Who Is Payton Riley? Contestant Asked To 'Come Back In 3 Years' By Katy Perry Dubbed 'Next Taylor Swift' By American Idol Fans

Teen contestant Payton Riley, dubbed by fans as the next Taylor Swift, receives mixed feedback from judges on American Idol.

Published on Mar 18, 2024  |  10:51 AM IST |  57.7K
Payton Riley (Youtube/American Idol)
Payton Riley (Youtube/American Idol)

On the latest episode of American Idol, 15-year-old Payton Riley from Texas captured the attention of fans and judges alike with her original song "Fireflies" and emotional performance. Despite being likened to Taylor Swift by fans, Payton faced a surprising setback as judge Katy Perry advised her to wait three years before returning to the competition.

Payton's Performance and Judges' Feedback

In her audition, Payton delivered a heartfelt rendition of her self-penned breakup tune "Fireflies," showcasing her Christian-Country-Pop style. The song resonated with audiences, drawing comparisons to Taylor Swift's signature storytelling style. However, while Katy Perry and Lionel Richie commended her talent, they ultimately decided to hold back her advancement, citing her age and need for further maturity. “It’s just because you’re in the growing phase, and I would hate to pull you out prematurely,” Perry said. “I’d say try it in three years, at 18, and you’d have a real shot.”


Fan Reactions and Backlash

Despite the judges' decision, American Idol viewers took to social media to express their support for Payton, applauding her raw talent and emotional depth. Many disagreed with Katy Perry's assessment, arguing that Payton's performance deserved more recognition and a chance to shine on the Idol stage. The backlash against Perry's critique highlights the passionate fan base rallying behind the young contestant.

Advertisement

As Payton Riley's journey on American Idol takes an unexpected turn, her story resonates with fans who see her as a promising talent reminiscent of Taylor Swift. While Katy Perry's advice may have postponed her Hollywood dreams for now, the overwhelming support from viewers suggests that Payton's star is still on the rise, leaving the door open for a triumphant return in the future.

ALSO READ: Why Did John Legend Call His Fellow The Voice Coaches 'Unhelpful' After Battles Round Performance? Find Out

Advertisement
Pinkvilla Pulse
Subscribe to our newsletter for entertainment exclusives, star interviews, and the latest lifestyle trends. Look No Further!
Subscribe
About The Author

Suhasini is a budding writer with two years of experience under her belt. She has a passion for

...

Advertisement

Latest Articles