I switched to clean mascaras because I became increasingly conscious of the ingredients in my beauty products. Concerned about potential harm from chemicals like parabens and sulfates, I sought alternatives that aligned with my values of health and sustainability. Thus, I embarked on curating the best clean mascaras to ensure I could maintain my beauty routine without compromising my well-being or the environment.

Curating the best clean mascaras involved meticulous research and testing. I scrutinized ingredient lists, seeking natural alternatives and avoiding harmful additives. Certifications such as USDA Organic and cruelty-free logos guided my selections, ensuring ethical sourcing and animal welfare. I considered performance factors like lengthening, volumizing, and smudge resistance, ensuring these mascaras met or exceeded the standards of conventional options.

I recommend using the best clean mascaras because they offer a guilt-free beauty experience. Not only do they enhance the lashes effectively, but they also prioritize health and sustainability. By opting for clean mascaras, users can avoid potential irritants and support brands committed to ethical practices. These non-toxic mascaras provide peace of mind, knowing that they contribute positively to personal well-being and environmental conservation, making them an essential addition to any beauty routine.

• 1
  Most Long-lasting

  Honest Beauty 2-in-1 Extreme Length Clean Mascara

  Buy on Amazon

This innovative formula, EWG Verified, and cruelty-free, ensures both lengthening and volumizing effects in one sleek package. With its dual-action design, the primer nourishes and strengthens lashes from root to tip, while the mascara coats each lash for intense definition and drama. Achieve bold, fluttery lashes without compromise, as the clean ingredients ensure gentle application suitable for even the most sensitive eyes. The rich black hue enhances natural beauty, framing the eyes with striking intensity. 

Key ingredients: Jojoba esters

Color: Black

Size: .27 fl oz

2

Best Recyclable Packaging

COVERGIRL Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Boasting a clean formula, this mascara from Covergirl ensures your lashes receive only the best ingredients for a flawless finish. The rich, intense black pigment coats each lash from root to tip, amplifying volume and length for a dramatic look that lasts all day. Its innovative brush design effortlessly separates and lifts lashes, creating a bold and eye-catching effect. With it, achieve glamorous lashes with ease, knowing you're using a product that cares for both your beauty and your well-being.

Key ingredients: Coconut milk and aloe extracts

Color: Black

Size: 0.44 fl oz.

Quick Tip:

For maximum impact, wiggle the wand at the base of your lashes and sweep upward for instant volume and definition.

3

Most Lightweight

ILIA - Limitless Lash Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Crafted with a commitment to non-toxic ingredients and cruelty-free practices, this mascara delivers stunning results without compromise. The innovative formula lengthens, volumizes, and defines lashes with precision, giving you limitless possibilities for your look. Its jet-black shade, After Midnight Black, enhances your natural beauty with an intense color payoff that lasts all day. The sleek wand effortlessly coats each lash from root to tip, ensuring even application and dramatic impact. Whether you're going for a natural everyday mascara look or a bold evening statement, ILIA's Limitless Lash Mascara is your go-to choice for clean, high-performance beauty. 

Key ingredients: Arginine, organic shea butter, beeswax, and carnauba wax

Color: Black

Size: 0.28 fl oz.

4

Most Nourishing Formula

Pacifica Beauty, Vegan Collagen Lash Serum & Clear Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Infused with conditioning vitamins E and B, this innovative formula promotes lash health while providing the perfect base for your mascara application. The vegan collagen serum strengthens and volumizes lashes, helping them appear fuller and more feathery with every use. As a clear mascara primer, it ensures effortless application and long-lasting wear, keeping your lashes looking flawless all day. Whether you're aiming for a subtle everyday look or dramatic evening glam, Pacifica Beauty's dual-action serum and primer deliver results you can trust.

Key ingredients: Aqua, copernicia cerifera (carnauba) wax, stearic acid

Color: Black

Size: Not mentioned

5

Best Budget-friendly Mascara

Half Caked Totally Tubular Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Crafted with clean ingredients, Half Caked's mascara reflects its dedication to sustainability and uncompromising performance. The flake-free and smudge-free formula ensures a flawless look that lasts all day while remaining gentle on your lashes. Plus, it's easy to remove, making your nightly routine a breeze. Whether you're aiming for a subtle, everyday elegance or a bold, glamorous statement, Half Caked's Totally Tubular Mascara delivers. 

Color: Black

Size: 8.5 ml

6

Best Non-flaking Formula

DIME Beauty Volume Mascara

Buy on Amazon

This black mascara is formulated with gentle ingredients, making it suitable even for those with sensitive eyes. DIME Beauty prioritizes clean formulations, ensuring that their mascara delivers stunning results without compromising on safety or efficacy. The volumizing formula coats each lash from root to tip, providing instant lift, shine and definition without clumping or flaking. Whether you're aiming for a natural everyday mascara look or a bold statement, this non-toxic mascara delivers versatile results that last all day. 

Key ingredients: Theobroma cacao extract, squalane, and panthothenic acid

Color: Black

Size: 0.28 fl oz.

Quick Tip:

Before applying mascara, gently wiggle the wand at the base of your lashes and then sweep upward for maximum volume and separation.

7

Most Moisturizing

Ere Perez - Natural Avocado Waterproof Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Formulated with nourishing avocado oil, this mascara not only enhances your lashes but also cares for them. The waterproof formula ensures long-lasting wear, making it perfect for any occasion, from busy days to special events. Ere Perez's commitment to clean beauty shines through in this mascara, which is free from harmful chemicals and harsh ingredients. Its gentle formula is suitable for even the most sensitive eyes, providing voluminous and lengthened lashes without irritation. Whether you're seeking a natural everyday look or a bold statement, this mascara delivers versatile results.

