your bag as the product lasts almost all day after applying. 

 

6

BOOM! BY CINDY JOSEPH BRIGHT MASCARA

Buy on Amazon

If you have short and fine lashes, then this hypoallergenic mascara will enhance their appearance by adding dramatic lengths. And, the ergonomic applicator of this product will help you apply the product efficiently and evenly, without smearing the excess on your skin. To be noted, Boom! Bright mascara comes in a unique, squeezable tube that allows you to eventually use up all the product in it, so nothing gets wasted. Furthermore, the clean, moisturizing ingredients infused in it ensure that the product doesn’t cause irritation to your eyes. 

 

7

FIFTH & SKIN Mineral Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Over 90% of the ingredients in this mascara are naturally-derived and GMO-free, so you can trust that it won’t irritate your eyes or cause redness. It is rich in fatty acids from olive oil, jojoba oil, and sunflower oil which gives the product a silky consistency for effortless application. Moreover, the formula is gentle for contact lens wearers and people with dry eyes and inflamed eyelids. While the product won’t melt away with sweat, moisture, or tears, you can take it off with splashes of water and a mild cleanser in absence of a makeup remover. 

 

8

COVERGIRL LASH BLAST VOLUME WATERPROOF MASCARA

Buy on Amazon

For dramatically bold lashes, get your hands on this waterproof mascara by Covergirl. The formula is sublimely volumizing, which makes it ideal to use as a standalone eye makeup product. And, unlike most thickening mascaras, the formula of this product is not too goopy or clumpy. It holds your lashes up firmly and makes your eyes look awake and brightened. To top off, this product contains enough quantity to last you for a long time. 

 

9

ALMAY Length & Lift Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Unlike other lengthening mascaras that give a mere illusion of longer lashes, this product by Almay promotes the healthy growth of your lashes to make them long naturally. It does so owing to its unique lash-caring complex, composed of botanically derived waxes and conditioners that boost nourishment. While the formula contains such ingredients, it is free from irritating contents such as phthalates, mineral oil, hydantoin, triclosan, etc., making it a great mascara for sensitive eyes. 

 

10

PHYSICIANS FORMULA ROSÉ ALL DAY MASCARA

Buy on Amazon

Infused with invigorating extracts such as rose water, Kakadu plum, and goji berry, this hypoallergenic mascara not only beautifies but also awakens your eyes by giving a lift to your lashes. Unlike other products that cause your eye area to inflame, this mascara soothes it and moisturizes your lashes — an excellent choice of mascara for sensitive eyes. Besides, the formula is highly pigmented, so you don’t have to apply too many layers, thereby ensuring that your lashes don’t look too clumpy or made up. 

 

11

prime causemetics primelash lengthening & volumizing mascara

Buy on Amazon

This volumizing mascara by Prime Causemetics can give a stunning, kohl-lined finish to your lashes to enhance the natural beauty of your eyes. Enriched with squalene and candelilla wax, the formula goes on smoothly over your lashes and works like a growth booster for them. Moreover, its silky consistency ensures that no pigment globs precipitate over your lashes or give an unflatteringly artificial look to them. And, the ergonomic applicator of the product works in harmony with the formula to achieve flawless results. 

 

12

w7 OH SO Sensitive HYPOALLERGENIC MASCARA

Buy on Amazon

Owing to the gentle ingredients in it, the cruelty-free formula of this mascara is also less cruel to your eyes compared to others, making it a good mascara for sensitive eyes and skin. It has a buttery-smooth formula that allows it to glide smoothly over your lashes without leaving any globs or residues. In addition, without giving an artificial look to your makeup, the product makes your eyes pop by lifting your lashes — an ideal choice for everyday makeup. 

 

13

MARCELLE ULTIMATE Lash Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Forget about clumping your lashes with this sensitive eye mascara by Marcelle. The formula goes on smoothly over your lashes, which makes the application process efficient and effortless. Moreover, the dark brown pigments infused in this mascara make it an ideal choice for people with light skin and hair as it gives a natural look. Hence, you can count on this product to primp up your appearance for everyday affairs. 

 

Here are a few factors to consider when looking for a hypoallergenic mascara:

Labels: While many products claim to be non-irritant, always look for explicit labels on the product, such as “hypoallergenic”, “allergy-tested”, and “ophthalmologically-tested” to be sure that the mascara you’re investing in is safe for use. 

Formulation: Allergies or side effects are often triggered when a makeup product contains too many filler ingredients that do not offer any specific nourishing, coloring, setting, or emulsifying properties. To avoid reactions from such substances, always look for a lean ingredient list on the packaging of the mascara before making an investment. Also, botanically-derived ingredients and mild conditioning agents such as squalene, candelilla wax, panthenol, tocopherol, ascorbyl palmitate, etc. should be prioritized as they nourish your lashes and promote healthy growth. 

Application: No one wants a clumpy residue on their lashes. This is why give priority to mascaras with a silky consistency that goes on smoothly over your lashes. Unless you are extremely skilled with makeup, you cannot stop thick formulations from leaving an unflattering residue on your lashes, and hence, you should avoid it. Also, while this is not a necessary feature, give a preference to products with an ergonomic applicator brush to prevent accidental smears on your skin. 

Conclusion:

So there you have it! The above-mentioned products are some of the best hypoallergenic mascaras you can find out there that are safe and gentle on sensitive skin around the eyes. To find your best pick, refer to our buying guide and check the ingredients list of the product carefully. Drop the product if you find any ingredient that you’re allergic to. Hypoallergenic mascaras are not too different from regular mascaras, except for the fact that they are less likely to irritate your eyes or skin. So, when investing in one, keep all the factors in mind that you would consider when looking for a regular mascara. Happy shopping!