Key ingredients: Avocado oil

Color: Black

Size: 0.35 fl oz.

8

Best Non-irritating Formula

Kosas The Big Clean Mascara

Buy on Amazon

This mascara is a testament to Kosas' commitment to clean, high-performance cosmetics. Its innovative formula coats each lash with precision, providing length, volume, and definition without clumping or smudging. The intense black pigment enhances the natural beauty of your lashes, creating a striking look that lasts all day. Whether you're going for a subtle, everyday elegance or a bold, statement-making effect, The Big Clean Mascara delivers.

Key ingredients: Castor oil, provitamin B5, biotinoyl tripeptide-1, and plant-based sugars.

Color: Black

Size: Not mentioned

9

Best Water-resistant Formula

SWEED - Lash Lift Mascara

Buy on Amazon

Crafted with clean ingredients, SWEED's mascara reflects their dedication to sustainability and uncompromising performance. The lightweight formula lifts and lengthens lashes, providing a natural-looking yet impactful result without clumping or flaking. Its gentle formulation is suitable for even the most sensitive eyes, ensuring comfortable wear throughout the day. Whether you're aiming for a subtle, everyday elegance or a bold, glamorous statement, SWEED's Lash Lift Mascara delivers. 

Key ingredients: Not mentioned

Color: Black

Size: 0.27 fl oz.

10

Best Sweat-proof Formula

The G.O.A.T Waterproof Mascara

Buy on Amazon

This revolutionary mascara stands as a testament to sustainability, boasting smudge-proof and sweatproof properties that ensure your look lasts all day. Infused with peptides and hyaluronic acid, it not only volumizes and amplifies your lashes but also nourishes and hydrates them, promoting lash health with every application. The rich black pigment delivers an intense color payoff, enhancing the natural beauty of your lashes with ease. Whether you're facing rain, sweat, or tears, The G.O.A.T Waterproof Mascara keeps up, providing you with flawless lashes in any situation. 

Key ingredients: Peptides and hyaluronic acid

Color: Black

Size: 9.1 ml

11

ROEN - Natural CAKE Mascara

Buy on Amazon

This vegan and cruelty-free mascara redefines your lash game with its innovative formula and sustainable ethos. Crafted with clean ingredients, ROEN's mascara is a testament to its commitment to both environmental responsibility and uncompromising performance. The creamy texture coats lashes evenly, providing both length and volume without clumping or flaking. Its rich pigment enhances the natural beauty of your lashes, giving you a captivating look that lasts all day. Whether you're going for a subtle, everyday elegance or a bold, glamorous statement, ROEN's Natural CAKE Mascara delivers. 

Key ingredients: Aqua (Water/Eau), iron oxide, helianthus annuus (Sunflower) seed wax

Color: Black

Size: 0.34 fl oz.

Now that you have seen my product recommendations for the best clean mascaras, glance through my buying guide to make an informed purchase.

When looking for a clean mascara, consider the following factors:

Ingredients: Look for mascaras that are free from harmful chemicals such as parabens, phthalates, sulfates, and synthetic fragrances. Instead, opt for products with natural and non-toxic ingredients such as plant-based waxes, oils, and pigments.

Certifications: Check for certifications such as USDA Organic, COSMOS Organic, or EWG Verified, which indicate that the product meets certain standards for cleanliness and safety.

Hypoallergenic: If you have sensitive eyes or skin, choose a mascara that is hypoallergenic and free from common allergens.

Cruelty-free: Ensure that the mascara is cruelty-free and not tested on animals. Look for certifications such as Leaping Bunny or PETA's cruelty-free logo.

Packaging: Consider the packaging of the mascara. Look for products that come in recyclable or biodegradable packaging to minimize environmental impact.

Performance: Despite being clean, the mascara should still perform well in terms of providing length, volume, and definition to your lashes. Look for reviews or try sample sizes to assess performance.

Water Resistance: Depending on your preferences, you may want to choose a water-resistant or waterproof formula. Look for natural alternatives to traditional waterproof ingredients like synthetic polymers.

Brand Transparency: Choose brands that are transparent about their sourcing and manufacturing processes. Look for companies that prioritize sustainability and ethical practices.

Price: Clean mascaras can vary in price, so consider your budget when making a purchase. Some clean beauty brands offer affordable options without compromising on quality.

By considering these factors, you can find a clean mascara that aligns with your values and meets your beauty needs.

• Apply clear mascara to your lashes for a natural, defined look without adding color. Clear mascara can help separate and lengthen lashes without the need for pigmented formulas.
• Use clear mascara as a primer before applying colored mascara. Applying a coat of clear mascara first can help to separate and lift your lashes, making it easier to apply colored mascara evenly.
• Clear mascara can double up as a brow gel to groom and tame unruly eyebrows. Use a clean mascara wand to brush the clear mascara through your brows, shaping them and keeping them in place throughout the day.
• Keep a wand of clear mascara on hand to quickly fix any mascara smudges or mistakes. The clear formula can help to clean up any excess mascara without smudging or smearing your makeup.
• Clear mascara is perfect for achieving a natural makeup look. Apply a coat of clear mascara to your lashes and brows for a subtle enhancement that enhances your natural beauty without looking too heavy or dramatic.
• Layer clear mascara over colored mascara to add shine and dimension to your lashes. This can help to intensify the color of your mascara and give your lashes a glossy finish.
• Use clear mascara on your bottom lashes for a subtle, defined look. The clear formula will help to separate and lengthen your bottom lashes without adding too much volume or color.
• Mix a small amount of loose eyeshadow or pigment with clear mascara to create your own custom-tinted mascara. This allows you to experiment with different colors while still enjoying the benefits of a clear formula.